5 ms·
Disclosure: I work on Google Cloud (and launched Preemptible VMs). Cool! Like you, I wish people would make productive use of spare cycles. Can I suggest you
by boulos 9y ago
Disclosure: I work on Google Cloud (and launched Preemptible VMs).
Cool! Like you, I wish people would make productive use of spare cycles.
Can I suggest you add a note comparing this to BOINC/gridcoin as well? I think your marketplace is a better idea, but because of the security implications dgacmu pointed out downthread, it shouldn’t be treated lightly.
Also, I really like your white paper (https://vectordash.com/primer https://vectordash.com/primer) as it’s nicely formatted and has pretty icons. I think you should update the comparisons to the cloud providers though. Comparing a Pascal-series (1080 Ti) part to a Kepler part (K80) isn’t particularly fair, as NVIDIA charges about the same for that part as the later P100s and V100s. That is, people should be comparing what the best price/performance ratio is, and all three providers have better options. There’s a secondary question about whether the right comparison is to AWS Spot / Preemptible VMs / Low Priority VMs, but I’m not sure from a quick skim what the likely preemption rate will be with your setup.
Finally, let me echo dgacmu in saying it’s too bad that NVIDIA forces all providers to only provide the expensive parts. The best price/performance is certainly the consumer parts (that 1080 Ti compares favorably to a P100 at a fraction of the cost), but both the EULA and otherwise prevent it. You’re not running a direct service / providing things in a data center which is a cool workaround! But you should definitely be more clear about the risks of letting untrusted third-party code to execute against your GPU.
Again, great project!
- navinsylvester 9y agoWe at Gridmarkets have cracked this one(spare cycles) and are now further enhancing the model.
- noir_lord 9y agoYou should elaborate when you say stuff like this otherwise some people will assume you are just advertising.
- largote 9y agoThat's a nice word-salad you got there.
- mykull 9y agoTalking to VCs will do this to a person. I dont know why they can't just speak normal English, but spewing marketese seems to be a rite of passage.
- tgtweak 9y agoWhats the cheapest hourly for a pre-emptive P100 instance?
- maxmcd 9y agohttps://cloud.google.com/products/calculator/#id=fb75f2cf-3f02-4b7f-ab7b-d79d3003901a https://cloud.google.com/products/calculator/#id=fb75f2cf-3f... $533/mo
- bhouston 9y agoAnd a NVIDIA GeForce 1080 TI is roughly $1000 USD right now (and should be $800 if cryptocurrency wasn't inflating the prices): https://pcpartpicker.com/products/video-card/#c=390&sort=price&page=1 https://pcpartpicker.com/products/video-card/#c=390&sort=pri... Cloud computing is so ridiculously expensive for GPUs.
- davewasthere 9y agoMy concern is this would be a great vector for some form of State-sponsored deployment of a sneaky rootkit which is then embedded in everyone's GPU. That said, I'd much prefer to see GPU cycles (and power usage) going towards scientific endeavors rather than the current crypto-mining boom.