4 ms·
> As of March, Uber was struggling to meet its target of 13 miles per “intervention” in Arizona To be fair, Uber is not necessarily acting badly -- especially
by danso 9y ago
> As of March, Uber was struggling to meet its target of 13 miles per “intervention” in Arizona
To be fair, Uber is not necessarily acting badly -- especially since AZ doesn't appear to care either way -- having the safety driver is ostensibly supposed to make the AV at least as safe as if it were a regular human-driven car. I hope during the investigation we find out whether Uber made it clear to its human drivers that they had to be at least as alert as if they were driving a normal car.
- johnmaguire2013 9y agoAs a human driver, when do you know to take control of the vehicle and start stopping? At 100 feet? 200 feet? 300 feet (a football field?) A quick Google[1] suggests the average stopping distance of a human traveling 35mph is 95 feet (including reaction time.) The promise of autonomous is 60 feet. If the human decides to stop at 60 feet, it's too late. If they stop before that, how do they know if the vehicle is working properly? 1. http://www.brakingdistances.com/35Mph http://www.brakingdistances.com/35Mph
- MarkMc 9y agoI suspect this is simply asking too much of human driver. The human brain is not wired to be constantly alert without any ongoing stimulus. If someone else is doing the cognitive load, it is extremely difficult not too get bored and 'drift off'.
- kalleboo 9y agoThe article says that Uber instructed their drivers to hover their hands over the wheel in order to be able to take over at a moments notice. But they also supplied an iPad app to report issues, that some safety drivers used while in motion (others were cited as using it at red lights)
- galdosdi 9y agoThe hovering hand thing weirded me the hell out. You'd get terrible RSI if you actually did that all day. Try it.
- chrismcb 9y agoIt is pretty much impossible to be "at least as alert as if they were driving..." When you aren't actually driving. And yes Uber is acting badly. Just because Arizona let them do it, didn't mean they have to do it. Of course, I believe Arizona also acted poorly.