4 ms·

Ask HN: What's up with this accusation of HN censorship? (blog.nodejitsu.com)

11 points by c1sc0 16y ago

I just saw this popup after following a link to nodejitsu from HN, how much of his claims are true? --- hello, i see you are coming from hacker news. the article you clicked on was most certainly not submitted by nodejitsu. news.ycombinator has a long history of squashing articles and submitters that aren't funded by y-comb. most of this is done through their "silent" banning and censoring mechanisms, that leave people not even realizing they have been silenced. i hope you enjoy this article, and remember that HN is extremely biased and that you should keep your horizons broad. ---

maxklein 16y ago
I doubt that HN censors people they disagree with. I've written many things that one could say are anti YC or anti-YC companies, and I have never been censored or had anyone email me telling to not do this. Several other people also who say 'anti-YC' things have been active on this site for years.
- deleted 16y ago
  [deleted]
- TeHCrAzY 16y ago
  A prime example would be many of the negative comments regarding scribd.
_delirium 16y ago
there's a bit of discussion in that link's comments: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1665999 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1665999
pietrofmaggi 16y ago
So, you read this on a page you reached from an HN post... Well, if HN do some censorship I think that they have to fire who checked this link ;-)
c1sc0 16y ago
I posted this because I was wondering if it was a new not-so-clever strategy to stir up a little controversy & pageviews.
losethos 16y ago
I wore-out my welcome, I know. It's their site. Downvoting leads to monoculture as people vote against things they disagree with. Linux people can ban anybody against Linux and most of these sites are full of Linux people. Atheiest, too. No surprise. That part, I understand, but the broader question of my reality is questionable -- 6000 downloads and only 3 emails in 3 years, all of which from fake people. No suprise, considering all the other unusual aspects of my reality.
proexploit 16y ago
I think that idea may come about because every YC launch or development usually hits front page and gets coverage while some others do not. This is fair. I believe it's the user's voting that appears to "game" the system, not anything unethical. A lot of people here have applied to YC or at least have a favorable opinion of it. We are on news.ycombinator.com after all, not hackernews.com. Some others who don't have as many natural followers will find their submissions less popular? Quite honestly, I'd find it fair if posts that were anti-YC were quashed but I've seen enough I dont think that could possibly be the case.
binomial 16y ago
They all got perma-banned I believe, hence the popup.

11 points by c1sc0 16y ago

maxklein 16y ago

I doubt that HN censors people they disagree with. I've written many things that one could say are anti YC or anti-YC companies, and I have never been censored or had anyone email me telling to not do this. Several other people also who say 'anti-YC' things have been active on this site for years.

deleted 16y ago
[deleted]
TeHCrAzY 16y ago
A prime example would be many of the negative comments regarding scribd.

_delirium 16y ago

there's a bit of discussion in that link's comments: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1665999 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1665999

pietrofmaggi 16y ago

So, you read this on a page you reached from an HN post... Well, if HN do some censorship I think that they have to fire who checked this link ;-)

c1sc0 16y ago

I posted this because I was wondering if it was a new not-so-clever strategy to stir up a little controversy & pageviews.

losethos 16y ago

I wore-out my welcome, I know. It's their site. Downvoting leads to monoculture as people vote against things they disagree with. Linux people can ban anybody against Linux and most of these sites are full of Linux people. Atheiest, too. No surprise. That part, I understand, but the broader question of my reality is questionable -- 6000 downloads and only 3 emails in 3 years, all of which from fake people. No suprise, considering all the other unusual aspects of my reality.

proexploit 16y ago

I think that idea may come about because every YC launch or development usually hits front page and gets coverage while some others do not. This is fair. I believe it's the user's voting that appears to "game" the system, not anything unethical. A lot of people here have applied to YC or at least have a favorable opinion of it. We are on news.ycombinator.com after all, not hackernews.com. Some others who don't have as many natural followers will find their submissions less popular? Quite honestly, I'd find it fair if posts that were anti-YC were quashed but I've seen enough I dont think that could possibly be the case.

binomial 16y ago

They all got perma-banned I believe, hence the popup.