9 ms·
The Best Alternative for Every Facebook Feature
- skrowl 9y agoThe younger generation is more IM focused than social network app focused. InstaGram / SnapChat / etc are going to do to Facebook what Reddit did to Digg.
- Larrikin 9y agoMaybe AIM will decide to come back online with new branding
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mcgarnagle 9y agowe want MSN! (bat_emoji)
- GyYZTfWBfQw 9y agoHaha, how about XMPP, using Gajim? Good times!
- GyYZTfWBfQw 9y agoYeah, but Facebook Lite and Messenger are both Facebook's IM app. Personally, I would use Wire. https://wire.com https://wire.com (https://github.com/wireapp https://github.com/wireapp)
- Sytten 9y agoAll this rage around Facebook makes me wonder if it would be a good time to start an open source social media. It seems to me that Facebook is the new Microsoft and we need a "GNU/Linux" to oppose it. The best would be a decentralized system for sure, but it is hard to be as good as Facebook/other social network with full decentralization. Food for thoughts...
- freehunter 9y agoSo... Mastodon?
- Sytten 9y agoI didn't know about it, but to me it seems more like a twitter than a facebook with friends, groups, feed from your friends, etc.
- 18pfsmt 9y agoActually, Mastodon can be set up on your own hardware, with only people you know IRL and be exactly a feed from your friends. You can disable the federation if you want as well.
- rndmind 9y agoThe approach is usually a federated system using an open-source platform. Less people using these services, however, in general the content quality is way higher and less political. Current For-Users-By-Users platforms I use are: GNU Social, D*, peertube ( in alpha stages ... )
- Jedd 9y agoDiaspora was meant to be it - launched in 2010 it had one million users by 2014 (according to the wikipedia page). I can't find numbers for current active user counts, but it didn't win much mindshare, by any measure. FreedomBox was being pushed heavily by Eben Moglen and Bdale Garbee (I saw them doing a FOSDEM presentation on this back in 2011) but it was more about the hardware platform (to support a free software social network suite) but it's also not really very popular, unfortunately. Mastodon, as freehunter notes, is well known, but only in niche circles - and seems to be positioning itself as a twitter-alike only. Searches for 'free software social network' will return a huge list of projects, but even for the most popular <sic>, federated, relatively painless to setup & maintain (or with paid hosted options available) systems ... the network effect combined with most people's inertia / apathy / ignorance means we're not going to be ridding the world of FB any time soon.
- 9y ago
- Y_Y 9y agoI wish there was one good messenger. Signal can't be it, because not federated, uses phone number. Riot can't be it because network effects. Google and facebook are abominable. WhatsApp and telegram are worse versions of signal. Who will save us from this efficient market competition? (a previous version of this comment incorrectly claimed signal was closed-source)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- mtreis86 9y agoI thought signal was open source? "Signal is developed by a software group called Open Whisper Systems.[123] The group is funded by a combination of donations and grants,[124] and all of its products are published as free and open-source software." -wiki
- asdsa5325 9y agoSignal is open source? https://github.com/signalapp https://github.com/signalapp
- Y_Y 9y agoJust having a GitHub doesn't make you open-source. All the same it looks like I was wrong, and they are open now. They previously required clsed-source components for voice and video afaik.
- Jedd 9y ago> Riot can't be it because network effects. You seem to be listing different criteria for each of the reasons you dismiss the various alternatives -- the reason against Riot / Matrix is not at all like the other (reasons), and is a bit self-defeating.
- Y_Y 9y agoI love Riot, and I''d be delighted for it to become popular. I'd also be shocked. They don't have the media-savvy or corporate power I suppose.
- iuguy 9y agoSomehow they managed to miss the point that it's the handing over of information to these services that is the thing giving them power. Instead of Paperless post, how about Framadate? No love for Nextcloud? Diaspora? Mastodon?
- Kalium 9y agoYou're right! They did miss the larger point about centralization. With that said, is it perhaps possible that they're writing for a more general audience that isn't particularly interested in the overhead that comes with administration and decentralized platforms? People want one, simple, clear, drop-in replacement for a given use. They want it to be one that's as easy to use as possible and trivially easy to get their friends to use. Most of all, people want to use something their friends are already using. Isolated, un-federated systems that require some level of technical skill (i.e., my late-90s grandma can't figure out in two minutes) to use are a hard sell.
- iuguy 9y agoOk, start here: * Nextcloud - https://nextcloud.com/providers/ https://nextcloud.com/providers/ * Diaspora - https://bitnami.com/stack/diaspora https://bitnami.com/stack/diaspora (not that you need to host, see https://diasporafoundation.org/#get_started https://diasporafoundation.org/#get_started) * Mastodon - https://masto.host/ https://masto.host/ (again, like diaspora hosting isn't needed, see http://joinmastodon.org/ http://joinmastodon.org/) Of the above, only Nextcloud generally needs some sort of hosting (which is reasonable given what it does), but there are plenty of low overhead options. It's not expected that normal people host their own Diaspora or Mastodon instances, there are plenty of open instances for people to choose from.
- koboll 9y agoThey missed the point with the Events alternatives. The problem isn't creating/inviting; you can do that with email. Facebook is great at finding events, and there aren't any competitors that have anything close to their reach.
- andrewl 9y agoMaybe we'd all have been better off on Google Plus. I avoid giving Google information about myself that it doesn't need, but I do trust them more than I trust Facebook. Although maybe that's naive of me.
- username223 9y ago> Maybe we'd all have been better off on Google Plus. Haha, probably not. G+ enforced a "real names" policy, then tried to merge accounts across search, YouTube, etc. It's the same Panopticon, though slightly less amoral. If we want to solve this, we need to make it easier for non-tech people to decentralize their data. Distributed communication was solved long ago: email (private 1-1), mailing lists (private many-many), weblogs (public 1-many), Usenet (public many-many). All of this can be self-hosted, or hosted on a shared server for a few $/mo, i.e. less than 10% of your phone bill. Since that will never happen, the least-bad way to do this is to silo your online activity among separate entities and identities.
- limeblack 9y ago> You can sync the app to other social networks you might use, like Twitter and LinkedIn LinkedIn is in my experience is as bad as FB. I really can't take anyone seriously that is recommending syncing with it. It uploaded my friends contacts which I did not want.
- Jaruzel 9y agoI had a bunch of legacy contacts inside my hotmail account that I hadn't touched in years. Shortly after MS took over LinkedIn, it started bugging me to add them all to my LinkedIn network, by listing them all on a special LinkedIn page and automatically ticking the checkbox on each one. Took ages for the penny to drop, as to where these contacts were coming from! Needless to say, my hotmail/outlook.com account now no longer has ANY contacts in it.
- hashkb 9y agoRemember that handful of friends who weren't on FB and so you hassled us to join for a while and then kind of lost touch? Many of us still have the same phone numbers.
- harel 9y agoReplacing functionality is the easy part. How do you replace volume of people using the system? Scandal or not - Facebook is still where "everyone is". And until "everyone" are not there, there is no "replacing" Facebook - just replacing some functional aspects of it. I use Facebook for one main purpose - to keep in touch with people around the world whom I know from different periods of my life. Unless all of them pack up and move to an alternative, leaving Facebook means leaving them.
- wolfgke 9y ago> Replacing functionality is the easy part. How do you replace volume of people using the system? Scandal or not - Facebook is still where "everyone is". I actually do know people who strongly prefer their friends not to have a Facebook account. So this is a feature and not a bug, since it is a strong opportunity to sort out to whom of the Facebook "friends" one really wants to stay in contact with. Or to give another argument why this is a feature and not a bug: About everybody who has used Facebook for a long time also has collected "friends" that one would love to drop from the friends list, but has not done for politeness. This is finally an opportunity to get rid of them in a much more socially accepted way.
- make3 9y agocome on you're a tiny minority, most people's friends are on Facebook
- wolfgke 9y ago> come on you're a tiny minority, most people's friends are on Facebook My impression is that this strongly depends on the social circle the respective person is. You first have to keep in mind that in Germany many people indeed use Facebook, but it is not not that deeply integrated into the life as it is my impression that it is the case in the US. Also in Germany it is often the case (at least in my impression) that people that come to some gathering explicitly say that don't desire that anybody puts some photors that were made of them on Facebebook. In this case: if I were living in the USA, I probably were in a tiny minority. I am also probably a minority in Germany, too, but it is not my impression that this minority is tiny.
- foxylad 9y agoAnother part of the puzzle is to return to blogging, for those totally public posts.
- aero142 9y agoAnd RSS feeds. I have a list of people who's opinion I trust after 10+ years of reading everything they write. I value their opinion on politics and economics rather than my aunt or some co-worker from two jobs ago.
- Mediterraneo10 9y agoThe problem with blogging in 2018 is that it can be difficult to actually draw readers to your blog unless you retain your Facebook and other social media accounts so that you can advertise your content there. The sheer amount of content out there means that even with SEO tweaks people might not find you through Google, you are simply lost in the noise. Even if people find you once through a search engine, the decline of RSS means that they are unlikely to subscribe to you and see what you write in future. I blog myself on a niche-interest topic, and I pride myself in writing substantial, specific and useful information. Unfortunately, my blog doesn’t get read by many people. And then you see lots of successful content farms out there, whose posts are actually devoid of content, but their empty posts are just packaged neatly to serve as clickbait and get advertising revenue. It is awfully dispiriting.
- anonu 9y agotldr; News Feed -> Nuzzel, Digg, Apple News Messenger -> Signal Events -> Paperless Post, Doodle Birthday Reminders -> Google Calendar, etc... Marketplace -> Nextdoor Groups -> GroupMe 3rd Party Logins -> 1Password, LastPass
- newsbinator 9y agoThat was pretty much the list before Facebook (or the popular version of it, anyway) existed too. It's not that people use Facebook because it's better than those tools, or worse than those tools, or even because it's an aggregate of those tools. They use it because all their friends/family/colleagues are there.
- naskwo 9y ago1) I'm missing photo sharing. www.famipix.com (2005) 2) What made Facebook interesting and addictive is the "variable reward" of small information snacks. The smaller the information snack is, the easier it is to produce (and consume). And the dumber society gets as a whole (Twitter)
- PrimoSync 9y agoFor Me: News Feed - Apple News, Feedly Groups - Reddit, BAND https://www.minicreo.com/itunes-alternative/best-facebook-alternative.html https://www.minicreo.com/itunes-alternative/best-facebook-al...
- SnowProblem 9y agoWhat about photo sharing and commenting?
- Nerdfest 9y agoGoogle Plus us quite popular with photographers.
- SomewhatLikely 9y agoRight? They leave out the feature Facebook was created for.
- sriku 9y agoSecure scuttlebutt (SSB) anyone? The core of all of these recommendations is that you need an identity online. It almost seems like if you solve the identity problem (like how various blockchains deal with it with addresses and wallets) you can get all the rest as easy follow ons. Mastodon still ties identity with a machine online much like email. Even SSB ties identity to your machine. Even what Sir T.B.L. is proposing - a "data pod" per person - seems to tie identity with a machine online. Are there no other solutions to this?
- DuskStar 9y agoIsn't that what keybase.io is for? Associating a single ID and trust graph across multiple accounts, devices and keys?
- psergeant 9y agoI feel like now — after the recent furore — is a great time to be on Facebook. They know they’re under the microscope for privacy issues, and have the time and treasure to find real solutions. Also, naive as it might be, I think Zuck genuinely cares and wants to fix what he’s broken. I am less inclined to trust any other service to get both security and intentions right.
- ahartmetz 9y agoYou got fooled much more often than twice.
- wousser 9y agoI’ve created a simple app for myself that lets me keep track of all my conversations, and it encourages me to keep in touch with all my friends, family, (ex)colleagues. If you like friendly contact reminders or like to recall what you talked about with friends whom you don’t meet every so often, give it a try. You can create your own timeline with conversations, photos, and other important things. As well as general background information. It can send you reminders to talk, and birthday reminders. The data is in your control, stays on your phone, is not synced. An internet connection is not required. Currently only for iOS: https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/social-contact-journal/id1186696582?ls=1&mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/social-contact-journal/id118...
- dandare 9y agoWhy nobody mentions the social connection functionality? To stay connected with my extended family, to be able to see their wedding pics and share my kids pics, there is no alternative to Facebook. I can not ask my elderly mom to start using something else on her precious ipad.
- reacharavindh 9y agoI wish there was GNUbook or something that is run by a non-profit organization like Wikipedia that provides a service that serves as a social ID(think like a portable phone number), and then let people use whichever "messaging service" they like by bringing their ID with them. This way the messaging services become replaceable and users a avoid the network lock-in.
- 0kto 9y agoSo [matrix] seems to fit the bill: federated network, bridges to other services (like IRC), encryption, you can write your own client or run your own server... [Matrix]: https://matrix.org/ https://matrix.org/
- beagle3 9y agoAlso hubzilla (nee red/matrix, unlrelated to matrix; descending from friendica which DID federate with Facebook and Twitter for a while, until FB & T closed off the federation API bridges)
- Broken_Hippo 9y agoThis article seems to miss a few things. I can do just fine without "news" from newsfeed. Their alternatives don't let me see pictures of, for example, my sister and brother's families. Random thoughts of people And so on. I'm sure my family would occasionally send me pictures, but it is hard to inconvenience everyone else. Not only that, but it would be more inconvenient for me. The main reason I joined facebook was because it was a simple way to keep in touch when moving overseas, after all. I can give updates and pictures without sending to so many people. Groups are a weird thing. I find things like Reddit to be a different sort of feel. Lastly: I think for a lot of people, alternatives need to be able to communicate with facebook and have be compatible in some ways. Right now, facebook is more akin to a phone company that only lets folks speak with others in the same network. If they would allow "friends" outside the network, allow public posts to be viewed by anyone, messenger coordinates with other messenger services, there would be more chance for folks to actually switch. In addition, more folks would switch to other services if there were an easy way for people to port some things to a new service: Profile information, pictures, and so on. Marketplace misses the point as well. I occasionally sell artwork, for example. I don't advertise or self promote much, but do keep up an art page. The sales I get are generally from facebook. There are a few social networks dedicated to artwork, but it definitely isn't the same. Someone else commented that facebook is great for finding events - I, too, use this. Sometimes the biggest problem with replacing messenger is that others still use messenger. My experience from pre-facebook times is that no, most people don't change for you. They simply talk to you less. Not having messenger on my phone (desktop only) causes some issues here and there as it is.
- alecco 9y ago> Right now, facebook is more akin to a phone company that only lets folks speak with others in the same network. If they would allow "friends" outside the network, allow public posts to be viewed by anyone, messenger coordinates with other messenger services, there would be more chance for folks to actually switch. In addition, more folks would switch to other services if there were an easy way for people to port some things to a new service: Profile information, pictures, and so on. I wonder if there is already legislation for this situation.
- superlopuh 9y agoSeems like a key missing piece is the "staying in touch with people" part. That's by far the biggest feature for me, once I've added someone on facebook, I know I can message/call them forever. No lost phone numbers/email addresses. If there was a network that automatically updated my contact for a person when they changed their phone number, I'd no longer have an excuse to stay on facebook at all.
- naskwo 9y agowww.famipix.com Online since 2005. 700k users. No ads. Free for schools and for private use up to 1000 photos.
- zerostar07 9y agosecond best.
- samstave 9y agoThe most insidious aspect of FB is their inference engine capability - that they can inherently track aspect of the activity of non FB users based on their relationships proximity and activity with those who do have FB accounts. Even if you choose to actively do no fb - they can still track you to a certain degree.
- beagle3 9y agoMost of that inference actually comes from the pervasive "like" buttons -- essentially all of the websites you use are happily and freely giving the information about you to facebook - who gladly correlate it across sites and with your shadow profiles. Your friends who uploaded their addressbooks and phonebooks to Facebook and WhatsApp are obviously helping to associate that data with a real identity, and by tagging you in pictures make it even more complete. But the vast majority of info Facebook has on you that YOU did not provide directly actually comes from the embedded Facebook bugs ("like buttons") all over the internet. And it's not surprising that the media doesn't mention it -- they rely on those bugs to get traffic, so they can't complain about it without taking it off, and they can't take it off without losing traffic.
- zombieprocesses 9y agoThe media pile on against facebook is reaching absurd proportions. And it's getting harder to distinguish between news and advocacy or journalism and propaganda. When a journalist is leading a #deletefacebook movement and when news is pushing alternative products over facebook does it cross a line from news/journalism/reporting to advocacy/advertisement/pay for play/etc? I hope one day we get to the bottom of what this is really about. Because it isn't about privacy or data protection. And the scale and scope of the facebook campaign is rather unsettling also. Maybe real journalists are out there and hopefully we can get some answers.
- GyYZTfWBfQw 9y agoSeems like a suitable alternative: https://www.minds.com https://www.minds.com Source code: https://github.com/Minds https://github.com/Minds
- vinceleo 9y ago> Scandal or not - Facebook is still where "everyone is". What about Elgg? https://elgg.org/ https://elgg.org/ Good point for starting your own 'Facebook'