2 ms·
I don't get why there have to be 401k and the various IRAs. There should be one system for all. Especially 401k is the same stupidity that employer based health
by maxxxxx 9y ago
I don't get why there have to be 401k and the various IRAs. There should be one system for all. Especially 401k is the same stupidity that employer based health insurance is. Instead of the individual choosing the best option the employer, whose interest is certainly not the same as the employee's, makes the choices.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoAt this point, I'm assuming it's because it gives larger employers an advantage and hence they lobby to prevent an even playing field.
- maxxxxx 9y agoIt's probably what you say and also a subsidy for capital management companies. They can force people to buy into high-fee funds.
- jogjayr 9y agoI would think that employers would be happy if they didn't need to manage 401K plans. It would be one less thing for them to do if employees just signed up for automatic IRA deductions with payroll and provided IRA account numbers in case of employer matching.
- lotsofpulp 9y agoIRA limits are $5k, 401k limit is $18k. Right now, smaller employers have higher per employee costs for administering 401k than bigger employers. I wouldn't be surprised if large employers were even compensated in some way for access to manage (collect fees) from all of the large employees' 401k funds.
- jogjayr 9y agoI meant replace 401Ks with IRAs wholecloth and raise the limit to $18k. Is it fair that some people are allowed to save (and deduct) $18k for their retirement while others are only allowed $5.5k?