3 ms·
> I wonder if he's familiar with the work of others who identify as classic liberals right now; my guess, given what I've seen of his writing, is that he'd dis
by dmix 9y ago
> I wonder if he's familiar with the work of others who identify as classic liberals right now; my guess, given what I've seen of his writing, is that he'd disagree with many of them pretty strenuously.
That's a silly reason to distance yourself from a legitimate ideology. A few newcomers cherry picking parts, bastardizing it, or misusing it should not be reason to abandon it. Especially if it's fundamentally sound.
For example, if Hitler adopted x socialist or capitalist policy that shouldn't be a reason to dismiss it simply because he held other awful views/ideologies. It should only be dismissed on the grounds that it directly contributed to something bad and had y outcome.
Dismissing ideas merely because some bad people happen to have embraced it as part of their wider ideology is anti-intellectual.
Not only that, but considering the above he shouldn't even have to defend claiming himself 'classically liberal' either, as it should be apparent to any unbiased mind what it is and what it isn't. The only ones who seek to blur that distinction tend to be politically motivated...