4 ms·
Google and Facebook employees: you have the power to influence what the companies you work for do.
by pmoriarty 9y ago
Google and Facebook employees: you have the power to influence what the companies you work for do.
- craftyguy 9y agopmoriarty: no you don't, not unless you are on the board or are a corporate officer. Having worked in a large tech company for quite a while now, grunts have very little (at best) influence on the decisions that upper management makes regarding where they sling their lawyers. In this time when you can be laid off for being "too old" or for other arbitrary reasons, you'll be removed/replaced for causing a stir.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pmoriarty 9y agoYou certainly do. First, you could just resign and choose not to participate in ongoing violations of privacy. By not giving them your help, you are already making a small difference. Second, you could threaten to resign because of this. Better, you could get together with others of like mind and threaten to resign en-masse. If enough people do this, upper management will take notice. It's just a matter of how many Google and Facebook employees have the will to do it. Third, when privacy issues come up, employees could try to influence their companies to err on the side of privacy. In companies this size there are always many situations which aren't guided by explicit policy or direction from on high, and where employees can use their own judgment or advocate for one course of action over the other. This is where people who care about privacy can make their voices heard. Finally, Google and Facebook employees are smart, creative people. They are more than capable of figuring out other ways they can make a difference -- if these issues are important to them. The main question is: are they? With all the media attention around Facebook and Google privacy violations it's becoming harder and harder for their employees to stand on the sidelines and claim ignorance or pretend there's nothing they can do. By not doing anything they are choosing to continue enabling these companies. They could act instead.
- craftyguy 9y agoFirst: You'll be replaced by someone who is either ignorant of the problem, or isn't but doesn't care. Second: You'll be replaced by someone who is either ignorant of the problem, or isn't but doesn't care. Third: Your complaints will fall on deaf ears and you'll be replaced by someone who is either ignorant of the problem, or isn't but doesn't care. The only way to reach companies of this size is by convincing their customers to go elsewhere. Throwing legislature at the problem might help, but it's unlikely that it will carry any teeth because of the lobby strength these companies possess.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"You'll be replaced by someone who is either ignorant of the problem, or isn't but doesn't care." It costs companies time and money to replace people. So you'll be hitting their bottom line just by resigning. They might not even be able to find someone to replace you, but if they do you might be replaced by someone who's not as effective. When you move somewhere else, you could help a competitor that respects privacy, or maybe even start your own privacy-respecting company.
- lainga 9y agoYes, and all of Google's employees could join the IWW and organize a wildcat strike, too, maybe with a holacracy instead of worker councils; so why don't they?
- pmoriarty 9y agoYou're conflating being a socialist with respecting privacy. Respect of privacy is an issue that cuts across the left/right divide. You could be a capitalist or communist, libertarian or socialist and still respect privacy. Organizing for change isn't limited to socialists either.
- lainga 9y agoI actually meant to conflate one unlikely action of mass coordination with another. I guess I shouldn't have been so flippant.
- confounded 9y agoYou can also devote the waking hours of the best years of your life to something else!
- xiphias 9y agoYou should look up a guy called ,,James Damore''. Everything you have seen on the internet as a valid point towards a big company has been raised to the CEO, and usually you get an answer that doesn't really answer the questions / even consider those points. Quitting and joining a startup is not an option for any rational person because of the network effects big companies have.
- superioritycplx 9y agoTell that to James Damore.