3 ms·
Why is it OK for the LIDAR company to make a blanket statement of innocence without proof, but not OK for Uber to do the same?
by gowld 9y ago
Why is it OK for the LIDAR company to make a blanket statement of innocence without proof, but not OK for Uber to do the same?
- skybrian 9y agoSaying they are "baffled" isn't a blanket statement of innocence. It's saying they don't know what happened. There is a mystery here. The responsible thing to do is wait for the results of the investigation.
- lisper 9y agoBut Velodyne has proof -- gobs of it -- that their product is "capable" of seeing the pedestrian in the dark. It's possible that this particular unit malfunctioned, but for this to be Velodyne's fault and not Uber's it would have had to malfunction in such a way that it gave the appearance of operating normally. That is extremely unlikely.
- dmix 9y ago> She said that lidar has no problems seeing in the dark. “However, it is up to the rest of the system to interpret and use the data to make decisions. We do not know how the Uber system of decision-making works,” she added. > “In addition to Lidar, autonomous systems typically have several sensors, including camera and radar to make decisions,” she wrote. “We don’t know what sensors were on the Uber car that evening, if they were working, or how they were being used.” There's still a ton of variables here besides whether or not the Lidar detecting the pedestrian. Including the other sensors, how the software works, etc. All things out of the scope of Velodynes knowledge. Velodyne is not saying that they are certain the car should/could have stopped in time or avoided the crash. Their perspective is merely regarding the functionality of Lidar being able to detect the person. Not to mention we don't even know whether the Lidar malfunctioned yet either...
- lisper 9y agoGo back and re-read the GP, which was trying to draw some sort of moral equivalence between Uber and Velodyne: "Why is it OK for the LIDAR company to make a blanket statement of innocence without proof, but not OK for Uber to do the same?" This is a disingenuous question. It assumes facts not in evidence, to use the legal aphorism. Velodyne did not "make a blanket statement of innocence without proof". It made a very narrow and defensible claim, namely, that its product, when working properly under the conditions at the time, should have been able to detect the pedestrian. It is obviously true that there are "a ton of other variables" but that is a red herring with respect to the original question.
- dmix 9y ago> Velodyne did not "make a blanket statement of innocence without proof". I agree, if anything I supported this statement with my comment. The difference is that regardless of the narrowness of their claim, it will have a broader impact on how people judge Uber. Nor do we even know if the Lidar was functioning properly, which is an assumption Velodyne is making when they made their claim. We simply need more evidence before we can fully judge Uber. And before we can give Velodyne a complete pass in terms of the functionality of their Lidar.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- CamelCaseName 9y agoUber is the poster child for lying and cheating. With an extraordinary reputation and history of scandals like theirs, extraordinary proof is required for their claims.