3 ms·
How many of the commenters read the actual bill, and not just about the bill? It's quite short, and it's on Congress' website. I agree with everyone who says t
by EGreg 9y ago
How many of the commenters read the actual bill, and not just about the bill? It's quite short, and it's on Congress' website.
I agree with everyone who says this will just drive prostitution underground, and isn't helpful. However, I am wondering about how hurtful it is to sites which are not designed to host personals or prostitution advertising.
Dating sites are in a gray area, and they have been vetting people's descriptions for a long time.
Social networking sites have flagging features, that others can use to flag profiles for review, under various categories. One of them can be specifically tailored to make sure this bill doesn't describe them as "reckless disregard".
All other sites that host user-generated content, such as programming forums, I think, are in no danger.
Again, this is not about the good intentions of the bill vs what it actually achieves to reduce human trafficking or prostitution. But rather, my comment is mainly about its effect on the vast majority of sites hosting user-generated content under section 230.
- girvo 9y agoI think you’re right; but it’s already having a chilling effect, with large platforms banning and removing content left right and centre to preempt this bill, regardless of whether it would actually fall afoul of it. When you’ve got huge fines and jail time at stake, it’s better for the companies in question to err on the side of more censorship, not less, and it’s worse for everyone who uses the platform in question. So even though I agree with you, it’s already having the impact that a slippery slope argument would expect... that’s very worrying to me.
- hannasanarion 9y agoOne of the problems is this line in particular: The term ‘participation in a venture’ means knowing conduct by an individual or entity, that assists, supports, or facilitates a violation. "facilitating" means "make easier or less difficult". Hosting a website that allows people to talk about things, potentially including sex trafficking, certainly makes it easier, and under this law, any such website would be liable.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]