9 ms·
The great Pacific garbage patch is largely abandoned fishing gear
- pietroglyph 9y agoIt's interesting that (according to this article), while 20% of marine debris globally is fishing gear, 46% of this sample was from fishing sources. There is one source quoted as saying that the study is based on "limited surveys", but the study also apparently took 752 surface trawls (which, to my layman's ear, sounds like a lot). Would the concern be not about the number of samples, but the type of samples? Perhaps fishing gear is more inclined to float to the top where the trawls were taken, or more gear is abandoned in a location that is more likely to float to the patch?
- trophycase 9y agoPerhaps it can be explained by the location of the patch and where fishing boats typically go? I would imagine other types of garbage may have a coastal bias?
- dmurray 9y ago> Perhaps fishing gear is more inclined to float to the top where the trawls were taken Virtually everything non-living either floats or sinks in water. There isn't a major accumulation of debris with exactly the same density as ocean water that follows this garbage patch 100 metres lower.
- nmca 9y agoHave you ever shaken a tube full of sand containing a marble?
- hudibras 9y agoThis isn't the title of the article, and the change is not only inaccurate (46% is not 'mostly') but it downplays the significance of the garbage patch.
- mc32 9y agoYeah, when you read the article it's clear they mean it's in the plurality. In a title it's ambiguous without the context, but not overly deceptive. It's not downplaying it, it's only stating that claims of its being "the size of Texas" and "you can see it from space" are exaggerated.
- hudibras 9y agoBut it's also saying that "the 79,000 tons was four to 16 times larger than has been previously estimated for the patch."
- dang 9y agoThe title is clickbait so we changed it, in accordance with the site guidelines, to the subtitle. But we can take out "mostly" if that bit is misleading.
- djrogers 9y agoThe 46% is only the nets, the title is absolutely true if left as it was. “The study also found that fishing nets account for 46 percent of the trash, with the majority of the rest composed of other fishing industry gear, including ropes, oyster spacers, eel traps, crates, and baskets.”
- spodek 9y agoCleaning it up doesn't fix the problem: we're producing disposable garbage. We can stop buying disposable stuff -- plastic bags, coffee cups, stupid gifts people use for thirty seconds before throwing it away, etc. How much stuff within your reach or eyesight will be used for under a month then never again that you could have not bought? It's a start that will improve your life not to get the stuff. Yes we can do more, but let's at least start with what we immediately control.
- danmaz74 9y ago1-use plastic bags that don't decompose are already banned in the eu. Would be nice if the US adopted the same approach
- headmelted 9y agoThis is not true. Here in the UK (EU, for now) single-use plastic bags are still depressingly common. A levy of 5p per bag was introduced a couple of years back, but nothing that even remotely resembles a proper ban.
- danmaz74 9y agoI stand corrected, how to curb their usage is left to the member states They're banned here in Italy (and in France), I thought the ban was EU wide. https://ec.europa.eu/environment/efe/themes/waste/breaking-bag-habits_en https://ec.europa.eu/environment/efe/themes/waste/breaking-b...
- JPLeRouzic 9y agoI do not know if plastic bags are banned in France, I can use any amount of PLA bags that I want for free and if I pay one euro per bag, I can buy as many plastic bags that I want. In France often what the law says and what is reported in media differs widely. It is absolutely out of context but the best example was the 35 hours per week laws that authorised up to 56 hours per week for some kind of workers.
- darklajid 9y agoCareful: Autoplays a video with sound for me. Muting the video and scrolling the page unmutes the video. Firefox Nightly, Windows. My coworkers didn't like the music, I think.
- sohkamyung 9y agoIf you want to disable video autoplaying permanently, enter about:config in the URL bar, search for media.autoplay.enable and set it's value to false
- headmelted 9y agoThank you kind stranger! Done.
- roseburg 9y agoWe have been seeing massive fishing net globs come ashore for the past few years on the Big Island of Hawaii. It's getting worse. My boys and I personally dragged a large chunk ashore this past year. They are extremely heavy and take a lot of work to move and dispose of all the netting. Here's the image: https://imgur.com/12U4FXg https://imgur.com/12U4FXg This is the latest, the largest tangle of net researchers have seen wash ashore. http://www.fox8live.com/story/37529263/its-huge-40-ton-mass-of-fishing-nets-washes-ashore-on-big-island?clienttype=generic&utm_content=buffere2764&utm_medium=social&utm_source=facebook.com&utm_campaign=buffer http://www.fox8live.com/story/37529263/its-huge-40-ton-mass-...
- citation_please 9y agoThis might be off-topic WRT the linked article, but I just wanted to take the time to say that I admire that you did this with your sons. If I become a parent I want to also instill the value of leaving behind a wake of improvement to our environment and communities, even if it's just picking up a piece of trash that would otherwise sit there until it decomposes.
- masklinn 9y agoSo this is basically a shower drain hairs clog, except made up of fishing nets & lines? I can believe that's heavy and hard work, hair clogs are already surprisingly difficult to get out & untangle (aside from being disgusting). The tangle looks surprisingly clean though, are they mostly recent disposals?
- anonymous5133 9y agoIt could be old. Rope doesnt break down quickly is why.
- masklinn 9y agoIt's more buildup on it I would be expecting.
- Gravityloss 9y agoArtificial proteins could reduce the need to trawl.
- headmelted 9y agoThis is actually somewhat encouraging. Plastic pollution clearly is an emergency now, but that this much of it comes from abandoned fishing gear means cutting the pollution at it's source should be a lot less complicated than trying to completely change the whole world's view on plastic production. Obviously we still need to curb plastic production globally, but it's so commonplace that this will be almost impossible to realistically achieve with the world the way it is. I'd hope that over time we could introduce legislation to move to biodegradeable plastics, but really, we need to change our cultural view of consumption and waste entirely. It's a task that makes solving climate change look trivial, so I'm struggling to hold out hope - although the one ray of light here is that it seems that the scale of the problem is bi-partisan acknowledged, for example, on the left: Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/mar/12/microplastic-pollution-in-oceans-is-far-greater-than-thought-say-scientists https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/mar/12/micropla... CNN: http://edition.cnn.com/interactive/2016/12/world/midway-plastic-island/ http://edition.cnn.com/interactive/2016/12/world/midway-plas... On the right: Daily Mail: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-5491469/Microplastics-flushed-oceans-far-faster-thought.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-5491469/Micro... Fox News: http://www.foxnews.com/food-drink/2018/03/16/93-percent-bottled-water-contains-microplastics-study-says.html http://www.foxnews.com/food-drink/2018/03/16/93-percent-bott... So at least some cause for optimism if the WHO can pressure the UN to take multilateral action, but it'll take pressure on the ground from people the world over.
- jesperlang 9y agokey sentence: > Microplastics make up 94 percent of an estimated 1.8 trillion pieces of plastic in the patch. But that only amounts to eight percent of the total tonnage. As it turns out, of the 79,000 metric tons of plastic in the patch, most of it is abandoned fishing gear—not plastic bottles or packaging drawing headlines today. "only eight percent of the total tonnage"? We are talking about microplastics, that is still an incredible amount of plastic. What's more interesting is I think this article shows how journalism about environmental destruction has some significant problems. It works as with most other human communication, we want narratives and images that evokes emotion (a kind of mythic/romantic understanding of things). That's why "The Great Pacific Garbage Patch" works so well, we all mentally see an island of trash in our heads that needs "cleaning up" and along comes the hero, a young entreprenour. Other things that work well are pictures of dead birds on a beach with their stomach full of different colored plastics. The problem is when our "romantic" idea of pollution hides/ignores the more destructive (and more complex) effects. Pictures of flooding being the poster images for climate change is an incredibly shallow view of the problem. And no part of the world is free of plastic, so basically the entire earth is a plastic garbage patch. Even worse, when an image that is built up doesn't fit what it started out as. You have basically made things worse by planting doubt about the problem in general by having an incomplete and shallow image of the problem..
- adrianN 9y agoYeah, and the relative harm between microplastics and heavy chunks of garbage is also off the charts. A big chunk of stuff floating around in the open ocean can actually become a habitat for all kinds of creatures, whereas small bits of plastic are basically poison.
- girvo 9y agoDon’t those large chunks contribute to the micro plastic problem though, as UV rays and water movement break up the particles? Genuine question.
- monk_e_boy 9y agoHere's a video of micro plastic on my local beach. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gTAojzv8V84 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gTAojzv8V84 How the hell can you clean this up without a thousand people using tweezers? You can't get a backhoe down to the beach. Every tide brings more of the stuff in. It's so overwhelming that it seems pointless even attempting to pick it up. There's f-ing miles and miles of it.
- drawkbox 9y agoDefinitely a great job for robots that are like beach and water roombas [1]. They can side as mapping the oceans better and report other data. These types of robots still need to be widespread and better but that is probably the only way to tackle this problem. Other solutions in the water are being worked on that scrape it off with a large line [2] or a boat like Mr Trash Wheel [3] [1] https://www.popsci.com/waste-shark-is-garbage-collecting-sea-drone https://www.popsci.com/waste-shark-is-garbage-collecting-sea... [2] http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-29631332 http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-29631332 [3] https://news.nationalgeographic.com/2017/02/mr-trash-wheels-professor-trash-wheels-baltimore-harbor-ocean-trash-pickup/ https://news.nationalgeographic.com/2017/02/mr-trash-wheels-...
- SlowBro 9y agoI wonder if within 1,000 years they don’t develop nano robots that actually mine our current trash for the minerals? We toss out gold, silver, rare earth metals, petroleum, every day... the trick is it’s so very hard right now to extract those minerals, but perhaps our current landfills and garbage patches will become the “gold mines” of the future. It would be super easy to reach — landfills have trash just feet below the surface. No dangerous digging. Just thinking optimistically here. I personally do what I can now to keep the earth clean. No sense peeing in your own pool.
- pizza234 9y agoThis is a technical solution to a human problem. Even with extremely advanced technology (by today's standards), the garbage of today will still be separated into valuable materials (just, more than today) and garbage... and the garbage will still be dumped in the ocean (or wherever).
- jerf 9y agoIf you consider it from an atom and energy perspective, you only really need to worry about the atoms that are going to cause you problems no matter what you do, like mercury and the other heavy metals. Those are generally valuable, though (the fact that they are valuable is why they are in a landfill at all in the first place, because it had value at one time), so if there was a cost-effective mechanism to remove those things from a landfill for profit, what was left over would not necessarily be a problem anymore. Garbage getting dumped somewhere is not intrinsically a problem, if the garbage is not as intrinsically harmful as our current garbage. (This is also why radioactive waste is so difficult to get rid of; it isn't a chemical problem, it's a problem all the way down to the atoms. Were it a mere chemical problem we'd have solved it long ago.)
- pizza234 9y agoA fish with a polymer of "innocuous" organic atoms in the digestive tract is likely to disagree. Removing more harmful materials would certainly be a benefit, but it wouldn't solve the large part of the problem (which, in the case of the patch, is plastics).
- _bxg1 9y agoIt's worth noting that National Geographic is now owned by the same parent company as Fox News: https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/national-geographic-magazine-shifts-to-for-profit-status-with-fox-partnership/2015/09/09/7c9f034e-56f0-11e5-8bb1-b488d231bba2_story.html?utm_term=.e78c06f034f1 https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/national-geog...
- todd3834 9y agoWhat significance does that have with the content of this article?
- _bxg1 9y agoA few people in the comments have pointed out problems with the reporting, and the general motive of downplaying environmental issues aligns with those of the aforementioned media company.
- kwoff 9y agoI don't mean to imply anything wrong with the article, but I totally agree that bringing this up is relevant. The potential motivations of who is telling you something is very important. One of the first things I did was google "who owns national geographic". Then I looked through the comments here to see if it'd been mentioned. (I would've made a similar comment, despite the almost inevitable downvoting which I see has so far happened to your comment.) One might also want to check the linked article and its source, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_Reports https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_Reports (I also don't mean to imply anything about that.)
- _bxg1 9y agoAgreed. The article itself doesn't seem wildly biased from a cursory glance, and I'm not really qualified to comment on its scientific rigor, but it's worth being aware of potential sources of bias nonetheless.
- 9y ago