3 ms·
> In fact, they specifically said employees were not waiving their right when it came to age and could pursue age discrimination cases against the company. > B
by shakna 9y ago
> In fact, they specifically said employees were not waiving their right when it came to age and could pursue age discrimination cases against the company.
> But, the new documents added, employees had to waive the right to take their age cases to court. Instead, they had to pursue them through private arbitration. What’s more, they had to keep them confidential and pursue them alone. They couldn’t join with other workers to make a case.
Forced arbitration means they were aware that this would appear to be an age discrimination case... And chose to continue with their actions without trying to dissuade that idea.
- darawk 9y agoOr they, correctly, predicted that it would be spun that way, and wanted to mitigate their risk ahead of time?
- shakna 9y agoAre you suggesting they knowingly mitigated risk without any attempt to redirect the PR backlash, or the government investigation that would result? That doesn't seem like something that would happen.
- darawk 9y agoIt seems like they took lots of steps to mitigate the PR backlash...? It's also pretty unclear what your point is. If they did indeed age discriminate, wouldn't they also want to take steps to mitigate PR backlash?
- shakna 9y agoI don't really see any steps to reduce PR backlash. I do, however, see a lot of steps taken to reduce liability, which is a bigger concern if they were targeting a demographic. The only PR steps seem to be ones to reduce liability, namely that no one involved should talk about it.
- darawk 9y agoRight, but what is that evidence of? I don't see how that is suggestive of anything other than them caring about liability risk.
- shakna 9y agoYou've moved the target. You said it was all PR, it isn't. As for liability, it stinks to high heaven. Age discrimination was picked out for extra protection, shortly before the layoffs began. It is the only form of descrimination where forced arbitration was applied. It was the only place where a complaint was required to be kept secret. And the only complaint where you could not join others with similar complaints. None of this is damning, but it is highly indicative. Most of the bigger companies, like IBM has in the past, will increase contractors in a demographic if that demographic is overly proportionate in a layoff. It's a simple PR stunt that helps show that it isn't likely intentional. Or issue numbers, or statements, like IBM has in the past. They have done nothing to show the public this wasn't on purpose, despite having successfully done so in the past, under the same PR director.
- darawk 9y ago> You've moved the target. You said it was all PR, it isn't. ...when did I say that? What i've said, consistently, is that it's unclear from the evidence presented whether they targeted older workers, or whether they chose some legitimate axis along which to fire people that happens to correlate with age. Like high salaries, or lack of expertise in newer technologies. You responded saying that their PR strategy is evidence that it was specifically about age. That's the only context in which PR has come up, and I still don't see how it proves or otherwise susbtantiates the connection.