3 ms·
If China is indeed a bubble (at least in the medium-term) Australia is going to experience a world of hurt. Yes, but... Australian is a commodity exporter. If
by nl 16y ago
If China is indeed a bubble (at least in the medium-term) Australia is going to experience a world of hurt.
Yes, but...
Australian is a commodity exporter. If China is a bubble, then yes, Australia will be hurt unless another country (US/India/Japan/Korea) picks up demand.
Also, it's not a property bubble when there are less houses than people who want them. Because the population growth rate in Australia is (comparatively) high for a developed country we have high intrinsic demand for new housing.
- jakarta 16y agoDo you realistically expect the US, Japan, or Korea to somehow fill the gap if China suddenly drops its demand for Australian commodities? India might pick up some of the slack, but I would bet against it. Household debt / disposable income in Australia is 157% versus 133% for the US shortly before the financial crisis. That level of debt combined with ever increasing home prices should create a pretty volatile situation.
- nl 16y agoDo you realistically expect the US, Japan, or Korea to somehow fill the gap if China suddenly drops its demand for Australian commodities? Probably not, but it depends. If you think the "China bubble" is because of Chinese domestic demand (ie, construction in China) then it will be hard to replace. If you think it is because of Chinese exports then it's possible another country could substitute. Personally I reject the idea of a Chinese bubble altogether. Household debt / disposable income in Australia is 157% versus 133% for the US shortly before the financial crisis. It would be great if that was lower, but there are reasons for it. It's mainly because of high house prices. Unlike the US we don't have a housing bubble, because of our increasing population. Average household debt is around 20% of household assets (http://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/Lookup/4102.0Main+Features60March%202009 http://www.abs.gov.au/AUSSTATS/abs@.nsf/Lookup/4102.0Main+Fe...). While the asset prices (ie houses) keep increasing that level of debt remains serviceable.
- wisty 16y agoYeah, but if the average Australian owes 1.6 times their annual salary, and house prices are 6X income, and they also have 2 years income locked into superannuation for their retirement (go boomers!), then things could go bad. Ask an American, English, Irish, Greek, Icelandic, or Japanese poster.
- nl 16y agoI don't understand what you are saying, but it seems to me you are confusing cause and effect. Yeah, but if the average Australian owes 1.6 times their annual salary, and house prices are 6X income, and they also have 2 years income locked into superannuation for their retirement (go boomers!), then things could go bad Yes, if you have a high level of debt and things go wrong then it's not a great place to be. But there needs to be something else to make things "go bad", and for it to be a significant problem it needs to happen quickly, before people can adjust their debt levels based on economic signals like an increasing unemployment rate. A very sudden collapse in commodity demand from China could cause a crisis like that, but a sudden drop like that seems unlikely to me. (If you disagree, explain what you think happens in China to cause such a rapid change) A more likely scenario seems to be a slow decrease in demand, occurring over many years. A slow slowdown in demand allows people to change their debt levels, and while individuals may have problems it is unlikely to cause a huge crisis beyond a higher unemployment rate. Given Australia got through the biggest financial crisis since the 1920's in pretty good shape I think automatic pessimism is unfounded.
- barkingcat 16y agoThe two things that could cause Chinese demand to collapse is war, or a people's revolution. Both will be very very bloody, and you would worry about other things than just property value or annual salaries. Be afraid for your life, no matter where on the globe you live. As a Taiwanese, I always feel that tension on the bead, that possibility that either World War 3 or the world's largest and bloodiest popular uprising would erupt before my eyes, perhaps on the back of some trivial issue, like denying China the ore that it wants.
- caf 16y agoThe debt ratios aren't directly comparable, because there are significant differences in the way housing finance is conducted in the two countries. Unlike the US, Australian house loans are never non-recourse. This means that borrowers tend to continue to pay them off even if the notional value of the asset drops below that of the outstanding debt - they can't just mail the keys back to the bank and get out of the loan. Most housing finance in Australia is provided through one of the "big 4" very large and heavily regulated banks - small regional banks are not a significant portion of the Australian market. Australian housing loans also tend to be variable-rate, as opposed to the fixed-rate that's the norm in the US.
- wisty 16y agoThe problem with commodities like iron is they mean-revert. Iron ore traditionally sells for under 40 cents. It's over 160. There is a big price bubble, because there was such a large spike in demand (thus a shortage, so customers bid the price up). But if demand drops, those mining trucks can't just sit idle. They run 24 hours a day, whether they are raking in money or just eking out a profit. The same goes for the 2 mile trains, container ships, loaders, and so on. Quantities won't drop a lot, so price will, right down to the cost of production. Once it hits the cost of production, companies will start scrapping trucks, but that's a very bad way to lower quantities.
- nl 16y agoYes, this is a good point. But I don't think the demand is going to stop (for a significant period of time anyway). While the Chinese standard of living keeps increasing their domestic demand is going to keep increasing. If their standard of living stops increasing then you'd have to question the stability of their government. If that happens then the world economy is probably screwed anyway.
- justsee 16y agoAlso, it's not a property bubble when there are less houses than people who want them. Because the population growth rate in Australia is (comparatively) high for a developed country we have high intrinsic demand for new housing. It is quite simply a myth that there is a housing shortage in Australia. This idea has been conceived and perpetuated by vested interests in the property market in Australia, particularly the Housing Industry Association (HIA). A recent article does a good job of exposing this:"Housing industry's missing persons report pure fiction" http://is.gd/eXZT5 http://is.gd/eXZT5 It's not the first time this kind of tactic has been applied either: in the lead up to the property crashes of the US and UK the press ran numerous stories about housing shortages. These quickly turned to stories of housing gluts after the bubble popped. Look to the Australian census data of 2001 and 2006 and you'll see we've been building at an increased rate, and have an increasing number of empty houses on the books (around 800 000 in 2006). A contrarian site gathers a bunch of this information here: http://bubblepedia.net.au/tiki-index.php?page=HousingShortage http://bubblepedia.net.au/tiki-index.php?page=HousingShortag...