3 ms·
And new tariffs will help that...how? You can't turn back the clock. The factories are already closed, the companies are already bankrupt, the workers have al
by nostrademons 9y ago
And new tariffs will help that...how?
You can't turn back the clock. The factories are already closed, the companies are already bankrupt, the workers have already been laid off and in many cases been out of work for 10-15 years, the young people (those that can get out) have already left. If Middle America wants to rejuvenate itself they need to engage with the world as it exists now and plant new seeds, not try to freeze-frame the world of the 1960s.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoYou can turn the clock back. And this is how you start. You have to create the economic incentives to have a manufacturing base. Without that foundation, nothing else works.
- nostrademons 9y agoYou (or politicians you support) are welcome to try. It probably won't turn out the way you hope. Historically, tariffs and protectionism have benefitted emerging manufacturing powers much more than entrenched incumbents. U.S. manufacturing might was built off the back of tariffs; by keeping them high, the U.S. protected its nascent domestic industries until they could become efficient enough to compete globally. China has been following the exact same playbook, as did Japan before it. But just because tariffs can build emerging industries doesn't mean that they can preserve those industries once they start going into decline. Usually the result isn't that the industries are suddenly revitalized, it's that the whole country goes into decline with them. (We've seen this play out historically with post-WW2 Britain and post-1990 Japan.)
- toomuchtodo 9y agoI intend to try.
- diyseguy 9y agoI don't see China playing fair re IP theft anytime soon. They undercut everyone by exploiting their poor in their factories. So, in order for the manufacturing to start happening here in a way we can afford, wages would have to be very very low, or else robots. So, probably robots. I don't see this creating any jobs here.
- nostrademons 9y ago...or move up the value chain. The idea behind that is that if Chinese goods are unreasonably cheap, there are bound to be some things that you can manufacture using these cheap Chinese components that would previously have been economically infeasible. Go take advantage of this and stop wasting time trying to build things that can be built better elsewhere. This was behind the whole hardware bubble of ~2014, along with the Kickstarter/Alibaba/Octopart/Flexport ecosystem and certain new consumer product categories (eg. fitness trackers, smartwatches, VR). The problem is that hardware startups (like any startups, really) are hard, and it's quite challenging to bring together cheap components in a way that actually adds value to a consumer. That, and primary capital markets are fairly inefficient, so oftentimes hardware startups run out of money before they can work out the kinks in their supply chains.
- pishpash 9y agoThe US has a lot of high end manufacturing. Where do you think all the aerospace tech and advanced weapons systems are built? It's the low end manufacturing that has gone overseas. The whole thing of turning the clock back is quixotic. Did the US benefit over all from this change and does it continue to do so? Yes. Are there winners and also losers? Yes, and crucially the gainers gained more than the losers lost. The problem then seems to be one of distribution of gains, and you can solve that by fairer redistribution. All that turning the clock back does is to make the country poorer on average, and it's a very roundabout way to achieve redistribution. This question will inevitably come again with robots and there will be people who want to turn back the clock then too, but they will be called luddites.