5 ms·
> We are not giving proper credit to how complex it is, and the multi-billion year developmental process that it took. Or we are simply not ready to accept tha
by pas 9y ago
> We are not giving proper credit to how complex it is, and the multi-billion year developmental process that it took.
Or we are simply not ready to accept that it's simply a big book of heuristics fine-tuned over biological eons.
It's just big. We have too many interwoven, interdependent, synergistic faculties. Input, output, and a lot of mental stuff for making the right connections between the ins and the outs. Theory of mind, basic reasoning, the whole limbic system (emotions, basic behavior, dopaminergic motivaton), the executive functions in the prefrontal cortex, all are very specialized things, and we have a laundry list of those, all fine-tuned for each other.
And there's no big magic. Nothing to "understand", no closed formula for consciousness. It's simply a faculty that makes the "all's good, you're conscious" light go green, and it's easy to do that after all the other stuff are working well that does the heavy lifting to make sense of reality.
- resu_nimda 9y agoYour last paragraph seems to contain the kind of overconfidence that I'm talking about. I don't understand how you can say "consciousness is simply X" or "it's easy to do that [if you handwave away the hard parts]." Clearly it's not that simple or easy, or we would have done it. We can't even create life from non-life. How can we begin to understand all the stuff you're talking about that's been layered on top? We don't understand this stuff well enough to just handwave it away as unimportant or trivial.
- 0xfeba 9y ago> We can't even create life from non-life. We can't really define life in the first place. But this is not necessarily to your favour. I think it's more of an indication of how the world doesn't fit into our... anthropomorphic way of thinking. That is, everything follows the laws of physics, no magic involved. We aren't special.
- Retra 9y agoWe certainly can define life, it's just that people don't generally agree on a definition. Some people get offended if you don't include their favorite things in your definition. Even so, we understand it just the same no matter how you define it, because what we understand is not a function of word choice or definition. It's a function of capability.
- pas 9y agoI'm assuming a simpler model, no need for magic, because so far I don't see what behavior/data this simple model cannot explain. > Clearly it's not that simple or easy, or we would have done it. We don't have the computational power yet. Not to mention the vast amount of development required. Think of the climate models, that are huge (millions of lines of code), but they're still nowhere near complete enough, and they only have to model sunlight (Earth's rotation, orbital position, albedo), clouds, flows (winds and currents), some topography (big mountains, big flats), ice (melting, freezing), some chemistry (CO2, salts). And they only have to match a simple graph, not the behavior of a human mind (eg Turing test). So, it's not easy, even if simple. > We can't even create life from non-life. We understand life. Cells, RNA, DNA, proteins, mitochondria, actins, etc. It's big, it's a lot of moving parts, and we understand it, but we can't just pop a big chunk of matter into an atomic assembler and make a cell. And I think intelligence/sentience is similar. It's big, not magic.
- ahartmetz 9y agoWe don't fully understand life. We don't even understand all the proteins. We sure don't understand a single neuron. We understand many small and big things about life, yes.
- oldandtired 9y agoIn part I agree with you. The big difference is that we don't understand the fundamental difference between what is alive and what isn't. We have many different ideas about the quality that is called "life" or living. We have no clue about what it is. We have little or no understanding of the complex protocols that occur within a cell. If we did, our standard manufacturing techniques would be vastly different. We can modify DNA and RNA in interesting ways, but they are not living. It is not until we put them into an already existing living cell that we can reprogram some characteristics of that cell.
- pas 9y agoIt's a spectrum. A rock is non-alive, and a human talking to another human is rather alive. A virus is closer to a rock than a cockroach is to a human newborn in terms of life, but a brain dead patient is probably closer to a tree than to a butterfly, and so on. We have pretty fine understanding of cells, but our materials science and manufacturing technology is not "vastly parallel incremental molecular", but "big precise drastic pure chunk" based compared to cellular manufacturing. Not to mention protein folding and self-assembling biomachines and so on. We're getting there.
- cr0sh 9y ago> We can't even create life from non-life. Have you not been following the work of Craig Venter? Depending on your point of view, he's already done it. Even if you don't agree, you have to admit that he's probably one of the few closest to actually doing it.
- hndamien 9y agoCraig Venter has not created life from non-life. He has synthesised code that can reproduce and grow into a synthetic life form once implanted into an already living cell. So no, not life from non-life.
- padthai 9y agoThere is plenty of magic going on. Today we cannot replicate or understand how emergent properties born of biological structures. Not even in "simple" systems as the metabolic pathways.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pas 9y agoWe mapped the whole genome and connectome of C. elegans, no? And most of that is understood. For example, it seems to be a good model for substance addiction (especially for nicotine). That seems a pretty complex emergent behavior to me. If you mean bigger biology, yes, sure, we don't have a full map of functional genomics for humans, but we're getting there. Or maybe not, maybe it's so exponentially more complex, that it'd take as much time to understand it as it took for evolution to work it out. (Especially considering that evolution played with every individual, whereas we like to constrain our data gathering to non-aggressive methods.)
- ronjobber 9y agoWe have the connectome of C. elegans, yes, but we are still pretty far from understanding how it 'works'. The functional connections are still an active area of research, and it is greatly complicated by connections not explicit in the connectome (neuromodulator effects), as well as the internal dynamics of neurons and non-linear network dynamics. The connectome is necessary, but far from sufficient, to 'understand' a brain, even one made from only 302 neurons as in C. elegans.
- ozy 9y agoSame way waves emerge in water. The rules that govern a system can create patterns, which themselves behave according to rules, but with a set of rules that was "hard to predict" from the underlying system.
- padthai 9y agoThat is exactly my point. We can use fluid dynamics and PDEs in waves. We understand some properties and processes. We are nowhere as close in biological system. I put the example of the metabolic pathways because last time checked (~2015) the most advanced things in the field were extremely simple and without any predictive power. Things like calculating the kernel of a stoichiometric matrix or the centrality of a node in the interactomic graph.
- ozy 9y agohttps://psyarxiv.com/387h9 https://psyarxiv.com/387h9
- jcora 9y agoI'd call this pulling a Dennett: trivializing complexity to something that cannot or just doesn't have to be explained. Being unable to conceive consciousness at this moment doesn't mean there's nothing to conceive of: even if we never get to the final satisfactory answer, there is undoubtedly much more room left for useful concepts we don't have yet, around or inside this idea
- clicea 9y agoI'd call bullshit. Dennett's argument not that the brain is complex but that it's not obvious it is not reductible.
- sgt101 9y agoThat's a lot of nots. So you are saying that Dennett says that the brain might be reducible[1]? I don't think that's a strong claim or that it even qualifies as a claim at all. Lots of things might decompose into simple components if subjected to the right analysis, very few things definitely won't - for example many clever people have spent a great deal of time attempting to reduce quantum and cosmic scale physics to simple intuitively founded laws... If Dennett's claim is that the human brain is the same order of object as the universe I can accept it only if we agree that all objects share the same order. Where does that get us? [1] Apologies, I don't know what reductible means, but guessed typo - I'm open to education though and unworried by typos!
- resource0x 9y ago200 years ago there was nothing to understand in electricity: it was just a liquid :) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluid_theory_of_electricity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluid_theory_of_electricity
- pas 9y agoThere were experiments that were not explained by the liquid theory. Now we have data and people for some reason want to claim that a theory with magical super complex and not-even-yet-describable and very-very-irreducible element(s) is a better fit than a good old box full of tiny yet specialized parts fine-tuned to work together over millions of years.
- resource0x 9y agoCan you think of any experiment that cannot be explained by your theory?
- pas 9y agoYou mean, is this a falsifiable/testable theory? Yes, it's testable, we see very specific neuropathologies, almost like on-off switches affecting very specific functions/faculties of the mind, and they usually correspond well to brain damage locations. So in that sense the experiment is to enumerate the basic (built-in) functional components of the mind and corresponding implementational level machinery, and the of course the reverse (try to enumerate the implementation components and match them with functions) can generate important data (is there a function that has no implementation?). That said, since the claim is that there's no magical component in the mind, and that's kind of hard to prove, but easily falsifiable, just find a/the magical component. The problem is the same as with the soul, and the self, and so on.
- mrfusion 9y agoKeep in mind the genome really isn’t big enough to store enough hueristics to make a functioning human.
- pas 9y agoYes, of course, the problem of bootstrapping consciousness from blueprints of a human mind is that we depend on our parents' whole epigenetic and other extra informational make up, plus their support for years while our mind finishes setting up.