4 ms·
I'm thinking of starting a blog about RC planes, but I'm going to outsource the development. I submitted a bid to IBM but they haven't replied! On top of that
by mulmen 9y ago
I'm thinking of starting a blog about RC planes, but I'm going to outsource the development. I submitted a bid to IBM but they haven't replied!
On top of that Boeing said they're not interested in assembling my plane!
Clearly these incumbents are holding me back.
/s
Sarcasm aside maybe it just wasn't worth it to VW to take on a relatively small project outside of their core competency?
- detaro 9y agoIf making delivery vans for one of the biggest users of delivery vehicles in Germany (that uses tons of VW vans currently) is "a small project outside their core competency", VW really is in trouble.
- mulmen 9y agoDoes VW already know how to make electric vehicles? How many would they sell relative to their total sales of existing ICE vans? Is it worth starting up an entire new business for one customer? I think this can be explained by VW just deciding its not worth it rather than saying VW is trying to suppress electric vehicle development.
- adrianN 9y agoIf you want to get serious about developing EV technology, why not start with a big customer that has a use case that makes the problem a lot easier? Also, small vans for use inside cities is a big market. All delivery services need them, all kinds of workmen need them. With bans for Diesel cars in German cities on the horizon all kinds of businesses are complaining because Diesels are the only offering in that category.
- mulmen 9y agoSure, but can we at least admit that maybe VW did the math and decided it wasn't worth it to them? And that they could have arrived at this conclusion without deciding to sabotage EV development?
- cyxxon 9y agoSure, maybe they did the math, maybe they just couldn't be arsed. But whatever the real reason why they didn't take the job - someone else (DHL itself) actually did the correct math and is now actually a viable competitor for VW in this area. So yeah, again, maybe but they failed at it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Fins 9y agoDon't they have an e-Golf? They know how to build an electric car. It's building one that's actually profitable without heavy tax subsidies and at VW's build quality that's a problem. Tesla hasn't figured that out either.
- michaelt 9y agoMost van companies offer a "chassis cab" option [1] - basically a van with the cab present, but most of the back missing. There's then an ecosystem of companies that will work with end users to design, build and fit custom van bodies. If you want a mobile broadcast van, or an ambulance or a mobile command centre? That's where they come from. If you see delivery vans that aren't standard models, they've almost certainly come through the same ecosystem; companies like VW generally aren't in the business of working with end users on custom products. [1] https://www.google.com/search?q=van+cab+chassis&tbm=isch https://www.google.com/search?q=van+cab+chassis&tbm=isch
- detaro 9y agoDeutsche Post uses a fair amount of the standard "van-type" vans by VW, and even if someone else is making a custom body electrifying the chassis is clearly a job for VW. Given that VW's CEO has been whining to the press about how annoying it is that VW is now not their customer but a competitor, they clearly now think that they should have wanted the job more. My guess is that they did not expect the Post (which as a massive, formerly state-owned company you'd expect to be fairly conservative) to risk going their own way and succeed with it, and thus misjudged the risk involved with letting them pass.
- mulmen 9y agoThere are companies that convert gas trucks to electric: http://autoweek.com/article/ces/your-electric-pickup-here-workhorse-w-15-lands-2019 http://autoweek.com/article/ces/your-electric-pickup-here-wo.... Based on this knowledge it's not clear to me the responsibility of creating an electric variant is the responsibility of VW.
- usrusr 9y agoTheir core competency, beside ICE engines, it's furnishing out vehicles with all the expensive, heavy cruft customers have come to expect from big brands vehicle makers, even in supposedly utilitarian delivery vans. The streetscooter, on the other hand, is really just the most barebone thing you could build around a battery. This saves a lot of money for a startup, but at a big brand with all the processes for sophistication, deviating from the established path would eat much of the savings. But that's not the only problem: many of the same people who are enthusiastic about the pragmatic minimalism of the streetscooter due to the underdog image would punish the same car if it was made by VW or any other of the big ones. And that's not just interior finishing and amenities, the same applies to more serious things like safety and reliability. People will cut streetscooter a lot of slack where they would be unforgiving towards a big brand.