4 ms·
To be clear, where did the money come from to build such things? If it came from a free giving choice from nearby residents, that is incredible, and I'm blown a
by exabrial 9y ago
To be clear, where did the money come from to build such things? If it came from a free giving choice from nearby residents, that is incredible, and I'm blown away by their generosity and we should study how they raised the funds. If it came from a tax that you cannot opt out of, it is wrong, regardless of the end result.
- nkoren 9y agoI'm all in favour of opting out of taxes -- provided that one simultaneously opts out of using public roads and utilities; opts out of being protected by public police, fire, and emergency services; opts out of using public legal regimes for the enforcement of contracts and property rights; and opts out of being able buy goods or receive services from people who have been received public educations. If you're happy to live without any of those things, then fine -- don't pay taxes.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- invincing 9y agoI suppose you don't live in Finland, because I've never heard opinions like that from a fellow Finn. Last night the outdoor temperature here was -20 C (-4 F). In conditions like this, it's basic human behaviour to give shelter to those in need. I gladly pay taxes so that the government can solve the problem in the most efficient way for the society. It would be much more expensive to let the ER and health care system handle these people when they get severely frostbitten outside.
- Sileni 9y agoThat's our jam here in the US. Can't afford $1k/month rent? Sleep in the streets, or get assaulted in an overcrowded shelter. If you're lucky once you freeze off a couple of toes you'll be taken to a hospital, where they'll load you up with debt. Then, we'll pass you off to one of our for-profit prisons for failing to pay off the debt, who will also charge you for the time you spend in the prison. This is an actual worst case scenario in our country. If you think we're a little psychotic, it's because if we've experienced poverty in our lives at all, that daily lottery draw has been in the back of our minds since. That sort of insecurity just does not go away.
- lurquer 9y agoIn light of the weather, would one expect a sizesble number of truly homeless people? Regardless of gov't policy, Finland isn't the place where one can sleep outdoors on the sidewalk or on a park bench. Such a person will either find housing, die, or get train ticket to Italy.
- iyrkki_odyss 9y agoThe money comes from Taxes (Ministry of Environment) and from Finland Slot Machine Association https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finland%27s_Slot_Machine_Association https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finland%27s_Slot_Machine_Assoc....
- magnetic 9y agoI think you've been downvoted a bit hastily because you didn't agree to the "forced subsidy" that came in the form of taxes. One reply caricatured your stance as if you said you didn't want to pay any taxes at all. More importantly you should have read the article until the end. It mentions that the program pays for itself. In other words, the government spends less by providing this housing to the homeless, because the savings due to medical/emergency services are _larger_ than the costs of providing the housing. From a pure money perspective, it sounds like they cost less to society when they are provided housing, so your concern is somewhat moot if you only look at the monetary side of things (which is, I believe, the angle you were concerned about).
- exabrial 9y agoExactly. I'm more than willing to pay for things I use and see worthwhile as investment in my community. However the government is not a charity, and if it were, their monetary efficiency would be very very low (revenue collected : actual benefit ratio).
- namlem 9y agoWould you care to provide evidence that the Finnish government's efficiency is so low, or is that baseless speculation?
- vardump 9y agoThat's probably preferable compared to building prisons.