4 ms·
GM reached the same conclusion when it built the EV-1. I expect that there are tremendous forces inside a company that push back on the sort of radical change t
by ChuckMcM 9y ago
GM reached the same conclusion when it built the EV-1. I expect that there are tremendous forces inside a company that push back on the sort of radical change that electric cars represent.
The difference between then and now is Tesla. I wonder if anyone asked BMW if they were given the opportunity to mass produce the Model 3, if they would have the same opinion.
As for looks, the i8 looks pretty nice. It is apparently going to be available in an electric version this year.
- maxerickson 9y agoTo be fair to GM, batteries improved a great deal since the EV-1. I know there is a crowd of people that are enthusiastic about the EV-1 and think GM killed it, but I'm pretty sure GM had a closer look at whether they could profitably produce them than the enthusiasts.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoGM could've handed the EV-1s over to the owners instead of crushing them.
- jarito 9y agoThey really couldn't. If I remember correctly, US law requires that a dealer provide replacement parts for publicly sold vehicles for 10 years. If you have a small run of cars with very custom parts like the EV-1, the cost of maintaining that capacity is likely prohibitive, so you kill them.
- maxerickson 9y agoThat's not really the right way to phrase that. I'm pretty sure they didn't crush cars that someone else owned. I wonder if they had offered them for sale at prices that would cover their parts obligations if that would have gone over well.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoGM would only lease them, not let you purchase. When they repossessed them at the end of the lease, they would not let you purchase them; they then proceeded to crush any that were not sent to museums. http://electrifyingtimes.com/ev1_crushed.html http://electrifyingtimes.com/ev1_crushed.html http://electrifyingtimes.com/ev1crush.html http://electrifyingtimes.com/ev1crush.html
- maxerickson 9y agoYes, I understand. My question is, what if GM had offered them for sale for $250,000 (I'm making up an obscene number) because they estimated that their service obligations would cost that much? How well would that have gone over with the enthusiasts?
- toomuchtodo 9y agoIt's a fair point.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoThis is the stated reason from the article, "... its current technology is not profitable enough to scale up for volume production" which was exactly the same reason that GM gave for cancelling the EV-1. Which if you compare that to the state of the world in 2008 when Tesla launched its Roadster you can see the difference of "We can't buy anything to solve this problem" and "This is a problem, what needs to be created to solve it?" mentalities. It is always a challenge at BigCorp to get them to actually create something new, they don't have to push the state of the art because they already have a profitable business. Sometimes this attitude is responsible for their demise.
- maxerickson 9y agoRight, but Tesla lost a big pile of money on the Roadster and the Bolt is reasonably comparable to the Model 3. GM isn't generations behind Tesla, they are sitting there forcing Tesla to execute or die.
- kjksf 9y ago> Bolt is reasonably comparable to the Model 3 Not as judged by buyers. According to https://insideevs.com/february-2018-plug-electric-vehicle-sales-report-card/ https://insideevs.com/february-2018-plug-electric-vehicle-sa... Model 3 is already outselling Bolt (in February 2.5k vs. 1.5k) Model 3 is on track to sell 20k per month within months, which will be 10x Bolt sales. If buyers show 10x preference of X vs. Y, Y is not "reasonably comparable".
- csours 9y ago> I expect that there are tremendous forces inside a company that push back on the sort of radical change that electric cars represent. In a publicly traded automaker you must present a business case for a vehicle before you are allowed to design and build it. The business case has to show some kind of profit one way or another, otherwise the board or executive committee reporting to the board will not approve it. It would be fascinating to see the business case for the Bolt EV, as it really looks like it's not making money from direct sales (speaking only from my understanding of public materials, I have no special knowledge of this). Disclaimer: I work for GM, but not on any of this.