3 ms·
I take it with a grain of salt when VCs find reasons to no-true-Scotsman failures like this. It's true that Theranos didn't follow the traditional path. But I t
by wpietri 9y ago
I take it with a grain of salt when VCs find reasons to no-true-Scotsman failures like this. It's true that Theranos didn't follow the traditional path. But I think it's also true that Silicon Valley energetically built up the myths that made Theranos possible, from the grand scale (Technology is a fountain of miracles! Hard questioning of visionary founders is crass!) down to the small details (like Holmes's Jobsian outfits).
Brushing this off as "East Coast" lets us avoid examining our complicity. And our vulnerability. We could look at uBeam, for example, which is backed by a number of West Coast luminaries, including Evans's own A16Z. An engineer has an extensive set of posts on how dubious it is: https://liesandstartuppr.blogspot.com/ https://liesandstartuppr.blogspot.com/
Theranos is different in terms of scale and visibility, for sure. And I do agree that they found a richer class of sucker elsewhere. But I don't think they're culturally any different than a bunch of other overfunded, never-could-have-worked, charismatic-founder failures around here.