4 ms·
>But he doesn't elaborate on it further, and neither does anyone else from what I can tell, and I have yet to figure out the trick 5 * 9 = 5 * (10 - 1) = 50 -
by joshuamorton 9y ago
>But he doesn't elaborate on it further, and neither does anyone else from what I can tell, and I have yet to figure out the trick
5 * 9 = 5 * (10 - 1) = 50 - 5 = 45
Specifically, you need to know everything in the 5x5 area, and how to multiply by 10.
More generally, any digit 6-9 can be rewritten as (10 - (10 - digit)) and then you can apply distribution rules to clean things up. Here's a three by two digit example:
247 * 68 =
(10 - 3) * (10 - 2) + // 7 * 8
10 * (10 - 3) * (10 - 4) + // 7 * 60
10 * 4 * (10 - 2) + // 40 * 8
10 * 10 * 4 * (10 - 4) + // 40 * 60
10 * 10 * 2 * (10 - 2) + // 200 * 8
10 * 10 * 10 * 2 * (10 - 4) // 200 * 60
evaluating we get
100 - 50 + 6 +
10 * (100 - 70 + 12) +
10 * (40 - 8) +
100 * (40 - 16) +
100 * (20 - 4) +
1000 * (20 - 8)
And then to finish up:
00056 +
00420 +
00320 +
02400 +
01600 +
12000 =
16796, which is the correct answer.
Edit:
The fun thing to think about is conceptually why this works. If you consider numbers as just bits, all you're doing is converting the highest bit from base to sign, without actually changing it, doing the multiplications on the lower bits, and then tracking the sign to know whether or not to add or subtract later.
Or to put it another way, you're shifting your set of numbers from being +0 - +10 to being -5 - +5. This makes the lookup table smaller, but requires you to do some additional intermediate lookups (up to four, one in each "quadrant" of the 10x10 table) to be as powerful.
Fun to conceptualize that way.
- Numberwang 9y agoIs this the best way to do quick arithmetic, or are there other ways?
- dahart 9y agoThere are lots of ways, depending on what you want to calculate. Here's a fantastic book on the subject: https://www.amazon.com/Dead-Reckoning-Calculating-Without-Instruments/dp/0884150879 https://www.amazon.com/Dead-Reckoning-Calculating-Without-In...
- pierrebai 9y agoI think this is one instance where using a larger look-up table (i.e. multiplication table up to 10x10) yields clear benefit. The technqiue using only 5x5 increases the number of intermediary results to keep in one's head.
- jacobolus 9y agoMost everything is easier with negative digits. Easier addition, easier rounding, easier multiplication, much easier subtraction. The one part that needs slightly more distinct techniques vs. what you are used to is division, but it's still probably easier overall. The grandparent poster's example only looks more complicated because we don't have standard glyphs for the negative digits.