4 ms·
I've been working through some of the MIT OCW math courses lately. It's actually been a better experience in many ways than my old college classes. Instead of s
by cageface 16y ago
I've been working through some of the MIT OCW math courses lately. It's actually been a better experience in many ways than my old college classes. Instead of sitting in a room full of 100+ people with a teacher too busy to answer questions I can sit back on my couch with a laptop and a lemonade and take my time, pause, rewind, etc.
There is something valuable in the kind of direct interaction you get at higher course levels in most colleges though. Any real alternative to the current system is still going to have to employ specialized, dedicated staff to answer questions. Crunching people through a meatgrinder of canned lectures and standardized testing is only going to take you so far.
- TomOfTTB 16y agoClearly the free offerings out there need refinement and the point you make about interaction is just one area. But my point is we should only care about the knowledge when certifying someone with a degree. So open it up to any business out there to educate people and just standardize what students have to learn to get a degree. I guarantee if you submit the task of educating people to the world of startups you’ll get thousands of systems that are better than the current system and all of them will cost way less than $100,000.
- cageface 16y agoMaybe. You might also just get a lot of companies that learn to game the system and crank out students that test well but that haven't really learned much. Commercial enterprises optimize for commercial goals. Look at the University of Phoenix, for example.
- _delirium 16y agoThere's an interesting supply issue in your example, as well. I mean, those were MIT courses after all, produced mostly by tenured faculty paid to teach students enrolled at MIT, not DIY courses produced by freelance instructors on the internet. Now the ratio of how many students can be taught by one instructor does go up greatly with something like OCW, but it seems we still need some sort of system where the people producing and updating that material have jobs that let them do so. (If we massively shrink higher education, we'll also need some alternate way of paying people to do scientific research, since currently universities are the source of a lot of that as well. But that could at least in principle be decoupled from the education angle, at least for undergrad education.)
- cageface 16y agoAn interesting corollary is that something like OCW might eventually mean that we need a small group of highly-paid, extremely talented instructors but far fewer average instructors. Or maybe all the average instructors can stop giving lectures and instead offer their services as tutors?
- Miserlou57 16y agoI'm working on something a lot like this right now...