3 ms·
Clearly we're seeing some real-world issues with the actual practice of science, but the concept is that if researchers are carrying it out properly it doesn't
by emodendroket 9y ago
Clearly we're seeing some real-world issues with the actual practice of science, but the concept is that if researchers are carrying it out properly it doesn't matter what their personal beliefs are. You start out with a hypothesis, design an experiment, and it either proves you right or wrong. I don't think it's necessary or even desirable to start interrogating beliefs and only selecting scientists we somehow judge completely unbiased; if we followed that to extremes we'd end up with a case where the same scientist could not even continue studying the same subject.
- coldtea 9y ago>but the concept is that if researchers are carrying it out properly it doesn't matter what their personal beliefs are. You start out with a hypothesis, design an experiment, and it either proves you right or wrong. Yeah, but note how this presupposes that its equally easy to "carry it out properly" in either case. Whereas what I say is that (a) it's less likely for biased researchers to carry their research out properly (I say less likely, not impossible). (b) so for that, we should try to have less research from biased researchers (That's because I don't think that "(c) biased researchers should try more to handle their research properly" is an option -- because of how bias works, biased researchers will always be more prone to not handling their research properly).
- emodendroket 9y agoIt strikes me that there is a crisis of rigor more generally. I don't think targeting religious believers would fix all the problems.