4 ms·
The more social media applies arbitrary rules to speech, the more likely they are to be regulated as common carriers. This puts a lot of restrictions and “the I
by prepend 9y ago
The more social media applies arbitrary rules to speech, the more likely they are to be regulated as common carriers. This puts a lot of restrictions and “the Internet” was against it.
But these items are not illegal speech (although sometimes).
These are private orgs and can legally ban whatever they want. However, phone companies are private too, but they have regulation controlling what is and is not allowed.
The issue is that banning legal speech is a slippery slope. I imagine how I would respond if YouTube banned howtos on ripping DVDs. They can legally do that and it’s based on an illegal activity.
This also opens the door for countries with restrictive laws to forbid speech about what is illegal in China, etc.
- dangoor 9y agoIt seems to me that social media aren't the same as common carriers in that people can very easily switch from one to another. I saw a headline saying that one gun video channel on YouTube was moving its videos to another site. They will no longer have access to YouTube's audience, but they are still free to post their videos in a publicly-accessible fashion.
- exabrial 9y agoJust curious, what site is that? Cody's Lab and AVE, two of the most informative educational channels, already have a crap ton of problems with YouTube (granted AVE pokes the bear with a stick). With the #DeleteFacebook movement in full swing, I'd love to see a #LoseTheTube and go to a platform that promotes free expression but can actually classify stuff correctly (giving the user the power to filter what they don't want to see).
- taborj 9y agoMany are moving over to full30.com
- dangoor 9y agoI had to go back to find the article, because it was just a headline that appeared in the sidebar of an article I was reading this morning. This wouldn't appear to be a general solution, they're moving to Pornhub: https://www.buzzfeed.com/leticiamiranda/a-gun-demo-youtube-channel-with-24-million-subscribers-is https://www.buzzfeed.com/leticiamiranda/a-gun-demo-youtube-c... (The slug in that URL is wrong. They changed the headline to be "24 million views".)
- flyingfences 9y agoA few channels are legitimately backing up their content to PornHub. The largest serious contender is Full30.
- juliangoldsmith 9y agoPeople can theoretically switch from one social network to another, however taking their friends with them is less easy. If you make your living making videos on YouTube, and want to move to another service, most of your audience isn't going to come along. Being able to publicly post your videos is pointless if nobody watches them.
- dangoor 9y agoI agree that it can be painful, but there are parallels that can be drawn. Dick's Sporting Goods just stopped selling certain kinds of guns. Those gun manufacturers can still sell their guns, but just not at Dick's, so they're losing part of their potential audience. There was a story a month or two ago about a publisher that went out of business because their whole business model (apparently) revolved around pushing their content on Facebook and then Facebook changed their newsfeed algorithm. I think that's a risk for anyone relying on a given channel for their product.
- juliangoldsmith 9y agoThe difference is that those manufacturers can go to other stores to sell their products. YouTube is the only store that customers go to, so it's the only place you can actually sell your product at.
- intopieces 9y ago>Being able to publicly post your videos is pointless if nobody watches them The freedom of speech is not the freedom to be heard. Youtube is not the only seller of megaphones by the public square.
- juliangoldsmith 9y agoYouTube isn't the only seller of megaphones, but they're the only one that matters. When they have an effective monopoly on audience, network effects will make it impossible for anyone else to compete.
- bnolsen 9y agoRipping dvds isn't affirmed by the constitution as an unaliable right either.
- craftyguy 9y agoNeither are instructions for making grandma's famous chocolate chip cookies.
- cuckcuckspruce 9y agoWriting and publishing a recipe is absolutely protected by the First Amendment as an inalienable right.
- craftyguy 9y agoWell then so are instructions for ripping DVDs, in that case. There are legitimate reasons to rip DVDs and make cookies.
- nsfyn55 9y agoWhen are you people going to understand that your first amendment right doesn't protect your right to post on the internet. It just stops the government from making laws that restrict your speech freedoms. Reddit and Youtube can sensor you all day and its perfectly constitutional
- intopieces 9y agoI don’t see the connection between a company changing its platform to please its advertisers and being declared a common carrier. Has it happened before? Telephones are not common carriers because the phone company tells you what you can and cannot say.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]