2 ms·
> I have better night vision than this camera, I feel as a human I would have seen the bike. I'm not so sure. Under conditions where there is low light everywh
by pdonis 9y ago
> I have better night vision than this camera, I feel as a human I would have seen the bike.
I'm not so sure. Under conditions where there is low light everywhere, so the eye has time to adapt, human low light vision is very good. But under the conditions shown in the video, where there are street lights present and the pedestrian comes out from a gap between the street lights, your eye won't be dark adapted and you won't have much of a chance of seeing the pedestrian in the shadows.
- eanzenberg 9y agoThis is literally the reason for high-beams. If the road is not illuminated enough you turn those on and drive as fast as you are comfortable being able to fully stop if a deer jumps out of left field (or in this case, a pedestrian is walking across the road).
- pdonis 9y ago> This is literally the reason for high-beams. I agree. From the video it doesn't look like they were on in this incident.
- user5994461 9y agoIs it allowed in the US to have high beams on when there are other cars on the road?
- pdonis 9y ago> Is it allowed in the US to have high beams on when there are other cars on the road? You're supposed to shut them off if it would impair the vision of oncoming traffic. But there are plenty of situations where that won't be the case.
- robryan 9y agoA self driving car should be far better than a human at turning them on and off. In Australia it is relatively common in semi rural areas with similarly sparse street lights that you would turn high beams on and off depending on oncoming traffic.
- hcknwscommenter 9y agoAnd I have literally never had to use high beams on a road with street lights. In my opinion, the camera footage vastly under-indicates the amount of visibility available to the human eye between the lighted areas.
- pdonis 9y ago> I have literally never had to use high beams on a road with street lights. I have, plenty of times. Not all road streetlights are optimally placed. > the camera footage vastly under-indicates the amount of visibility available to the human eye I agree with this; it's pretty much always going to be true for a visible light video camera under nighttime conditions. But I don't think that means a human driver, without high beams, would necessarily have been able to see the pedestrian. (As I've commented elsewhere in this thread, I think I would have been using high beams on this street, streetlights notwithstanding; the gaps between the lights look too long for good visibility.)
- extrapickles 9y agoIt's typically illegal[0] and otherwise a bad idea to operate high beams when there is other traffic around as you can blind other drivers. [0]: Page 46 of https://www.azdot.gov/docs/default-source/mvd-forms-pubs/99-0117.pdf https://www.azdot.gov/docs/default-source/mvd-forms-pubs/99-... Other states have similar laws, such as California: http://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?sectionNum=24409.&lawCode=VEH http://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection...
- imh 9y agoIt's not a function of seeing it the dark, it's that human eyeballs have really good dynamic range, which is exactly why they'd beat cameras in those conditions.
- pdonis 9y ago> human eyeballs have really good dynamic range Not if they're not given time to dark adapt. As I've posted elsewhere in this thread, human vision would still be better than that of a video camera using visible light, but that still wouldn't be very good under variable lighting conditions.
- imh 9y agoThere's a range of light to dark you can see at once. Your eyes can adapt and move the whole range up and down, as can cameras. You're right that it takes time. But the width of the range at a given moment is wider on people than many cameras (sans post-processing). That's why this video is deceptive. Our eyes can see details in the light and dark at the same time better than cameras can. This (https://i.imgur.com/3u1kN7T.png https://i.imgur.com/3u1kN7T.png) is an example. The top picture has less detail in both the lightest and darkest portions than the bottom one. The human eye is reeeeally good at that.
- pdonis 9y ago> Our eyes can see details in the light and dark at the same time better than cameras can. Yes, I agree. But that doesn't mean that a human eye would necessarily have seen the pedestrian in this situation in time to react. (Based on other posts elsewhere in this thread, I don't think a human driver would have been able to see the pedestrian in time without high beam headlights on.)
- freyir 9y agois this what it looks like when you drive at night? Can you only see about ten feet in front of you, and everything else is pitch black? No. Not even close. Our eyesight is much, much better than this. If our eyes were as bad as this camera, it wouldn’t be legal to drive at night.