4 ms·
Wow, I had thought it impossible for the Uber AV to be in the right lane, and for the victim to be crossing left-to-right, for the police to claim that the vict
by danso 9y ago
Wow, I had thought it impossible for the Uber AV to be in the right lane, and for the victim to be crossing left-to-right, for the police to claim that the victim couldn't be seen until it was too late. But I didn't expect the road to be so dark, given what we saw in the accident photos (which might have been over-exposed?) and Google Maps, which showed a lot of street/sidewalk lighting.
In the moment that we can fully see her, she does look unambiguously like a person walking a bike across the road (reports say there were plastic bags on the bike, but they weren't obvious/obstructive in the camera view). Is the AV's LIDAR expected to detect this kind of thing, even if it's too dark for human eyes?
The video of the Uber driver doesn't look great for the driver. I mean she doesn't look particularly engaged -- but I suspect that's what most of us would look like at the wheel. But she definitely seems to be looking downwards, right at the moment of impact.
Unless some other incriminating info is discovered, I hope that the driver isn't the sole focus of punishment (doesn't help that she's a convicted armed robber, albeit years ago). Being able to brake in time for the victim seems difficult even in most ideal and alert conditions. And I have to think human operators are going to suffer complacency when 95-99% of the time they never have to actually drive -- making that switch seems to be a situation ripe with problems.
I don't mean that Uber execs/testers/engineers (again, assuming there isn't other incriminating evidence) should be scapegoats. I hope the result involves regulations that add more transparency to reporting (especially in Arizona), and public debate about the expectations of AV and AI.
- somebodynew 9y agoThe dynamic range of small sensor digital cameras is so poor that it is impossible to judge whether or not she would have been visible to the naked eye based on the video.
- danso 9y agoThat's a great point. I did think, looking at the video, that the street was unnaturally dark. The camera seems to be exposed for night lights and the headlights too.
- throwaway2048 9y agoMost cameras have very poor contrast in low light situations that are interspaced with lights like a typical street with streetlamps, your eye does significantly better.
- iancarroll 9y agoLiDAR is not affected by the amount of visible (sun) light. I'm very curious to see the data returned from the LiDAR, because this should've been a very clear human frame, albeit with a bike behind it.
- wnkrshm 9y agoLIDAR still has a signal to noise ratio that limits it though, especially with materials that reflect little with the wavelength used (usually NIR, somewhere around 980nm, the military uses 1500 because it's more eye-safe). But even then, this impacts the maximal detection range only. Even if the obstacle suddenly popped up at 20m it should have been enough to drastically reduce the collision speed.
- jcranmer 9y agoDigital image quality is generally far inferior to naked eye visibility, but even in the image, the pedestrian can be seen for at least a full second. The driver clearly was unfortunately not paying attention. She clearly reacts within a few hundred milliseconds of looking up, which is to say immediate reaction time in terms of mental processing. That means that we cannot use her reaction time to gauge how early she could have seen the pedestrian to compensate for poorer optics of digital cameras. As I understand LIDAR, it should work even at night (as it generates its own light and measures response time). This is a pedestrian, walking across a road, with nothing possible to occlude her. There is no reason it should not have identified an obstacle in the road (she's been in the road for several seconds, after all, having crossed at least 3 lanes of traffic by that point). Even if the visual camera had problems identifying the object, LIDAR should have flagged it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- soperj 9y agoIt's a video.. it was likely not as dark as portrayed.
- ScottBurson 9y ago> I hope that the driver isn't the sole focus of punishment As sad as this accident was, I don't see how the driver or Uber is legally at fault. Pedestrians crossing outside of a crosswalk are supposed to yield to traffic. The victim in this video is stunningly oblivious to the fact that she's on a roadway. Obviously we want self-driving tech to be good enough to avoid such an accident, particularly since a human probably could have; I'm not arguing otherwise. But legally, the victim was clearly at least partially at fault here. I think one thing this incident is going to do is to point up the limitations of having a human at the wheel, supposedly ready to take over. In a true sudden emergency, after tens of thousands of miles of uneventful riding around, that just isn't going to happen reliably.
- WiseWeasel 9y ago> Pedestrians crossing outside of a crosswalk are supposed to yield to traffic. Pedestrians always have the right-of-way. They might get a ticket for jaywalking in some cities, but it's never permissible to hit someone with your car, regardless of whether they're in a crosswalk. Vehicular manslaughter is no minor infraction, and Uber can expect a civil suit from the victim's family even if there are no criminal charges.
- ScottBurson 9y agoI'm sure you're right about the civil suit.
- DannyBee 9y agoThey will probably lose in arizona (In My Lawyerly Opinion) but Uber will settle it out anyway. It's not only comparative negligence, you don't have to always yield. In fact, Arizona has a weird set of rules that would make this exact set of events a law school exam style question: Arizona: Vehicles must yield the right-of-way to pedestrians within a crosswalk that are in the same half of the roadway as the vehicle or when a pedestrian is approaching closely enough from the opposite side of the roadway to constitute a danger. Pedestrians may not suddenly leave the curb and enter a crosswalk into the path of a moving vehicle that is so close the vehicle is unable to yield. Pedestrians must yield the right-of-way to vehicles when crossing outside of a marked crosswalk or an unmarked crosswalk at an intersection. Where traffic control devices are in operation, pedestrians may only cross between two adjacent intersections in a marked crosswalk. One saving grace for any plaintiff is that in AZ you can recover 1% damages even if you are 99% at fault.
- gkya 9y agoThis is a shit show now. A new technology is being tested, and the tester is a convicted armed robber, and was not even looking at the road during the test drive. I think every single person in Uber that has anything to do with this testing program is guilty of homicide, including the driver. This could've been at least non-fatal.