4 ms·
I have done a lot of extensive read and thinking on the subject for my startup (we're now doing digital real estate transactions leveraging the Blockchain, but
by simonebrunozzi 9y ago
I have done a lot of extensive read and thinking on the subject for my startup (we're now doing digital real estate transactions leveraging the Blockchain, but months ago we were exploring the idea of a platform to create/fund communities). [0]
The pioneer in this field has certainly been Adriano Olivetti in the 1940/1950s, back when Olivetti was an amazingly successful company. They were market leaders in typewriters, so much that they bought the US-based Underwood, and they were pioneering computers in the 1960s.
Olivetti built a "quasi-socialist" company campus in Ivrea (outside Turin, Italy), which was really innovative for its time. Kindergarden, schools, services, etc, all available to Olivetti workers and their families. Think of it as a combination of a Google or Facebook campus, with an Italian, pragmatic, honest twist.
Now, let's get back to Facebook's proposed "campus" or "community".
I see a few problems here:
1) providing rent to FB employees is a form of employee retention - you have a strong incentive not to leave Facebook, or you will lose a rent likely more affordable than outside the campus, and your neighborhood friendships.
2) Most of these campuses are done to project an image of an amazing, cool company. Therefore, expensive architects plan expensive buildings in a way that cannot be easily replicated elsewhere. When building costs are "subsidized" by the need of "grandeur" of a company, it's the wrong incentive at play. Look, for a counter example, at the Nightingale project [1].
3) Many architects and thinkers have written about the subject. In particular, Christoper Alexander and Leon Krier, among others. The short summary of their conclusions is that "top down" almost never works; "bottom up" does. In essence, you have to plant the seed, provide initial resources, and get out of the way, letting people and communities figure out how they want to organize their life. A good counter example? The planned city of Brazilia. I studied it, and visited it, and it's an urban design nightmare. [2] - so much so that, to cite just one metric, Brazilia has 4 to 5 times the number of pedestrian accident (in proportion of the population) of other Brazilian cities.
I could go on and on, but let me just conclude with this: most of these company-driven initiatives are dead from the start, and they are set to produce only aberrations. I hope I'm wrong, and I hope to see something different emerge over time.
[0]: https://www.fabrica.city/ https://www.fabrica.city/
[1]: http://nightingalehousing.org/nightingale-village http://nightingalehousing.org/nightingale-village
[2]: http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-20632277 http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-20632277