3 ms·
The more real (and observable today imho) problem is: in general, people aren't really good at, interested in, or have time for thinking deeply and critically,
by mistermann 9y ago
The more real (and observable today imho) problem is: in general, people aren't really good at, interested in, or have time for thinking deeply and critically, and some things matter, a lot. So if they can't (or won't) think about these things themselves, and you remove a religious rule, it creates a vacuum where anyone or any "-ism" can enter and replace religion's influence on public behavior.
- verylittlemeat 9y agoWhat kinds of religious rules do you feel keep which types of behaviors in check? (the ones you see as most important for society) I'm just curious what you consider, not looking for an argument or debate necessarily.
- mistermann 9y agoIn general, honesty and following the rules I think correlates to religion. Religion isn't necessary, but I believe something formal is necessary. I see no reason whatsoever to believe that people are going to each come to similar fairly optimum decisions individually, and plenty of reasons to believe they won't.
- armandososa 9y agoIt's not the rules, it's about the faith. e.g. If I (honestly) believe that all human beings were made equal in the image of God (whatever that may be) that would affect the way I treat people. Some rules will came out of that belief: like "don't lie" and "don't kill" but, in it's purest form, religion is not about rules, and the fact that people don't know that means that religious institutions have failed.
- mistermann 9y agoThat's a fine theory, but to claim you know this with certainty I think is a much larger claim than you realize. What exactly makes humans behave they way they do is extremely complex - some people may behave exactly for the reason you describe, others may not, anyone that says they know for sure is not telling the truth (although that doesn't necessarily mean they're lying).