4 ms·
"I think the shifts have been so rapid that we'll really need to wait a generation or two before we can say that some of these countries have fully cast off rel
by jerf 9y ago
"I think the shifts have been so rapid that we'll really need to wait a generation or two before we can say that some of these countries have fully cast off religious practice,"
Christianity is not the only religion. On the generational time scale, Europe (considered as a geography) may be trading Christianity for Islam.
- gumby 9y agoThat is of course possible but I think more likely the same reasons people are ignoring christianity will cause people in the same environments to ignore other religions. I could get into what I think those reasons are but that could open an HN flame war, so unless there's a followup comment on the topic I won't get into it.
- checkyoursudo 9y agoI would be super surprised if young muslims were any different than young christians and young-everything-elses in this regard. The increase in islam in europe is primarily from an influx of muslim immigrants. On the generational time scale, you can probably expect their children to become accustomed to universal culture[0] just like the rest of europe (and north america, and probably everywhere eventually). Because of continued migration, Islam will probably increase in absolute numbers for a while yet. But I doubt it will ever become dominant in regions where it is not already dominant. Being targets of missionaries from, e.g., Africa or South America (if they're more religious than EU/NA? I don't know?) would be a really interesting (to me) idea. Again, I'd be surprised. But interesting nonetheless! [0] https://slatestarcodex.com/2016/07/25/how-the-west-was-won/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2016/07/25/how-the-west-was-won/
- thriftwy 9y agoIslam as is has very little desirability to convert for non-Muslim. It has to be either a hostile takeover (think Egyptians and Copts, Lebanon and christians, or any other kind of religion-based cleansings) or it will be two communities. Muslim and post-christians. (And proponents of religious tolerance have already promised us that no hostile takeover is ever possible, didn't they?)
- pgeorgi 9y ago> Islam as is has very little desirability to convert for non-Muslim The successful pitch of a certain variant of Islam seems to be "structure": That it tells you what to do and what not to do down to the tiniest minutiae (and it tells you that it's desirable that everybody sticks to the same set of rules, and if necessary, is made to do so). For people who are overwhelmed by the many degrees of freedom in some western societies, that seems to look like a safety net: The most active radical islamists in Germany are converts.
- thriftwy 9y agoI can see that but I don't think this will ever be a particularly popular reason, numbers-wise. Not everybody is born zealot.
- KirinDave 9y agoReligious decline is a global phenomenon. That's why religions the world over are tending towards regressive policies: they're an increasing majority as other groups decline.
- simula67 9y agoNope. From https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atheism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atheism > Two global polls on the subject have been conducted by WIN/Gallup International: their 2015 poll featured over 64,000 respondents and indicated that 11% were "convinced atheists" whereas an earlier 2012 poll found that 13% of respondents were "convinced atheist Religious decline seems to be Western and East Asian phenomenon
- thriftwy 9y agoThat's also two areas with arguably most of contributions to humanity. Is this a coincidence? You either do or pray.
- simula67 9y agoWhile these areas where "making contributions to humanity" they were religious
- thriftwy 9y agoThey stopped being religious while making contributions to humanity. As if they burned through their stash. Also, this is exaggerated. Greeks and Romans did awesome things that nobody could reproduce until XX century while being "pagans". Christianity just stole those results, tried to pass as their own.
- simula67 9y ago> They stopped being religious while making contributions to humanity. As if they burned through their stash My claim was merely that you don't need to be atheist to contribute to humanity > Christianity just stole those results, tried to pass as their own. Christianity did not steal anything, they built on existing knowledge. No one is denying that. Every generation builds on what previous generation knew. You think Christians should have the thrown out knowledge from pagans in the name of honor ?
- Freak_NL 9y agoAs the major religion, or as the major world-view? It looks like atheism/agnosticism/no religion is set to remain the majority world-view in the countries where it already is. Unless you subscribe to the notion that Muslims will be in the majority in those countries because of immigration and large families. Some extreme right political parties claim this, but the sources for these statistical prognoses seem dubious at best.
- candiodari 9y agoOnly on a global level. In Rotterdam, Antwerp and Brussels and Amsterdam and even Paris is very close this is now fact among the very young (kindergarten). That means that it's only a matter of time unless something drastic changes. But it would need to be very drastic. Even if immigration stops completely muslims will still be a majority there, at the very latest in 30 years, but very likely much sooner. And ... www.ejournals.eu/pliki/art/3178/ Religion has always retreated while great economic progress was being made. And time and time again great economic progress periods ... end. And time and time again ... nobody sees it coming, and time and time again the exact same thing happens : religion comes back with a vengeance. Even in this current period. Where economic progress crashed, an extremely intolerant brand of religion immediately gained an incredible following. Google "Egypt in the 60s". Google "Iran under the Shah". Google "Turkey under Ataturk". Now this may or may not be happening soon (and soon means something like a decade), but that's another one of those things people think during periods of great economic progress. That they never end. That it's impossible for anything to go wrong. But I must say, even today, one walk around the North station of Brussels through Schaarbeek and Molenbeek will tell you that it's not going so well for everybody, especially if you stop in a street shop for dinner (note: sorry to state this but do not attempt in the evening if you're a woman).
- nsxwolf 9y agoMuslims are the only ones having more children than the replacement level, so could you expect a different outcome?