2 ms·
Builders of bridge for general public use have a legal obligation for safety. That's not comparable. Moreoever, I have made bridges across streams, using stone
by eesmith 9y ago
Builders of bridge for general public use have a legal obligation for safety. That's not comparable.
Moreoever, I have made bridges across streams, using stones and logs, which were not safe. And left them there as-is, because there isn't an obligation that these sorts of throw-it-together hiking bridges actually be safe for others. The risk is entirely on the crosser. If you try to cross it, slip, knock your head on a rock, and drown, there is no blame on me. (Plus, it might have been safe when I made it, but the water conditions changed, or if overnight it iced over, etc.)
Look at it another way. If I post a poem on my web site, for people to read for free, and you think it's crap, I don't have an obligation to edit the poem to your liking or even read your criticism.
Do I have an ethical obligation to not post shitty poetry on the world? No! I don't even have the obligation to not be snide to criticism I don't like.
And I believe you are saying that it's unethical for all of those college students in introductory CS classes to host their software - almost all of which are 'shit software' - on a public system like github.