4 ms·
perjury is punishable by 5 years in prison. That's a suitable punishment. The problem is that the law is not enforced.
by gowld 9y ago
perjury is punishable by 5 years in prison. That's a suitable punishment. The problem is that the law is not enforced.
- ncallaway 9y agoTotally agree on enforcement, and probably agree on the term of the punishment. In the vast majority of nonviolent cases I think we as a society tend to be overly punitive with the criminal justice system. Maybe I'm making the same emotional overreaction here.
- naasking 9y ago> The problem is that the law is not enforced. I've started to think that prosecutorial discretion is one of the main problems in Western societies. It yields all kinds of injustices, and overly vague and expansive laws that essentially result in every citizen breaking a few laws a day. If prosecutors didn't have a choice on whether to prosecute a case, the law would ultimately be a lot more reasonable because old and unjust laws would more readily be stricken from the books, and there would be no possibility of favouritism.
- bluntfang 9y ago>overly vague and expansive laws that essentially result in every citizen breaking a few laws a day. I've had the idea that the current system we have, which is basically you're not breaking the law unless someone is watching, isn't going to play nice with constant surveillance. Currently, if a law isn't enforced, it's de-facto not the law. Just imagine if computers in people's cars were phoning home to police. How many speeding fines would be issued daily? Failure to (completely) stop at a stop sign? Reckless driving? Look at how China is currently testing the waters with shaming j-walkers[0]. Just wait until this is fully institutionalized. [0] http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-03-20/china-deploys-ai-cameras-to-tackle-jaywalkers-in-shenzhen/9567430 http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-03-20/china-deploys-ai-camer...
- snowwrestler 9y agoThis debate is already well underway in the context of speed cameras, which can automatically issue a ticket to every single driver who is even 1mph over the speed limit. Many communities are limiting their use, for example by restricting their placement to only streets immediately outside schools.
- jaclaz 9y ago>I've started to think that prosecutorial discretion is one of the main problems in Western societies. It yields all kinds of injustices, and overly vague and expansive laws that essentially result in every citizen breaking a few laws a day. >If prosecutors didn't have a choice on whether to prosecute a case, the law would ultimately be a lot more reasonable because old and unjust laws would more readily be stricken from the books, and there would be no possibility of favouritism. It is not "Western societies", in some Roman/Civil Law countries, as an example Italy, prosecution is not discretional, it is "mandatory" for crimes (whether this is effectively enforced in the same way and everywhere is another thing).
- bradleyjg 9y agoAt one point in Anglo-American legal history it was possible to bring a private prosecution. Although on the balance it is probably for the best that doesn’t exist anymore in general, perhaps it out to be revived for cases of public misconduct where the public prosecutors have a conflict of interest.