5 ms·
How do you know Google does the same thing? What can you get out of Google by writing an app? Off the top of my head, I don't think Google even has most people
by skybrian 9y ago
How do you know Google does the same thing? What can you get out of Google by writing an app?
Off the top of my head, I don't think Google even has most people's friends lists (outside Orkut back in the day, and Google+, which isn't so popular). They do have contact lists in Gmail, which is a bit different.
There is address book spamming via mobile apps, but again, there are permissions. How good are they?
It seems like it's "the same thing" only if you ignore all technical detail. We should be able to do better than that!
- HenryBemis 9y agoGoogle absolutely harvests all info they can get. They scan gmails, they monitorig everything on all Android phones, even when you disable something [1]. It's just that Google maybe be a bit hesitant to sell data to 3rd parties, since they abuse them themselves :) (and this is the price of a 'free' service). [1]: https://gadgets.ndtv.com/apps/news/google-tracking-user-location-data-on-android-even-when-disabled-report-1778542 https://gadgets.ndtv.com/apps/news/google-tracking-user-loca...
- skybrian 9y agoIsn't selling or just giving data to third parties what we're talking about today?
- untog 9y ago> It's just that Google maybe be a bit hesitant to sell data to 3rd parties Which is the entire point. I know Google is taking data when I use Google products. The problem arises when Google freely gives my data to a random third party company I neither know nor trust, without my knowledge.
- earenndil 9y agoWhy is it better that google has your data than that another company has your data?
- untog 9y agoBecause I agreed to give it to them, for one. For another, I know what Google is. And where it is - they have an address. They're in the US. I could, if I wanted, sue them. Compare that to a literally limitless number of unknown organisations all across the world? Yeah, I'd say Google is better.
- soohyung 9y agoBecause at least then you know who has your data. If I agree to Google having some of my data because I trust them with it to some extent that does not mean I want to give any third party access to that data. And I'm not saying there's any reason to trust Google with your data, but at least you'll know who really has access to that data.
- yters 9y agoArguably Google can create a pretty good social network from email. That's why the use it for ads.
- criddell 9y agoI was looking at Google Plus again last week and there's a lot of interesting things about it. I kind of wish they would spin it off into its own company.
- kyrra 9y agoGoogle stopped scanning emails 9 months ago[0]. [0] https://blog.google/products/gmail/g-suite-gains-traction-in-the-enterprise-g-suites-gmail-and-consumer-gmail-to-more-closely-align/ https://blog.google/products/gmail/g-suite-gains-traction-in...
- ctchocula 9y agoThe exact quote is "Consumer Gmail content will not be used or scanned for any ads personalization after this change." I know they still scan my emails, because airbnb reservations will magically pop up on my calendar.
- pvdebbe 9y agoDo you log in to AirBnB using Google credentials? Perhaps they use an undocumented feature to broadcast the dates to GCal without mail harvesting.
- ctchocula 9y agoNope, using Facebook credentials. That's definitely a possibility. Maybe I'm cynical, but whenever I see qualifiers around a verb I get suspicious. Something like "hey, we're not lying when we said we stopped scanning emails for ad purposes, but we are still scanning to improve other Google ecosystems tools like Calendar".
- distant_hat 9y agoThey scan emails. I have had airline ticket reservations that my friends emailed to me added on my Calendar.
- pvdebbe 9y agoYikes. That would prove it...
- icebraining 9y ago
- 4684499 9y agoYou are implying friends list is the main factor here. Let's assume you are right. Still, Google may have a database for people you might know, you just don't know its existence yet. They don't have to let you input your contacts voluntarily to find out about your relationships. For example, have you used Google Maps? You search a place, Google tells you popular time of that place, how did they get the data? If they are able to do things like that, they might also be able to know who (or which Google account) you spend time with and where, they just don't have reasons to tell you they have the data or they have deep learned the data for various purposes. We just don't have a whistleblower to testify that they sell the data yet, possibly because they have strict internal confidentiality policies.[1] Disclaimer, about that Google Maps example, it's just my assumption, I don't know how it actually works. [1]: https://www.theinformation.com/articles/employee-lawsuit-accuses-google-of-spying-program https://www.theinformation.com/articles/employee-lawsuit-acc...
- skybrian 9y agoSo you're saying they have lots of personal data (nobody is disputing this). If they have the data, and they let someone else have access to it, it could leak. Which, sure, makes sense. But that's not the same as "know[ing] Google does the same thing" unless you define either "know" or "the same thing" very loosely.
- 4684499 9y agoYou are right. Basically what I'm trying to say is they could do the same thing regardless whether they have your friends lists or not. Indeed, I don't know if Google does the same thing.
- skosch 9y agoIf you have Google Maps running on your phone with data and GPS on, the app will explicitly ask you about your experience in whatever place you're visiting at that moment. I have friends who enthusiastically respond to those notifications every time, arguing that the information will help other users. More people than you think are happy to share more than passive metadata.
- glogla 9y agoGoogle has contact lists, call logs, real-time location and possibly texts from most used smartphone OS. Google has communication graphs and contact lists from the most used email platform. Google has the search logs from your internet searches. Google has web logs from the most used web analytics platform. Google knows a lot.