4 ms·
I sense the same can be said about many medical devices. Firemen came to my house they had a portable digital EKG with 2G data line to push the graph to a doct
by agumonkey 9y ago
I sense the same can be said about many medical devices.
Firemen came to my house they had a portable digital EKG with 2G data line to push the graph to a doctor remotely. The thing couldn't get cell reception, probably a weak modem/antenna. One of the guy hinted at 5000$ unit cost. In terms of screen + processing + com electronics, it's about 50$. Some MD told me there needs to be some precise analog probes and ADC but I doubt it's in the 1000$ range.
Then there are standard validation costs, which are necessary.
The rest comes from premiums due to the medical market IMO. The companies know very well they can get away with such prices so they do, even though it could be pushed down without altering quality or even decent profit for them.
- FireBeyond 9y ago> Firemen came to my house they had a portable digital EKG with 2G data line to push the graph to a doctor remotely. The thing couldn't get cell reception, probably a weak modem/antenna. One of the guy hinted at 5000$ unit cost. If only. As someone in Fire/EMS, a moderately equipped LifePak 12/15? $14,000 to $40,000 depending on configuration - https://www.ogs.ny.gov/purchase/spg/pdfdocs/1260522835PL_PhysioControl.pdf https://www.ogs.ny.gov/purchase/spg/pdfdocs/1260522835PL_Phy... But to also be fair, there's a fair amount going on beyond all that. Defibrillator, including pacing, non invasive measurement of carbon monoxide, certain drugs and chemicals, integrated printer, weather sealed (gotta be able to operate outside in the rain), ruggedized for drops. But still, $40K... oi.
- agumonkey 9y agoYeah that kind of device, made by Phillips in my case. I don't think it had advanced functions like defib.. it felt barely big enough to be an EKG already but Im the noob. That said 14K is ludicrous. The fact the mainstream market is able to sell 200€ smartphone with somehow advanced features is also ludicrous in that context. I guess it's just economy of scale power. But I'm convinced we could make the medical market a bit cheaper. It has serious implications on the whole structure. People will be treated differently based on cost. And in my case, that lack of 2G could have been lethal. I went to a few fablab, these guys are replicating some mundane lab equipment for 1/100 or 1/1000 (can't recall) of the market price. I really liked that mindset.
- rayiner 9y agoThe thing that makes smartphones so damn cheap is you can sell a couple of hundred million of them every year. It’s the same reason consumer grade GPUs and CPUs completely wiped out SGI, Sun, etc. Those companies weren’t incompetent, it’s just the economies of scale are insane.
- FireBeyond 9y ago> I don't think it had advanced functions like defib. I can guarantee that it did. It may even have been an AED. Earlier ones didn't actually display an EKG rhythm, but current models can, and run "reasonably" at about $1,000. If they hooked up either 4 leads or 10 leads to you, then you were getting the full meal deal, so to speak.
- bsder 9y ago> it's about 50$ And if Silicon Valley brogrammers built it, it would fail about 25% of the time, and catch fire the other 5%. But, hey, the fires would make for a great YouTube video--because the video uploader always works. Medical has little to do with cost and lots to do with certification and indemnification. Certification--that defibrillator WILL do what it is supposed to ... or ... Indemnification--if that defibrillator doesn't do what it is supposed to, somebody is out a lot of money.
- agumonkey 9y agoFair enough. In that case I wonder who's gonna pay for that failing cellular module.
- bsder 9y agoThe FDA is notably snotty and humorless about wireless, in general. I am deeply surprised that they would approve something that required a cellular connection to function. I have seen the FDA push back on wireless even when it was completely ancillary to the primary function or when the device had no ability to do anything to anybody. I would be suspicious that a person did something--accidentally gave permission to the cell connection, for example. This is NOT an indictment of competence. LOTS of shit goes wrong when things are in crisis mode. Devices which are perfectly well designed for calm situations can be totally useless because the interface trips you up when amped on adrenaline.
- agumonkey 9y agoThis was in Europe though. I hear your point, but this was probably a main design decision. It's not a portable EKG for MD, it's for rescuers. They're trained for the average situation but they need a second opinion and the ability to transmit your EKG as-is to an actual doctor is probably very useful. Now the frailty of wireless I understand, but in this case it's a bit absurd. Considering a chart is 1000 x 32bit samples (uncompressed). You could almost tweet that today u_u. Anyway, I wish I could discuss with people about the possibility of blending both models. I understand the economy of scales, but maybe some partnership between large mainstream electronics could give medical device suppliers special access to some standard, well rounded/tested at cheap prices even at low volume compared to say cellphones.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- wglb 9y agoIs it possible that you ever ran a medical device through clinical trials? The are demanding and hideously expensive.
- pmorici 9y agoSomething like that is going to be relatively low volume compared a mass market consumer device. Low volume means higher cost.