5 ms·
That was the first thing that I thought as well. This is another program like private prisons. I have a hard time seeing how you can align the incentives of a
by criddell 9y ago
That was the first thing that I thought as well. This is another program like private prisons.
I have a hard time seeing how you can align the incentives of a business like this with greater societal interests.
- stouset 9y agoThat said, I'm hoping they can. I too am skeptical that a for-profit model can work here, but as long as the incentives are appropriately aligned (they profit when incarceration rates drop and recidivism rates decline), there's a possibility it can work.
- maxerickson 9y agoIt'll almost certainly be a fee for service model. (municipalities simply won't write contracts with big rewards tied to incarceration or recidivism rates)
- grivescorbett 9y agoThere is such a thing as for profit for good. Perhaps they believe they can be both better and cheaper than prisons at the same time. That allows them to provide a compelling pitch to governments and convince them to direct funds to Promise instead of prisons. The government wins because it's cheaper, their users win because they are not incarcerated, and they win because they have cash flow. These types of businesses are not impossible to create.
- criddell 9y ago> There is such a thing as for profit for good. Their association with Y Combinator doesn't help with that impression. How many other venture funded start ups exist to provide a societal benefit while making only a modest return? Isn't the goal a big exit? They might not be venture funded yet, but they aren't at Y Combinator for the coffee, right? I know this sounds super cynical, so please tell me why I'm wrong. Why is this a good thing?
- ceejayoz 9y ago> How many other venture funded start ups exist to provide a societal benefit while making only a modest return? YC has a non-profits program. https://www.ycombinator.com/nonprofits/ https://www.ycombinator.com/nonprofits/ I don't see any indication that Promise is going non-profit, though.
- grivescorbett 9y agoWho says anything about a modest return? How much does the U.S. spend on prisons? How much does the world spend on prisons? Say they operate at a 30% discount, how much revenue is that? Off the top of my head, a lot.
- gt_ 9y ago>These types of businesses are not impossible to create. This is amazingly uninformed. Let’s stop pretending private businesses were born yesterday and just consult history. Privatization of human rights is despicable and this is not a lesson that needs to be learned again. Do you know why we never had private prisons before? They incentivize corruption of the most vulnerable fabric of our society. No excuse.
- grivescorbett 9y agoI agree that for-profit prisons are not good for society. But does this one (granted, massive) mistake mean that we can no longer try to innovate in this space? Does it mean that the only model is publicly funded rehabilitation? That's obviously not worked either.
- Jemmeh 9y agoExactly. I think there's a lot of things to consider around it all, for-profit prisons have a LOT of problems. But if we found that microwaving food for prisoners saved a lot of time cooking and thus also the amount of time we had to pay for people to cook for prisons that would be a good thing...at least it would be if that money gets funneled back to the point that a taxpayer is paying less. As it is I assume it just goes into the pocket of whoever runs the for-profit prison.
- criddell 9y ago> does this one (granted, massive) mistake mean that we can no longer try to innovate in this space? No, but we should learn from those mistakes, right? When a company makes money from prisoners and more prisoners mean more money, then the incentives are a problem.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Do you know why we never had private prisons before? You mean, before 1852?
- dminor 9y agoA profit motive can lead to perverse and unforeseen incentives, even despite the best intentions of the founders, who someday will not be running the company. The private prison industry routinely lobbies for higher fines & longer sentences because it is to their benefit to have more people go to prison. Promise appears to have a similar incentive.
- smw 9y agoThis aims to be much closer: http://benefitcorp.net/faq http://benefitcorp.net/faq. Companies with the ability to operate for-profit, but without the obligation for maximizing shareholder profit.
- jpdb 9y agoWould it be more ethical to only profit based on recidivism? Eg, Promise is only paid if the prisoner doesn't go back to prison?
- ceejayoz 9y agoNot necessarily. That gives them a financial incentive to send people their algorithms deem "iffy" to jail instead of accepting them into the program.
- maxerickson 9y agoThe read I have is that they are aiming downstream of the detention decision, providing services related to probation and parole. I wouldn't be real surprised if their initial targets are places that have large, established probation systems, offering the tech as an aid to government employed probation officers. Easier than taking on legal responsibility for the probationers.
- gt_ 9y agoFor anyone wondering, this is definitely sarcasm.
- adamsea 9y agoWell, it wouldn't be recidivism, but rather if the accused committed another crime prior to their trial date. Or, if they missed their trial date. It's easy to keep getting confused around if we're dealing with accused criminals or convicted felons, as both are in jail. Sounds like Promise is focusing on the accused.
- grivescorbett 9y agoYes this would be a very interesting and ethical incentive model to explore.
- phaedradiana 9y agoWe love this! Right now the incentives are wrong. Contractors are paid per person, per day, which creates the wrong incentives.