4 ms·
If your _opinion_ conflicts with reality then the resulting comments are likely to be useless noise and get filtered out. And that is probably going to feel unf
by tialaramex 9y ago
If your _opinion_ conflicts with reality then the resulting comments are likely to be useless noise and get filtered out. And that is probably going to feel unfair to you, but it's actually valuable information.
HN readers find this unremarkable in many types of story. We don't find ourselves wondering if the comment "But five is an even number" for a number theory article might be signal that needs boosting, it's not, whoever wrote that either was joking or wrong, either way it's noise.
- mjh2539 9y agoHow does my opinion conflict with reality? Which of these is "in conflict with reality"? 1. The human embryo is human (this is true by definition); 2. The human embryo is innocent; 3. The human embryo is alive; 4. Murder is the intentional killing of an innocent human life.
- vlan0 9y agoSuper off topic.... Do you also feel the same about murder of other sentient beings?
- tialaramex 9y agoAlthough "Murder is the intentional killing of an innocent human life" sounds like a reasonable definition out of context, you've presented a context in which "innocent human life" just means any human cells that you've arbitrarily judged "innocent". I'm going to guess this dodge is here because you support, or at least wish to avoid antagonising, people who believe that killing other people is a legitimate criminal punishment and so somehow it's not "murder" if the state chooses to do it. Although it's also possible you condone extra-judicial killing, with the same dodge, it's OK to torture somebody to death so long as you know, they're bad guys... Anyway, a more reasonable definition of murder requires the victim to be a _person_ and an embryo is not a person. Personhood is a strange phenomenon, and there's definitely room for a grey area. But embryos aren't in that grey area, not even close.
- mjh2539 9y ago> an embryo is not a person > but embryos aren't in that grey area, not even close. You're begging the question. You haven't provided any reasons or arguments for your position. You've merely re-asserted it. It's akin to saying "It's true that x, because it's true that x". How is my judgement that an embryo is innocent arbitrary? What crime has the embryo committed? What did it do to warrant being killed? The trouble with your position is that you have to make an arbitrary judgement. You have to arbitrarily judge the fetus to be a person at some point. Is it at 12 weeks, 6 days, 32 weeks? The day before it is born? When, exactly? What criteria are you using for making that judgement? Why not the day before? Why not a day later? My position doesn't require making an arbitrary judgement, or answering any of those silly questions. It requires making an intuitive, simple, straightforward observation: from the very moment that the sperm and the ovum meet and the genetic material between the two is exchanged (i.e., the egg is fertilized), a new human life is formed, with its own ends and identity. If nature takes its course, the person either dies naturally and the mother miscarries, or the embryo continues to develop and is subsequently born. Further, I'm not just designating "any human cells" as innocent. I can't just designate "any human cells" and make them develop in the way that an embryo or a fetus develop. I'm talking about a specific group of spells, easily identifiable as distinct from the cells of the mother, that act in unison and coordination with one another through pregnancy to further develop the human being that has been there from the very beginning. If that is an arbitrary grouping of human cells, then I don't see how the same point can't be made to you, or to me (simply being an arbitrary collection of human cells), but everyone would recognize that this (you are an arbitrary collection of human cells, in contrast to a fully-fledged human 'life') would be absurd. In addition, you seem to be implying that we need to use different definitions of murder in different contexts, but I don't see that's the case. How isn't the definition I provided inclusive of every instance of murder?
- RobertoG 9y agoSomething that deeply bother me about the "pro-life" stance is its hypocrisy. They put advertisements about "protecting life" and use "life" and "humanity" all the time in their discourse, but that have nothing to do with what they think. What they think, normally, is in the line of "in the moment of the conception an immaterial entity take hold in the zygote". For some reason, they refuse to discuss that. They believe in an immaterial soul but they hide their real beliefs in their discussion of the issue. Of course, I don't know if this is so in your specific case, but I know other cases where it is.
- hcknwscommenter 9y agoAssertion #1 is problematic here. As best I can parse it, you are saying, the human embryo is [of human origin]. That is very different from "the human embryo is a human." Most scientists and non-religious scholars and philosophers would disagree with the latter statement. Assertion #3 is also problematic. You need a definition of alive that is both non-arbitrary and does not include skin cells, cancer cells (which can reproduce indefinitely), etc. Assertion #4 is very interesting, and I think has been well-treated by other commentators. Basically, you have asserted a syllogistic like statement that completely falls apart when examined closely. The attempt to save it by asserting that assertion number 1 is true by definition does not work. Assertion number 1 is only true by definition for trivial interpretations of assertion #1 (i.e., the human embryo is a collection of human cells).
- HyperTalk2 9y agoI find how HN completely hides comments with a "[flagged]" replacement a bit insulting as a reader. We're all adults and I'm sure we can handle reading whatever he wrote. Instead we have to guess what you are responding to.