4 ms·
Do you have evidence for this? (Note: I'm looking for something a bit stronger than "Country X has gun prohibition, a different social structure, different dem
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
Do you have evidence for this?
(Note: I'm looking for something a bit stronger than "Country X has gun prohibition, a different social structure, different demographics and different laws, and has lower homicide rate than Country Y which does not have gun prohibition.")
- thailandstartup 16y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_gun_ownership http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_gun_owners... Countries that have prohibitions on firearms have fewer firearms. It's a huge difference in the numbers and that's an example of prohibition working. I don't know that countries that have prohibitions on drugs reduce drug taking by the same amount, or countries with prohibitions on prostitution reduces prostitution by a similar amount. Mexico is an outlier because of its large porous border with the US. Switzerland is just an outlier.
- kelnos 16y ago> Countries that have prohibitions on firearms have fewer firearms. It's a huge difference in the numbers and that's an example of prohibition working. Who cares? You're working from a premise that having fewer firearms is a good thing. I'm not going to say I disagree, but I'm not sure I agree either. The real metric is whether or not firearm-related crimes are significantly reduced in countries where there are prohibitions on firearms. There's also the question of whether firearm use matters in some crimes. Take these two scenarios: 1. Burglar commits armed (firearms) robbery of a house. Owners of the house are suitably frightened but give in to the burglars. Stuff is stolen but no one gets hurt. 2. Burglar commits armed (knives) robbery of a house. Owners of the house are suitably frightened but give in to the burglars. Stuff is stolen but no one gets hurt. They are essentially the same crime, but now #2 is not lumped in with the "firarms-related crime" group. And let's try keeping #1 as it is, but now #2 is this: 2'. Burglar commits armed (knives) robbery of a house. Owners of the house think a knife isn't too scary and fight back. One owner gets stabbed and dies. I don't know about the frequency of stuff like this, but it's certainly not a quick "look at the numbers" thing to decide which is better.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThe real metric is whether or not firearm-related crimes are significantly reduced in countries where there are prohibitions on firearms. No, the real metric is whether or not firearms cause a net increase in the amount/severity of crimes - firearm crimes are not the only relevant ones. There are all sorts of factors which make it a tricky question. Deterrence (burglar is afraid to rob a house, since homeowners might shoot him) is a fairly big effect. Substitution (criminal 1 wants to kill criminal 2, since no guns are around he uses a knife) are some of the biggies. If criminals stab 20 people instead of shooting 15, that's not a good thing.
- kelnos 16y agoNo, the real metric is whether or not firearms cause a net increase in the amount/severity of crimes - firearm crimes are not the only relevant ones. How can you draw causal relationships there? At best I'd think you'd be able to make correlative arguments, but not much more.
- barrkel 16y agoThe real metric is whether or not firearm-related crimes are significantly reduced in countries where there are prohibitions on firearms. http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_mur_wit_fir_percap-crime-murders-firearms-per-capita http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/cri_mur_wit_fir_percap-cri... Contrast US with UK and Ireland. Actually, I think US cultural exports are a large factor in the increase of gun crime in the UK and Ireland, a certain glorification of the weapon that gang members feel they need to live up to.