4 ms·
Non-driving advocates have pointed out that many investigations of car crashes with pedestrians and cyclists tend to blame the pedestrian/cyclist by reflex and
by jcranmer 9y ago
Non-driving advocates have pointed out that many investigations of car crashes with pedestrians and cyclists tend to blame the pedestrian/cyclist by reflex and generally refuse to search for exculpatory evidence.
Based on the layout of the presumed crash site (namely, the median had a paved section that would effectively make this an unmarked crosswalk), and based on the fact that the damage being all on the passenger's side (which is to say, the pedestrian would have had to have crossed most of the lane before being struck), I would expect that there is a rather lot that could have been done on the driver's side (whether human or autonomous) to avoid the crash.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- alanh 9y agoYour passenger's side comment didn’t make sense to me until I read the Forbes article linked above: > Herzberg is said to have abruptly walked from a center median into a lane with traffic So that explains that. However, contrary to the thrust of your argument, the experience of the sober driver, who was ready to intervene if needed, is hard to dismiss: > “The driver said it was like a flash, the person walked out in front of them,” Moir said. “His first alert to the collision was the sound of the collision.” And also: > “It’s very clear it would have been difficult to avoid this collision in any kind of mode [autonomous or human-driven] based on how she came from the shadows right into the roadway,” Moir told the paper, adding that the incident occurred roughly 100 yards from a crosswalk. “It is dangerous to cross roadways in the evening hour when well-illuminated managed crosswalks are available,” she said.
- mirimir 9y agoYes, I see. So she walked maybe 2 meters into the lane before being hit. At a slow walk (1 meter/second) that's 2 seconds. At 17 meters/second, that's 34 meters. And it's about twice nominal disengagement time. So yes, it's iffy.
- dotancohen 9y agoAnd at a moderate sprint, like most adults do when they try to cross a roadway with vehicular traffic, that is 4-5 m/s, giving the vehicle 0.4 - 0.5 seconds to stop. 40 MPH ~ 18 m/s that gives the vehicle 7-9 meters to stop. No human could brake that well, and simply jamming the brakes would engage the ABS leading to a longer stopping distance. Not to mention the human reaction time of 0.5 - 0.75 seconds would have prevented most people from even lifting the foot off the accelerator pedal before the collision, even if they were perfectly focused on driving.
- aianus 9y ago> simply jamming the brakes would engage the ABS leading to a longer stopping distance I was taught that the entire point of ABS is so that you can just jam the brake and have the shortest stopping time instead of modulating it yourself to avoid skidding. Do you have any source to the contrary?
- kalleboo 9y agoI was taught the point of ABS was to keep control over steering while stepping on the brakes instead of skidding out of control into god knows what/who Wikipedia backs me up but adds that it also decreases stopping distance on dry and slippery surfaces, while significantly increasing stopping distances in snow and gravel. I’m from a country with a lot of snow so that makes sense.
- carlmr 9y agoThat's correct. The ABS basically takes away the brake pressure as soon as the wheels block. On most surfaces this will shorten your stopping distance versus a human blocking the tires. It is never the optimal stopping distance though. In terms of split second reactions, it's pretty much optimal still to just jam the brakes if you have ABS. It's much better than braking too little, which is what most non-ABS drivers would have done.
- hvidgaard 9y ago