8 ms·
> According to the Chronicle, the preliminary investigation found the Uber car was driving at 38 mph in a 35 mph zone and did not attempt to brake. Herzberg is
by danso 9y ago
> According to the Chronicle, the preliminary investigation found the Uber car was driving at 38 mph in a 35 mph zone and did not attempt to brake. Herzberg is said to have abruptly walked from a center median into a lane with traffic. Police believe she may have been homeless.
I know this isn't the most pertinent issue here, but I'm surprised the self-driving AI is allowed to speed, though with further research, this seems to be the case with Google/Waymo software too:
http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-28851996 http://www.bbc.com/news/technology-28851996
Though in that BBC article (which is from 2014), the stated scenario is when the self-driving car is surrounded by traffic exceeding the speed limit. It doesn't sound like this was the case for the Uber vehicle.
- drewg123 9y agoNot speeding would cause it to impede traffic flow. Speed limits are often set for revenue generation, not safety.
- jcranmer 9y agoOn a 35 mph road with no traffic to impede, there is no reason to speed.
- hamandcheese 9y agoThere is always a reason to speed: getting from point A to point B faster.
- ronilan 9y agoThere can be several ways to explain this but generally speaking you are right. It shouldn’t go over the speed limit, and under no circumstances should it take the liberty drivers usually take of being within 10% above the limit. I hope no one wrote it that way.
- emodendroket 9y agoI don't think that's true at all. There was an article posted about the subject a while ago, but the thrust of it was that researchers think they need to do more to make cars behave like (fully attentive) human drivers rather than being weird anomalies that behave in surprising/irritating (to humans) ways if they're going to actually go on the road, and I think that's completely right.
- BillTheBiker 9y ago"(fully attentive) human drivers" probably cause deadly accidents every day, and they certainly behave in surprising/irritating ways. Anyways, a human driver going the speed limit is no hazard, so I fail to see how having self-driving cars follow the limits could be a problem.
- emodendroket 9y agoAutonomous cars need to share the road with human drivers, so they should not behave in a way that is surprising to humans, to the extent possible.
- CamperBob2 9y agoWhy not? The range between 1-10 MPH over the speed limit is statistically the safest. (Yes, I know, good luck finding a citation for a study I read 20 years ago...) It's hard to argue against the notion that you're safest when you keep up with prevailing traffic. That means that self-driving cars shouldn't be programmed to go slower. Speed limits are usually too low. Often they have nothing to do with engineering or safety considerations, but are primarily revenue-oriented. If the advent of autonomous vehicles forces regulators to listen to the engineers for a change, that will be an unalloyed Good Thing.
- URSpider94 9y agoMan, sorry for the downvotes. This link -> http://www.lsp.org/pdf/troopc85thSpeed.pdf http://www.lsp.org/pdf/troopc85thSpeed.pdf doesn't include any references, unfortunately, but the statements are that: -- 55% of drivers regularly exceed the speed limit, meaning that the speed limit represents the 45th percentile speed -- driving between the 50th and 90th percentile speeds is the safest Taken together, driving at the speed limit is significantly unsafe.
- omarforgotpwd 9y agoOf course a self driving car should be able to speed. My understanding is that speed limits are set by measuring the speed people are driving on the road and then determining a speed at which roughly 15% of the drivers are exceeding that limit. There is an expectation that people will speed, but by setting the speed limit a little bit lower almost all traffic will fall under safe bounds. Driving 38 in a 35 zone is completely reasonable. I probably would have been going 45 - 50 if the road was empty. If self driving cars aren't allowed to speed, they're going to be a nightmare for passengers and other drivers. Obviously different people have different feelings about the issue of speeding, but personally I lose my mind when I get an Uber driver that's driving to slow. Try and think about what it would be like if a computer followed every traffic restriction to the letter of the law rather than driving like an actual human. People will vote me down because the idea of a speeding self driving car sounds scary, but I personally can't wait until the software has advanced to the state that it can confidently drive 200 mph on the 5 from LA to the Bay Area. (Presumably they'd have to build a much bigger better 5, with special lanes dedicated to autonomous vehicles)
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago>> People will vote me down because the idea of a speeding self driving car sounds scary Or because they don't think that speed limits are set so that everyone can keep under them- but so that keeping under them means you're driving safely.
- naveen99 9y agoWhat speed would you drive if there was no speed limit ?
- franciscop 9y agoWhat speed would you drive? Would you take close corners at 120km/h? People (on average) drive at the speed their actually very well tuned survival instinct tells them to.
- in_cahoots 9y ago
- bichiliad 9y agoThis is probably less the case with self-driving cars, as I imagine they're using pretty new or well-maintained vehicles, but there's usually a 5mph leeway with speed limits due to slightly mis-calibrated speedometers. I anecdotally remember hearing this being the reason for speed limits that end in "5" rather than being multiples of 10. https://travel.stackexchange.com/questions/40113/do-any-states-in-the-us-give-traffic-tickets-for-5-mph-above-the-speed-limit https://travel.stackexchange.com/questions/40113/do-any-stat...
- protomyth 9y agoWouldn’t that be mitigated by the GPS and the map? It would seem that an automated car using maps as an important input would no its exact position and therefore speed.
- bichiliad 9y agoThat could easily be the case, sure. Some other people mentioned that it could be just to more closely emulate a human driver. I don't think we'll have a good answer without knowing the implementation.
- __david__ 9y agoGPS can be remarkably bad in urban environments. You can't really trust it for second-to-second speed or positioning. It's only really good for long term/high level planning. For speed, the wheel sensors are going to be way more reliable and consistent.
- asteli 9y agoThe typical approach is to fuse GPS, inertial, and wheelspeed sensors to track a vehicle's motion in space. They all have their shortcomings, and all compensate for each other. GPS is, as you said, wildly inaccurate, disconcertingly often. Wheelspeed is great when you're moving, but at low speed it tends not to have the granularity you want. Inertial sensors are pretty amazing nowadays, but they still drift. To illustrate, if your wheels aren't moving, then you can ignore the IMU telling you that you're sinking into the ground at 5mm/s. Watching the monitor of a mapping vehicle as it depicts the car returning to mother Earth is pretty hysterical though. Until you have to fix it.
- vadimberman 9y agoI remember early reports about self-driving experiments saying that some of the issues where because the cars were driving at the speed limit, which is usually not the case in the US with the human drivers. Maybe they decided to change it.
- noobermin 9y agoIf they just track human driver habits then we're no more safer! What's the point left about self-driving cars then? Free up drivers of even more responsibility when they kill people?
- scythe 9y agoThe #1 cause of collisions is inattention, which ought to be impossible with automated cars.
- supergarfield 9y ago> Free up drivers of even more responsibility when they kill people? That's a strange way to put it. Surely if someone is not driving their car, they can't be responsible if the car kills people (assuming of course the car was well-maintained and the model was legal). I don't see how that's a bad thing, since they have zero control over the situation. Do you mean that it could make car users feel less responsible for deaths, even though cars will presumably still kill people?
- noobermin 9y agoI'm not sure if you meant it, but you essentially answered my question with a "yes." It's to absolve individuals of responsibility in killing people. If that's the case then I'm not sure how it is a benefit to society.
- manfredo 9y agoResponsibility isn't being absolved, it's being shifted to the one that actually operates the vehicle - probably either the car vendor (who either manufactured or licensed the self-driving car software), or the fleet operator depending on what kind of sales and operations model self-driving cars adopt. When human escalator operators were replaced with automatic escalators, was there are problem with shifting responsibility over to Otis and other escalator manufacturers? As with automatic escalators, there are two primary benefits to society: greater aggregate safety[1], and freeing up people's time. You point to the lack of a human operator to hold responsible as a detriment, but the statistics point the other way around: human drivers are horribly irresponsible and even if we can punish them when they do wrong that doesn't substantially change their behavior. Freeing up people's time is self-explanatory.
- freehunter 9y agoIt may not be programmed to speed per se, but if you’ve ever had cruise control turned on you’ll know it doesn’t keep you exactly at 55mpg. It might be 54 with the throttle applied to speed up, or it might be 57 which doesn’t trigger the brakes yet but is coasting to a slower speed. Imagine the car in front of you cycling rapidly between the gas and brake pedal to keep the speed exactly at 55mph. One, that’s completely impossible with how cars are designed, and two that’s really illogical. Cars have to follow the laws of physics too.
- lkhjyuio 9y ago"completely impossible" You, sir are not an engineer. "really illogical" And you lack vision. "laws of physics" Nice appeal to authority.
- CydeWeys 9y agoThere is no brake involved with cruise control. What you are describing is bad drivers who do not use cruise control. It's actually extremely pleasant and predictable to be following a driver who is using cruise control. Following a well-regulated self-driving car would be similar.
- to3m 9y agoMy car has cruise control with brake functionality. Not sure if I've ever seen it actually do it - I only really use cruise control on the motorway, where I expect wind resistance is a major factor - but apparently it will apply the brakes to maintain the set speed when necessary. At town speeds I would expect it to use the brakes a lot more readily. At 30mph in 3rd (2000rpm) or 4th (1500rpm) there's not really all that much engine braking, and wind resistance won't slow it much either. (Mine is a 2010 model, but I think this stuff was introduced in 2004-6, something like that... it's not exactly new technology.)
- gaelian 9y agoMy car absolutely uses the break when required to maintain the set cruise control speed, I've watched it happen. The car I owned before my current car didn't use the break to keep to the set cruise control speed though, so I get why you may think there is no break involved. It largely seems to depend on make and cost of the car you're driving.
- arvinds 9y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/SelfDrivingCars/comments/85ozqr/exclusive_tempe_police_chief_says_early_probe/dvz5ztt/ https://www.reddit.com/r/SelfDrivingCars/comments/85ozqr/exc...
- jamie_ca 9y agoAs another driver on the road, I'd far rather that autonomous vehicles maintain speed with the flow of traffic around them, in lieu of strictly sticking to the posted limit.
- cpncrunch 9y agoThere is no traffic "around" them, just the car behind. And if the car behind is speeding it's up to them to slow down if the car in front is obeying the speed limit. This kind of argument is just used to justify speeding.
- tarheeljason 9y ago> There is no traffic "around" them, just the car behind. How about when merging, or changing lanes? The speed limit is not _always_ safe or practical to obey strictly.
- cpncrunch 9y ago>How about when merging, or changing lanes? The speed limit is not _always_ safe or practical to obey strictly. In the case of overtaking, you just need to make sure you don't cut someone off in the overtaking lane. No need to go over the speed limit just because you're too impatient to wait for a proper gap in the traffic. I've never seen a situation where you're merging onto a freeway and everyone in the right-most lane is speeding excessively. That would be a very dangerous situation, and if you yourself go significantly faster than the speed limit to merge you're just adding to the dangerous problem.
- lhorie 9y agoYou don't seem to drive. If you don't follow traffic flow, people will cut off in front of you, tailgate, zigzag, and do other dangerous lane changes/maneuvers much more frequently. And that's when the trigger-happy ones don't yell obscenities at you.
- cpncrunch 9y ago
- eanzenberg 9y agoId rather the cars travel at safer speeds than an arbitrary speed limit which is 99% of the time unsafe.