4 ms·
I love Hawking, but I have to play apologist here (and I am not a religious person) I've spent many, many hours on this God thing, and at the end of the day yo
by DanielBMarkham 16y ago
I love Hawking, but I have to play apologist here (and I am not a religious person)
I've spent many, many hours on this God thing, and at the end of the day you can't prove nor disprove there is a God. Sure, you can assume all sorts of attributes about a God that don't make sense or are silly -- big old guy with beard in the sky. But the idea that there is some greater intelligence out there with some sort of interest in mankind? It's just impossible to know, one way or another.
Now some will tell you that because it is impossible to know, there must be a god. I.e, that we can put whatever thing we like under the category "god" -- one story is as good as another. Actually, this "creative story-telling for stuff we don't know" is a critical part of being a human, even being a scientist. As long as the stories don't contradict observable reality. So that's okay, up to a point.
Some will tell you that because we don't know, there must not be a God. If you can't prove it, it doesn't exist. Or put better: why add terms to an equation where no extra terms are needed? You see this in Hawking's essay -- once we figured out the theory, didn't need a God anymore.
The problem here is that this smacks of the caveman, when told about airplanes, said that the other person was either a fantastical liar or crazy. In his mind he is being uber-rational. From our point of view he's being childish and silly. Certainly things exist that we have not experienced. We do not know everything, and many things we think we know we are mistaken about. This is the way it has always been. It is part of being our species at this point in time.
So we're left not-knowing. And that bugs folks. I had a good friend that was an atheist tell me last week that sure, he didn't know, but he felt like he had to take sides. He felt like certain Christians he knew were somehow harming rationality, and it was up to him to sort of balance the scales. Many other people are profoundly disturbed by not-knowing and go the other way.
As for me? I've decided that while I cannot accept your story about an angry guy in the sky, the idea of not-knowing -- and the greater idea of our relationship to not-knowing, our relationship to the unknown, is a critical part of being alive. I choose to call that Great Unknown God, simply because, well, that's the traditional name for powers that are outside of our scope of knowledge. This allows me to enjoy both the work of the scientist and the priest.
- alexandros 16y agoWhat Hawking said is not that god does not exist, but that god is not required for the universe to exist. Subtle but important.
- steve19 16y agoEvolution is not required for Homo sapiens to exist. The above statement does not in any way infer that evolution did not result in humans. Subtle but important.
- jeromec 16y agoEvolution is not required for Homo sapiens to exist. How do you know? If you were framing your statement scientifically it would be "Evolution may not be required for Homo sapiens to exist", which, of course, scientists already understand. Theories are subject to change, and even be discarded altogether in light of better information, unlike faith which cannot change.
- steve19 16y agoYour definition of faith is very narrow. What certain institutions define as faith may not have changed in thousands of years. Peoples personal beliefs and understanding of the spiritual change over time. I know mine have.
- jeromec 16y agoFaith that a Creator exists without verifiable proof is inherently unchangeable -- that's why it's called faith. How one chooses to arrive at, or express that faith certainly may be subject to change.
- sigzero 16y agoThat is correct. He also doesn't prove his point at all. Subtle but important.
- oozcitak 16y agoYour last paragraph nails it. God is an alias and hence doesn't need proving or disproving. There is this huge closet containing the questions we do not have answers for. Some people name this closet God; scientists call it "TODO". You can call it whatever you like, as long as: 1. You accept that questions can be removed from and (more frequently) new questions can be added to the closet. 2. You do not add a question we already have an answer for into the closet. 3. You do not remove a question from the closet unless you have an answer.
- henrikgs 16y agoThe problem with using the God alias is that most people do one more fundamental thing with this closet. They put answers into it on questions we have no way of knowing answers to.
- ErrantX 16y agoSee it's weird but that stuff has never worried me, from a rational perspective anyway. It's all about knowledge voids and what we use to fill it (pretty much as you say in the last paragraph). But I've always been amused to see Atheists getting all het up about the non-existence of God (it's the main reason I don't identify as one). It is as if disproof is fundamental to their understanding of the universe. My take is pretty simple; I have absolutely no idea of any of the big answers (and even some of the little ones) but I'm pretty excited to see the progress being made and, maybe, I might get some more awesome answers in my life time. Beyond that, what does it matter :) The perspective is that we are a tiny dot on a tiny dot on a pinhead in the centre of an ocean. No matter what you believe about the origins and future of the universe our time here is barely a flicker - it doesn't seem worth worrying about not having the answers, instead lets go grab all we can before it's over :)
- jeromec 16y agoSo does your "Great Unknown" have sentience? That's the question. If I understand you correctly it appears you are theist.
- mike-cardwell 16y ago"at the end of the day you can't prove nor disprove there is a God" Correct. In the same way you can't disprove that a race of super intelligent massive squid like monsters live at the center of the earth. There are an infinite number of things which: 1.) We have no evidence that they exist 2.) They don't exist There are only a finite number of things which: 1.) We have no evidence that they exist 2.) They exist What puts God into the second category rather than the first? The first contains unimaginably more things...
- wazoox 16y ago> I've spent many, many hours on this God thing, and at > the end of the day you can't prove nor disprove there > is a God. Just a slight detail : you can't prove or disprove there aren't unicorns, or an invisible dragon in my garage, or a teapot in orbit between the Earth and Mars (just to take well-known overused examples). Non-existence is the default state of anything you can think about. You need to prove that things do exist, not the other way around. Therefore unless you proved something exists, it doesn't exist. Nobody would ever seriously discuss that conclusion on any other subject than God, that's getting tiring, admit it.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoGoing to reply (against my preferences) here because I'm seeing this repeated. Looks like you are making the mistake several other commenters are: you are ascribing some specific attribute to the word "God" and then throwing rocks at it. Are you asking me if a giant squid exists somewhere? Probably not. Unicorns that can sing and dance? Highly unlikely. FSG? I kinda don't think so. But you're the person making up the details. Yes, any detailed explanation of anything that is unknown is more likely false than true. But to say "therefore unless you proved something exists, it doesn't exist" is the height of fallacy. Lots of things exist that I (or nobody else) can prove. That's my point: in your eagerness for some kind of "answer" you jump too far the other way -- nothing exists unless I can prove it. This is as bad, really, as those who have some large detailed story of a Flying Spaghetti monster that they "know" to be true. If you don't know, you don't know. That's it. End of story. Looking back through history, I can say with some degree of confidence that whatever our world-of-knowledge was at any one time, there has always been a bigger world that we were unaware of. Many times a world for which we have no language to describe. Hard to talk about Quantum Dynamics with Francis Bacon. For every pond we swim around in, there is always a bigger pond. This leads me to believe that the unknown is a huge part of our experience. A Great Unknown exists with things in it that will highly interest us and affect our lives. This is just from induction. Not a particular myth that you might find fault with -- the unknown itself. The idea that nothing exists effectively unless we can prove it is a horrible idea. It's really, well, fundamentalism, when you get right down to it. So you can go on arguing octopuses, pink elephants, Thor, whatever. It really has no relevance on what I'm talking about. If you'd like to call the unknown Thor, have at it. Works for me. I like Thor better than "Bob". But let's not fight over particulars, because that misses the point entirely. As Hawking put it in another article, there might be a philosopher's God, but he's not somebody that could come down and talk to you. Hawking here still goes off the deep end -- I have no idea if something unknown to me could communicate to me or not. Or -- to put my response to Hawking differently -- can the laws of physics still be valid and things happen for which I have no explanation? Why of course they can. That's just common sense. The opposite belief -- that somehow mankind has a model of reality such that nothing unusual can happen? That's as bad as other folks who think their holy book is a science book. Both groups of people are assuming a certainty that just isn't there.