3 ms·
If it's not obvious to you, then the crimes of these people must then be obvious, no? https://www.forbes.com/billionaires/list/ https://www.forbes.com/billionai
by dmix 9y ago
If it's not obvious to you, then the crimes of these people must then be obvious, no? https://www.forbes.com/billionaires/list/ https://www.forbes.com/billionaires/list/
Care to share a few of them which generated their wealth?
- dieterrams 9y agoObvious criminality is not the same as obvious non-criminality. You seem to be getting pretty worked up about this. The reason I don’t think the claim is obviously untrue is because I believe the magnitude of wealth involved, and often the scale of operations/actors, increase the probability of actions ranging from morally dubious but legal to outright criminal. Per one of your other replies, we can quibble about the quote and what “behind every great fortune” means, exactly. You seem to be interpreting it to say that criminal action was a major factor responsible for the fortune, while I interpret it more loosely, the impact being irrelevant. At any rate, I doubt the quote is meant to be taken strictly literally, and is more of an aphorism.
- dredmorbius 9y agoA fair bit of the point (and much the discussion of the quote's origins, which, again, I've rather pointedly linked) is the notion that the crime is not obvious, but of an undiscovered crime. As in the (translated) version of an actual Balzac version of the concept: "The secret of a great success for which you are at a loss to account is a crime that has never been found out, because it was properly executed." The concept is metaphorical, but it is not without any merits. And there may be other elements, either on their own or in addition to, that crime, which accounts for the wealth. Blind luck (or some measure of luck-and-skill) being among the less-accounted-for in many instances. As to the list you present, I see among the several monopolists, operators in corrupt countries, gambling and gaming, coal and fossil fuels industries, advertising, and financial services, numerous fairly obvious crimes, in at least a moral sense, though yes, also, quite often literally criminal.