10 ms·
Stamos had been actively engaging with security researchers on Twitter over the past few days about CA with heated discussions: > I have deleted my Tweets on C
by minimaxir 9y ago
Stamos had been actively engaging with security researchers on Twitter over the past few days about CA with heated discussions:
> I have deleted my Tweets on Cambridge Analytica, not because they were factually incorrect but because I should have done a better job weighing in.
https://twitter.com/alexstamos/status/975069709140877312 https://twitter.com/alexstamos/status/975069709140877312
Archive of those deleted tweets: https://twitter.com/aprilaser/status/975078309930311680 https://twitter.com/aprilaser/status/975078309930311680
EDIT: Stamos responds to news:
> Despite the rumors, I'm still fully engaged with my work at Facebook. It's true that my role did change. I'm currently spending more time exploring emerging security risks and working on election security.
https://twitter.com/alexstamos/status/975875310896914433 https://twitter.com/alexstamos/status/975875310896914433
- danso 9y agoWondering what he thought would be him doing "a better job weighing in"? It seems like his deleted tweets were apparently too honest? i.e. in arguing that there was no data breach, he argued that FB's API and TOS allowed (without oversight) for all app developers to do the kind of data harvesting Cambridge Analytics did? That was well-known by developers, but I guess it's different stating it as an official policy.
- Analemma_ 9y agoIn political circles, this is what is called a "Kinsley gaffe": when somebody accidentally tells the truth (and then has to hastily walk it back)
- chatmasta 9y agoTranslation, "I pissed off my boss"
- beager 9y agoEssentially admitting that the amount of information harvested was not unauthorized but rather by design.
- AFNobody 9y agoIts corporate speak for "The PR department and/or my boss gave me marching orders to delete them."
- this_user 9y agoAnd probably the legal department too. He was inadvertently delivering ammunition to anyone who might want to come after the company for this, which seems like something that might very well happen.
- AFNobody 9y agoYup but Legal is probably smart enough to realize deleting it won't make it go away tho.
- gdulli 9y agoI can easily see how FB wants to throw CA under the bus and make it look like data theft while the truth FB wants to draw attention away from is that this is the system working as intended. Or if not technically "intended" then well within the boundaries of what FB is willing to tolerate as long as it's making them money.
- threeseed 9y agoCambridge Analytica took data from a third party app against the terms and conditions and has alleged to have wilfilly lied both to Facebook and congressional committess about what they did with the data. They absolutely deserve most of the blame.
- gowld 9y agoThere's "willfully lied" and there's "played the game by the unwritten rules"
- jimsmart 9y ago...and then there's admitting (on film) to using bribes and sex workers to entrap politicians, amongst other illegal shennanigans. I can totally understand why Facebook suddenly want to distance themselves from Cambridge Analytica. https://www.channel4.com/news/cambridge-analytica-revealed-trumps-election-consultants-filmed-saying-they-use-bribes-and-sex-workers-to-entrap-politicians-investigation https://www.channel4.com/news/cambridge-analytica-revealed-t...
- FireBeyond 9y agoHow is CA legally bound to Facebook because of Terms and Conditions between Facebook and that app? Like you said, third party app - there was no agreement between Facebook and CA?
- nerfhammer 9y agoIt sounds like CA and FB had other contracts for other stuff, given other news that FB has banned CA and related from other stuff.
- benmmurphy 9y agoI don't understand why he deleted that. It seems a reasonable summary. When I originally saw his tweet about the deletion I thought he may of gone on some crazy rant.
- gdulli 9y ago> I don't understand why he deleted that Well it made his company look bad and now he's gone from that company ahead of schedule. Sometimes things are as simple as they seem on the surface.
- 734786710934 9y agohttps://twitter.com/alexstamos/status/975767154145415168 https://twitter.com/alexstamos/status/975767154145415168 "I never expected them to disappear, I was hoping to reduce the rate at which people were intentionally misreading them." Why Facebook employees are doing PR on Twitter, a platform designed for intentional misreading, is the question.
- chatmasta 9y agoThe man makes some extremely reasonable points. I just wrote a comment along the same lines. I'm glad to see there is some common sense at Facebook. Stamos always seemed a bit too rational to be working at a company like that. I worry what will happen to Facebook after he leaves; they were lucky to have him. Also, I think the real problem here is that the media is attempting to politicize the term "breach," and security professionals are rightly offended.
- karmelapple 9y agoHow would you define the term breach? Is it fair to use the term breach from the perspective of the user whose data has been acquired? Or is breach only in reference to what the company that collected the data intended to do with it? There’s also seemingly two types of breaches at play: 1. The idea of a security breach, where a company gets “hacked” 2. The idea of a breach of trust, where people had given a company data in good faith that it would not be abused, and then had it abused, even going against that company’s TOS
- rhizome 9y agoRight, "breach (of trust)" is the terminology getting bandied about, and is absolutely more accurate, but I think it still obscures the issue.
- chatmasta 9y agoThis is the difficult question at the heart of the matter. Certainly I am accustomed to hearing "breach" in the context of a "security breach," in which a third party accesses data without authorization by circumventing technical measures restricting such access. In this case, there was no such security breach. The Facebook API worked as designed, and returned all data according to spec, TOS, and API documentation. The case of a "breach of trust" is a different story, and the problem emerges when you realize that what defines "private data" (the plunder from a breach) is nothing more than an arbitrary set of restrictions, set forth by the platform producing the data itself. Without Facebook, none of this data would exist. Without the Facebook API, no app would be able to collect this data within a sanctioned platform. Because Facebook exists, and because Facebook offers an API to its data, Cambridge Analytica was able to collect "private data" on users. But it never needed to circumvent any technical barriers to collecting the data it extracted. The Facebook API and platform willingly supplied the data to Cambridge Analytica, as it did and does to thousands of other apps. If it constitutes a breach that Facebook supplied that data to Cambridge Analytica, then there must exist some "bug," technical or not, that Cambridge Analytica exploited to gain access to the data. What is the bug? Can Facebook identify it, document it, and rectify it? If not, can Facebook really classify it as a breach? The fact is, there was no bug. The Facebook API and platform worked as designed and documented, and supplied all data as expected to Cambridge Analytica, along with user authorization to supply that data. If Facebook were to classify this as a breach, they must also point to the "bug" or "vulnerability," or whatever they want to call this, that enabled and precipitated the breach. Unfortunately, there is nothing for Facebook to point to, because the real vulnerability is the system itself. Facebook created an ecosystem of private data, and Facebook defined the boundaries for access to it. Facebook cannot claim an app, that was explicitly within the boundaries of its ecosystem, utilized the Facebook API in a way that constitutes a "breach." Facebook is the only entity in control of the boundaries defining a breach, or what exactly constitutes "private" data, so trying to call this a "breach" is like changing the rules mid-game.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 9y agoNote that Stamos' clarification doesn't contradict the NYT, which says he effectively gave 8 months notice in December, a notice period he'd now be just 3 months into.
- metafunctor 9y agoAgreed. But, what is your point? That HN shouldn't crucify Stamos, there is something else more important we should be looking at?
- tptacek 9y agoJust that Stamos' clarification doesn't really clarify anything in the NYT story itself.
- metafunctor 9y agoYeah. The timing's weird, but stranger things have happened...
- tptacek 9y agoWhat's weird about the timing? I assume NYT ran it as soon as they could confirm it, and that Alex commented as soon as it was published. The timing here seems pretty straightforward.
- metafunctor 9y agoI took another look, and the timing is, in fact, not weird at all—thanks for pointing this out. This news is not very exciting.
- tptacek 9y agoWait: Stamos' tweet isn't exciting. The NYT story is huge news.
- Camillo 9y agoIn the deleted tweets, he was using "breach" in the narrow sense of computer security, basically saying "my team didn't mess up, we didn't get hacked". There are two problems with that: 1) That view is already too narrow for practical security engineering. It's not enough to have a technically correct solution, you need to consider the entire product to ensure that it has the expected security properties in the way it's actually used. 2) Worse, it ignores how the message is going to be interpreted outside of the computer security field, which is especially important when the company is under political scrutiny. For a C-level executive, it seems like an unfortunate lapse.
- mml 9y agoAs a point of anecdata, I worked with Alex in 2005. He's a standup guy, and one of the best in the business. I think what's missed in this conversation, is that this sort of shenanigans isn't really in the purview of a CIO anyway. Too bad he got himself mixed up in it.
- duxup 9y agoIt wasn't a breach.... because Facebook straight up let it happen. I can see why Facebook would not want that out there.