3 ms·
> It also seems absurd on its face - they're essentially claiming to be able to not only do a accurate psychological classification on someone based on what th
by dmix 9y ago
> It also seems absurd on its face - they're essentially claiming to be able to not only do a accurate psychological classification on someone based on what they post online, but actually use that to work out how to manipulate their minds.
This is not dissimilar to the idea that Russia spending a few million dollars on Facebook ads and automated Twitter bots somehow played a defining role in influencing an election. Even within the context of 1.5yrs+ of 24/7 mainstream TV/internet news coverage, billions of dollars in marketing spend by both parties, the personal influence of two of the most famous celebrities in American history (Clintons and Trumps), a multi-decade legacy of highly partisan politics, etc, etc.
It seems measuring the real-world impact of these tools and tactics is completely ignored in favour of believing we're living in some fantasy scifi world where bots and pseudosciencey psychological profiles can make anyone president.
Has anyone asked how much impact these tools have had on the sales of consumer products over the last decade? If they've hardly revolutionized online advertising of consumer products to make people buy products they didn't want (which AFAIK it hasn't), I highly highly doubt it played a huge role in the election of someone a portion of the voting populace didn't want.
- pas 9y agoIt's easy to start wildfires, that's what paid agitators do and likely did. The problem is - of course - millions of Americans were (and still are) very susceptible to particular kinds of bullshit. (InfoWars, religon, guns don't kill people, "gay agenda", anti-vaxxers, other new age fuckvoodoo, and so on.) Yes, it's probably unknowable how effective the russian bots were exactly.
- dmix 9y ago> Yes, it's probably unknowable how effective the russian bots were exactly. Possibly but I'd say it's a very safe bet the amount of outrage and blame being put on this foreign super villain boogieman with his infinitely powerful technology far far outweighs it's real world influence. Oh well, I'm sure it will be a boon for the tech industry the more people believe in this magical nonsense.