3 ms·
Asimov's Three Laws of Robotics are often remembered as being hard set rules, but Asimov more often than not used them as the precursors to murder mysteries. So
by WorldMaker 9y ago
Asimov's Three Laws of Robotics are often remembered as being hard set rules, but Asimov more often than not used them as the precursors to murder mysteries. So many of the best of his Three Laws stories are locked room murder mysteries where a robot finds some edge case that no one had yet considered. Especially, the entire concept of the Zeroth law is interesting because it was a loophole defined by robots, and the ethics of which are somewhat debated in the series, but most of that debate is left as an exercise to the reader so readers don't often do it. But even a lot of the very edge cases listed here are part of the meta-ethics debates across the Three Laws stories.
Whether or not the Three Laws are a viable system for AGI governance (and I agree it seems rather unlikely, at least in their simplest define forms most encountered in Asimov's stories, but even the stories would claim that the way they are written in English is not exactly how they are coded in positronic technology, however that may be), the ethics conflicts and edge case debates in the stories are very fascinating reads.
It is somewhat surprising to me how many people seem to think the laws are set in stone and don't realize how many of the stories themselves are secretly ethics debates about edge cases. Just because some of the characters believe the laws to be infallible doesn't mean those characters are right and the laws are infallible. There wouldn't be so many tales about the Three Laws if there weren't so many edge cases and exciting locked room mysteries to explore.