2 ms·
Professional Ethics often can't stop companies from being evil (that's for government regulations, sort of, mostly), but they can help individuals stand up agai
by WorldMaker 9y ago
Professional Ethics often can't stop companies from being evil (that's for government regulations, sort of, mostly), but they can help individuals stand up against such companies. Most such codes of ethics such as American Society of Civil Engineers Code of Ethics [0] or even the Association for Computing Machinery's Code of Ethics [1] are written to the individual first as a part of your relationship (membership) to the larger society.
Most of the actual effective power of such an organization in an ethics violation is to remove its relationship (membership) with an individual that breaks its code of ethics. In a field like Civil Engineering this has bite because few respectable, non-evil companies are willing to hire Civil Engineers that aren't members in good standing of the ASCE. When was the last time a software job interview asked if you were a member in good standing with the ACM? (Sigh, imagine if that saved you a bunch of time in that job interview, as a civil company wouldn't bother asking an ASCE member a laundry list of basic job knowledge.)
In terms of collective action, the professional society/association can help. If a civil engineer refuses to do a job, or whistleblows on a job in progress, due to it being a potential ethics violation the society (because it is not a union) cannot prevent that particular employer from firing the engineer, but it can: A) make sure that the firing is less of a black mark for other employers by making that information transparent and available to future possible employers, B) notify the remaining members at that company that they may be involved in an ethics violation which could result in loss of their society membership, C) notify potential candidates to that company that the company is involved in ethics violations. Sometimes that collective black list of "no respectable engineer will work for you" can be enough of a deterrent for a company to be less evil.
So Code of Ethics are a good step, if you have an association/society with some bite that would apply if they kicked you out as a member. They can sometimes leverage that collectively for overall good.
Organizations with further more bite are Unions, which can and do set contractual terms with employers that can force the company to adopt the Unions' ethics, and Governments, which can and do set regulations that are the closest we have to enforceable ethics terms on companies because Governments in the worst case have armies with which to enforces them.
Pulling it more specifically to your worries about surveillance, it seems to be almost directly addressed in ACM's Code of Ethics section 2.1. We've established that ACM doesn't have much bite in the tech sector, however, as employers mostly don't care about ACM membership. It would be interesting to see someone try to unionize software developers with a goal of promoting non-surveillance as a first principle, but software developers mostly don't seem to want to unionize because they see themselves as white collar and above such concerns as collective bargaining. (Despite many of Hollywood's unions being quite white collar and proving collective action can be essential, but I digress.) That mostly leaves government regulations. Data and Privacy are certainly things that governments could regulate, given they were shown a clear enough need, but also unlikely in certain political climates and by those that passionately are against regulations, even those designed to enforce ethics and protect privacy.
[0] http://www.asce.org/code-of-ethics/ http://www.asce.org/code-of-ethics/
[1] https://www.acm.org/about-acm/acm-code-of-ethics-and-professional-conduct https://www.acm.org/about-acm/acm-code-of-ethics-and-profess...
- mindslight 9y agoProfessional ethics only work to punish outliers, or at least what the industry wants to publicly consider outsiders. You can't reign in the "defense" industry by creating a code of ethics that discourages making offensive weaponry - it will simply be ignored by the relevant parties! Posit a new organization that "we all" decide to join and care about, say the Association for Personal Computing Machinery (APCM). It comes into existence, and then declares to Google, Faceboot, Amazon, Cisco, etc that they need to clean up or at least detail who is responsible for their organizations' unethical operations, or all of their employees are going to end up on the APCM shitlist. What happens next?
- WorldMaker 9y agoI described the power hierarchy in my post. If "we all" decided to care about the unethical behavior of Google, Facebook, Amazon, Cisco, et al, it's probably too late to join the ACM or your faux APCM as none of those employers care about industry ethics, won't listen to ethics authorities (at least on the issues in this thread), and aren't focused on hiring ethical employees (or at least, make no current recognition/requirement of existing professional societies such as the ACM). The next step is that "we all" must decide to join and care about the "Union of Software Workers". Only in collective bargaining might "we all" make a difference in the industry, only in the hard tools of work stoppages and shortages, the hard bargains of strong contracts, the forges of blood, sweat, and tears. History shows unionization often literally involves lots of sacrifices, it's definitely a lot of hard work and a lot of people would need to put their jobs and maybe their lives on the line for the cause. Of course that step is very hard, so the next most likely step is actually that enough smart people get voted into government that care about this stuff like "we all" do that maybe we can force some regulations on the industry. If "we all" care enough, we could certainly fight the good fight and try to send smart people to government or the hard work of unionization. In both of those cases, joining the ACM (or a purported APCM) might be a first step in organizing, as they've had multiple decades to start a Code of Ethics for which to build a union or government regulations around, but it's certainly not a sufficient step to solve industry problems at this point, in this current software industry culture that currently sees no value in professional societies, professional ethics, etc. As long as the software industry is infantilized with the concept of the amateur programmer, the rags to riches "taught myself to code and I need no professional training" story, the "we need to spend an 8 hour day interviewing every candidate on basic technical skills because we don't trust professionals to know the basics and also we want to be 'fair' to random people walking in from the street" attitudes, professional organizations like the ACM cannot have much power in the industry. (Which is it, software industry, are we a white collar job that can respect professional codes of ethics and answer to societies such as the ACM, or are we a blue collar job willing to interview anyone even remotely qualified off of the street, and it is way past time that we unionized? You seem to want it both ways here, Google, Facebook, Amazon, et al.)