3 ms·
> This is what the self-driving cars industry insists on, but has nowhere near been proven Because machines have orders of magnitude fewer failure modes than h
by naasking 9y ago
> This is what the self-driving cars industry insists on, but has nowhere near been proven
Because machines have orders of magnitude fewer failure modes than humans, but with greater efficiency. It's why so much human labour has been automated. There's little reason to think driving will be any different.
You can insist all you like that the existing evidence is under "ideal conditions", but a) that's how humans pass their driving tests too, and b) we've gone from self-driving vehicles being a gleam in someone's eye to actual self-driving vehicles on public roads in less than 10 years. Inclement weather won't take another 10 years.
It's like you're completely ignoring the clear evidence of rapid advancement just because you think it's a hard problem, while the experts actually building these systems expect fully automated transportation fleets within 15 years.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y agoYour comment is just random hopeful assertions though... >It's why so much human labour has been automated. But how much human labour that is as complicated as driving has been automated? As far as I can tell automation is very, very bad when it needs to interact with humans who may behave unexpectedly. >b) we've gone from self-driving vehicles being a gleam in someone's eye to actual self-driving vehicles on public roads in less than 10 years. Inclement weather won't take another 10 years. >It's like you're completely ignoring the clear evidence of rapid advancement just because you think it's a hard problem, while the experts actually building these systems expect fully automated transportation fleets within 15 years. Actually plenty of experts within the field disagree with you. “I tell adult audiences not to expect it in their lifetimes. And I say the same thing to students,” he says. “Merely dealing with lighting conditions, weather conditions, and traffic conditions is immensely complicated. The software requirements are extremely daunting. Nobody even has the ability to verify and validate the software. I estimate that the challenge of fully automated cars is 10 orders of magnitude more complicated than [fully automated] commercial aviation.” Steve Shladover, transportation researcher at the University of California, Berkeley http://www.automobilemag.com/news/the-hurdles-facing-autonomous-vehicles/ http://www.automobilemag.com/news/the-hurdles-facing-autonom... With autonomous cars, you see these videos from Google and Uber showing a car driving around, but people have not taken it past 80 percent. It's one of those problems where it's easy to get to the first 80 percent, but it's incredibly difficult to solve the last 20 percent. If you have a good GPS, nicely marked roads like in California, and nice weather without snow or rain, it's actually not that hard. But guess what? To solve the real problem, for you or me to buy a car that can drive autonomously from point A to point B—it's not even close. There are fundamental problems that need to be solved. Herman Herman, Director of the National Robotics Engineering Center @ CMU https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/d7y49y/robotics-lab-uber-gutted-says-driving-cars-are-not-even-close-carnegie-mellon-nrec https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/d7y49y/robotics-l...
- naasking 9y ago> But how much human labour that is as complicated as driving has been automated? Driving is not complicated at its core. Travel along vectors that intersect at well-defined angles. Stop to avoid obstacles whose vectors intersect with yours. Sometimes those obstacles will intersect with your vector faster than you can stop, which is probably what happened to this woman. As long as the autonomous car was following the prescribed laws, then it's not at fault, and a human definitely would not have been able to stop either. > Merely dealing with lighting conditions, weather conditions, and traffic conditions is immensely complicated. The software requirements are extremely daunting. Which is why self-driving cars don't depend on visual light, and why prototypes are being tested in regions without inclement weather. Being on HN, I'm sure you're well familiar with the product development cycle: start with the easiest problem that does something useful, then generalize as needed. > With autonomous cars, you see these videos from Google and Uber showing a car driving around, but people have not taken it past 80 percent. It's one of those problems where it's easy to get to the first 80 percent, but it's incredibly difficult to solve the last 20 percent. If you have a good GPS, nicely marked roads like in California, and nice weather without snow or rain, it's actually not that hard. Right, so the experts agree with me that the problem the pilot projects are addressing is readily solvable, and that general deployment will take a number of years of further research, but isn't beyond our reach. This past year I've already read about sensors that can peer through ice and snow. 15 years is not at all out of the question.
- rohit2412 9y agoDriving isn't just travel along a vector. Maybe trains, but not urban roads. urban roads are full of people and animals. If a ball bounces in front of me, I slow down expecting a dog or a child running after it. No self driving car now, and in 30 years is going to be able to infer that. Driving is essentially interacting with the environment, reading hand signals from people, understanding intent of pedestrians, bicycles and other drivers. No way any AI can do that now.
- naasking 9y ago> Driving isn't just travel along a vector. Maybe trains, but not urban roads. Trains travel along a straight line, not a vector in 2D space. > If a ball bounces in front of me, I slow down expecting a dog or a child running after it. No self driving car now, and in 30 years is going to be able to infer that. Incorrect. I don't know why you think humans are so special that they're the only system capable of inferring such correlations.
- username223 9y ago> It's why so much human labour has been automated. There's little reason to think driving will be any different. Repetitive, blunt, manual labor now, and probably much basic legal/administrative/medical work in the near future. But we still pay migrant workers to harvest fruit, and I don't imagine a robot jockey winning a horse race anytime soon. Driving a car under non-ideal conditions is incredibly complex, and relies upon human communication. For example: eye contact between a driver and pedestrian; one driver waving at another to go ahead; anticipating the behavior of an old lady in an Oldsmobile. Oh, the robots will be better drivers eventually, but it will be awhile. We humans currently manage about one death per hundred million miles; Uber made it all of two million. I expect we'll have level 5 self-driving cars about the same time we pass the Turing test.
- naasking 9y ago> But we still pay migrant workers to harvest fruit Harvesting fruit is far more complex than driving. It's a 3D search through a complex space. > Driving a car under non-ideal conditions is incredibly complex, and relies upon human communication. No it doesn't. The rules of the road detail precisely how cars interact with each other and with pedestrians. > We humans currently manage about one death per hundred million miles; Uber made it all of two million. Incorrect use of statistics.
- galdosdi 9y ago> Harvesting fruit is far more complex than driving. It's a 3D search through a complex space. Are you making a joke? "a 3D search [for a path that reaches the destination safely and legally] through complex space" is exactly how I would describe driving. (Also, driving is an online problem.)
- naasking 9y agoCars don't leave the road which is a 2D surface. In what way is that a 3D problem?
- deleted 9y ago