3 ms·
These are associations, not causal implications. "Lead kills" is a causal statement, and even "lead associated with X deaths" is a bit leading, and I think that
by epistasis 9y ago
These are associations, not causal implications. "Lead kills" is a causal statement, and even "lead associated with X deaths" is a bit leading, and I think that the authors were careful to not say that directly.
Given the experimental evidence mentioned in the introduction of the paper, it's likely that some or many of these deaths could be due to lead, but they could also be due to shared causes. There could be other things that lead to both greater lead exposure and greater cardiac death, for example.
One has to be very very careful with drawing conclusions from surveys such as this one. The standard in epidemiology is usually, association + one potential mechanism, but even with that it doesn't mean that the one potential mechanism is an explanation for all the observed association.