3 ms·
Hollywood's not a great example. Their centrality to the movie industry has been declining for decades. E.g.: https://www.thewrap.com/louisiana-california-movie
by wpietri 9y ago
Hollywood's not a great example. Their centrality to the movie industry has been declining for decades. E.g.: https://www.thewrap.com/louisiana-california-movie-making-capital-world-2013/ https://www.thewrap.com/louisiana-california-movie-making-ca...
Or an article from this year listing LA as the 3rd-best place, after Atlanta and Vancouver, for moviemakers to live: https://www.moviemaker.com/archives/best_of/best-places-to-live-and-work-as-a-moviemaker-2018-big-cities/ https://www.moviemaker.com/archives/best_of/best-places-to-l...
One important factor at work here is the Internet. Effects companies, for example, are all over the place, including London, New Zealand, Vancouver, LA, and even here in San Francisco. Big movies will often use multiple companies, something that would have been very challenging 30 years ago.
Silicon Valley does have capital and talent. But it's not like that capital is in doubloons in a vault. It's purely digital. A big reason it's not more mobile is that VCs wouldn't deign to stop in a flyover state. Talent isn't quite as mobile, but a) advances in technology mean talent is less necessary, and b) the rise in remote work means the location of talent is less and less meaningful.
- jrs95 9y agoThe talent is also considerably more expensive and not substantially better unless you need people in a specific niche. And if you really need talent from SF, you could always hire them on remotely.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoMuch of this is due to unfair tax credits in various areas. And instead of competing, the geniuses in Cal/LA have been raising taxes.
- majormajor 9y agoActually tax credits for staying local have been increasing, e.g. http://www.latimes.com/business/hollywood/la-fi-ct-amazon-sneaky-pete-tax-credit-20180319-story.html http://www.latimes.com/business/hollywood/la-fi-ct-amazon-sn... today
- mixmastamyk 9y agoNice, a new program. However the total tax burden is still high, e.g. there is a "freelancer" tax in Los Angeles with onerous reporting rules.
- sedachv 9y ago> However the total tax burden is still high, e.g. there is a "freelancer" tax in Los Angeles with onerous reporting rules. BS. The online form literally takes 5 minutes to fill out. "Creative artists" earning under $300,000 are exempt from paying city taxes, as are small businesses grossing under $100,000.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoYou have a strange idea of not high and onerous if you think taxes in LA are attracting work rather than repelling it, as the top of this thread explains clearly. Take 30 seconds to search and you can find stories of folks who got shafted for thousands because they didn't even know such a thing existed and needs to be reported early even if you do. The fact you most get an exemption is another example of big brother showing who's boss for no gain to the city.
- sedachv 9y ago> Take 30 seconds to search How about you stop being a libertarian keyboard jockey and actually try to get involved in running a business or two in Los Angeles, like I am doing? Everything you have posted is bullshit. My wife happens to be a "creative artist" who does a lot of work in the film industry here. She is also the type of person who did not do basic research into starting a business and did not bother to find out what taxes she was supposed to be paying. I don't know why you think that being an airhead is the city's fault. The fine was not "thousands of dollars," it came out to $80-something for two years of unreported city taxes. It was literally a letter and a couple of phone calls to settle that.
- 9y ago
- wpietri 9y agoWell, unfair is a matter of opinion. The concentration of moviemaking in Hollywood was a historical accident. From the point of view of present cities, there's no reason to see that as fair. They also aren't unfair in the sense that LA can't do exactly the same thing. The theory of places like Atlanta and Vancouver is that the film industry has positive externalities, so in theory there's nothing wrong with capturing some of that value and paying the people who create it. It's a free country, after all, and if LA isn't willing to bid as high, then perhaps the market has spoken. Personally I'm not a big fan of tax incentives, but unfair isn't a word I'd particularly use to describe them.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoUnfair in the sense of paying business to relocate, not that the folks in other places don't deserve it. Some of it has been tax "dumping" at below cost.