5 ms·
Peter Thiel Is Bullish on Bitcoin, the Heartland and Trump
- melling 9y agoThiel, like many people, doesn’t like Hillary. I think I heard him say something about “Trump still being better than Hillary “ Someone should distill out what his reasoning is. It might be China, American competiveness, ... I’m not sure. But he has the pulse on something that others believe. What are the policy changes that he wants?
- daxorid 9y ago[edit] Point made, I suppose.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Mononokay 9y agoI replied, although I might not be the exact perspective they're looking for.
- Mononokay 9y ago> Someone should distill out what his reasoning is. I'm not huge on Trump (primarily, I find him inefficient at policies, and too prone towards a privacy-second approach, and find most of his social views reprehensible), but I think to some extent it's understandable why some people think he was better than the alternative, especially when taking into consideration media bubbles. I took on an experiment during the elections of exposing myself solely to media supportive of different candidates, and it's quite odd how quickly a person can get into a mindset of comradery with almost all of the non-social conservative candidates. The media outlets that you're subjected to as a follower of a politician can easily sway you into being absolutely enamoured with a person. For example, pre-election day, /r/The_Donald was a fairly odd place. Not odd in that it was overly hostile and hypermacho, but in that it was very supportive of almost every type of supporter. If your main source of news was from that subreddit, for example, Trump was quite heroic sounding - they sliced his speeches to highlight a person of which loved all people, just hated the extent of how extreme the world was getting in regards to social justice. If your main source of news was from a more liberal outlet, the opposite happens - he's racist, homophobic, vitriolic and evil. Even if he does something they support, like advocating for guns to be taken away, he gets crucified. The supporters on the conservative side tended to see this, compare it to their own version of things, and consider that there's no winning with the liberal side. The liberal side, again, does the opposite. * * * With Hillary in particular, she had far from a clean record, and arguably a less clean one than Trump did at the time, and does currently politically.
- mpfundstein 9y agoGreat story. I can confirm much of your experiences and observations. I truly think /r/T_D and pepe/4chan will become a rich source for future studies. They truly took online media and mass manipulation to a next level.
- Mononokay 9y agoHis rallies were truly captivating, and it's amazing how efficient he was at getting audience-approval. I found myself, a person who very much disagrees with his views, rationalizing his views with him to an almost uncomfortable level.
- r00fus 9y agoPerhaps the 100% media saturation helped to legitimize his views? He got probably 4x the media mentions as any other candidate despite e.g. Bernie getting more people at almost all rallies. By captivating, do you include the calls to violence and dog-whistling?
- Mononokay 9y ago> Perhaps the 100% media saturation helped to legitimize his views? I'd say what helped him most were his speeches, no doubt. The media saturation was a side benefit. He had an absolutely captivating way of giving a speech. > By captivating, do you include the calls to violence and dog-whistling? I would like to clarify, here, that captivating and able-to-be-rationalized are not the same thing. Hitler's speeches were captivating beyond all doubt, but were not possible to rationalize. Trump's speeches were captivating, and occasionally easy to rationalize. Did you listen to any? There were very few, if any, calls to violence - dog whistling wasn't an overt thing from the speeches I observed, either. The vast majority of his speeches he focused upon two sole things - former prosperity, and regaining that prosperity. He directly mirrored Reagan's campaign, down to the slogan - "Make America Great Again." A typical outline of a Trump speech goes: [INTRODUCTION - He starts giving "I love you all!" kiss-ups.] [PLEA FOR THOUGHT - He gives the story of someone who serves as a conduit to gain sympathy for one of his causes, usually someone hurt by an undocumented immigrant, or a military member.] [EXCLAMATION OF SUPERIORITY - He combats the Republican candidate's talking point of the week, along with the leading Democratic candidate, whilst telling how he has a plan to do better. He does this very well, even if the argument itself doesn't hold up.] [EXCLAMATION OF PATRIOTISM - He begins going on about how he loves his country, and how it has potential to be wonderful again. Ironically, this was the most disillusioning part of his speeches for me.] [EXIT, I LOVE YOU ALL - He again tells the audience how wonderful they are, and how he's happy they support him. He then leaves in an occasionally bravado way.] * * * It's rather simple, but he perfected the formula very quickly.
- SamReidHughes 9y agoFor example, Trump is making the ACA fail hard and fast, instead of the slow drawn-out death it would have under Clinton. That's less stagnation, more turning over the rocks and letting the earthworms crawl out. And of course you've got basic stuff like court appointees, his are way better if you're conservative or libertarian.
- jgrowl 9y agoI can't remember the source, but I seem to recall an interview where a major point for Thiel was just the simple potential for disruption.
- zombieprocesses 9y agoConsidering that Trump owes his presidency to the midwest/rust belt, it doesn't take a genius to see that the heartland will see improving conditions going forward. Trump will almost certainly advance policies that will benefit the heartland as that's his only chance of winning in 2020.
- dragonwriter 9y agoYour argument assumes that Trump has both the knowledge to determine what policies would result in positive net change in the heartland and the power to get then in place. Even with the same party in control of Congress, President's don't always get what they want, and moreover politicians are quite often wrong in their assessment of what policies will produce the results they prefer. And that’s even before considering that politicians often have interests in policy other than reelection, and reelection is often secondary and instrumental to those signs rather than primary over them.
- saint_fiasco 9y agoThey don't have to be right in the assessment, they just have to make it look like they tried real hard and any failures are not their fault. For example steel tariffs are meant to benefit Trump voters (at the expense of the rest of the country). If it turns out they don't actually benefit Trump voters, he still gets points for being the only one willing to try. It's similar to the security theater that the government uses to fight terrorism. It doesn't matter if it doesn't work, because being seen trying and failing gives more points than not doing anything.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> They don't have to be right in the assessment They do to support the prediction that “it doesn't take a genius to see that the heartland will see improving conditions going forward”, based on Trump's political need for heartland votes. I agree with you that things don't actually have to get better for Trump to get votes if he can sell it as something else blocking his efforts, but that just further undermines the claim I was responding to.