8 ms·
Indeed what? It's obvious that slower cars will kill fewer people. That's meaningless without saying what the cost of driving slower is.
by mhb 9y ago
Indeed what? It's obvious that slower cars will kill fewer people. That's meaningless without saying what the cost of driving slower is.
- jessaustin 9y agoYou'll have to leave earlier for your important appointment!
- mhb 9y agoI suppose you're suggesting there's a distinction between someone losing x hours of life due to travel time vs. someone being killed and losing y hours of life. I'm sure you can see why someone attempting to create a reasonable policy might avoid making that distinction.
- jessaustin 9y agoI thought you were asking about "the cost of driving slower"? I'm perfectly serious in my answer. Any transportation goal (with the possible exception of ambulance service?) that may be accomplished at high speed, also can be accomplished at lower speed, with sufficient planning.
- mhb 9y agojerf addressed this above. What you're saying isn't accurate. Doing things more quickly avoids wasting hours of life. That's a benefit. The cost is measured in hours of life of people killed and injured as a result of doing things at a chosen speed.
- jessaustin 9y agoWhat activity are you talking about, that is feasible at 40mph in an urban environment but not at e.g. 25mph? Can you not imagine a different way of conducting that activity? There is a fundamental inequity between the operator of dangerous equipment comparing hours and years of life, and the pedestrian who suffers the consequence of that comparison. The USA auto industry is built on this inequity, which is why no one ever talks about it.
- mhb 9y agoAny activity which requires things to be moved. Meeting a friend, making a delivery, Lives, dollars, wasted time are all fungible. Your new, inequity point adds externalities to the discussion. That's fine, but those are also measured in lives, dollars, wasted time.
- jessaustin 9y agoMany people meet friends and make deliveries e.g. via bicycle. Those motorized vehicles that are set aside specifically for deliveries often travel more slowly than other motorized vehicles. But I shouldn't pick nits; you were speaking in generalities! So when I said "any transportation goal" and you disagreed, you hadn't actually thought of a particular exception to my universal statement. And you still haven't thought of one. Are your contributions to this discussion offered in good faith?
- mhb 9y ago1. I want to visit a friend. He lives an hour away by car. New speed limit changes it to two hours. I lose an hour of life in the car. 2. Auto plant needs radiators. Truck delivering them takes longer to get them there. Costs $x more. Car costs more. Car buyer has to work longer to buy car. Car buyer wastes y hours of life.
- jessaustin 9y agoI suppose this subthread is complete, because you have now completely agreed with my original statement: you'll have to leave earlier for your trip to visit your friend, and delivery trucks will have to allocate more time (routes, trucks, drivers, etc.) for their deliveries. Alternatively, freight trucks might make fewer mostly-empty trips. Note that these two examples clearly match the characterization I provided: both may be accomplished at lower speed, with sufficient planning. This will be the "cost" of safe driving.
- mhb 9y ago
- PurpleBoxDragon 9y ago>also can be accomplished at lower speed But what about an even lower speed? If 15 mph is good, then 5 mph is better. And if 5 mph is better, 1 mph is superior once more. I think we can agree there is a point where slow becomes too slow and the 'sufficient planning' becomes an unreasonable burden. So given we aren't operating off the notion that slower is inherently better, then there is some equation giving us our optimal point. What if that point is 45 mph instead of 15 mph? In short, how do we argue that 15 mph is better than 45 mph that can't also be applied to speeds lower than 15 mph?
- bobthepanda 9y agoIt's easy - you have diminishing improvements in pedestrian survival rates. 40MPH+ is associated with a fatality rate of over 50%, whereas you get to 30MPH and you have 7%, and 20MPH is essentially zero: https://nacto.org/docs/usdg/relationship_between_speed_risk_fatal_injury_pedestrians_and_car_occupants_richards.pdf https://nacto.org/docs/usdg/relationship_between_speed_risk_...
- PurpleBoxDragon 9y agoEven if it is close to zero, how do we decide if the lives saved from going from a .1% fatality rate to a .09% fatality rate is worth the speed reduction or not?
- TheSpiceIsLife 9y agoAnd not even necessarily that. Often speeding just gets you to the next intersection, or red lighter, quicker, where you then have to wait longer for traffic, or a green light.
- YSFEJ4SWJUVU6 9y agoHow often? How often you'd manage to go through the intersection before the lights change, and gain even more? (edit: just to be clear, I'm not in support of speeding, however I do value good logic.)
- smileysteve 9y agoI can't find it, but I remember reading that an aggressive driver saves on average 20 seconds on what is on average a 10 minute trip.
- bobthepanda 9y agoI'd like to think that the economic cost of regularly killing people on the streets is higher than getting to a place ten minutes faster. American traffic fatalities per year are basically equivalent to killing off a large town. No one is saying reduce speeds everywhere. But in an urban context with lots of pedestrians, these speeds matter, and urban traffic is generally so stop-and-go and congested that drivers rarely sustain the top speed, and reducing it doesn't actually affect travel time by all that much.
- mhb 9y agoRegardless of what you'd like to think, actual costs and benefits of driving speeds would make a more compelling argument.
- jerf 9y ago"I'd like to think that the economic cost of regularly killing people on the streets is higher than getting to a place ten minutes faster." However comforting that logic may be, it is unusable in the real world. If you value lives infinitely, then you will never ever do anything that risks your or somebody else's life in order to gain on any other need. You routinely engage in things that are not the safest possible option in order to fulfill other needs, ranging from food or water acquisition through mere entertainment. Therefore you place a finite value on your life. Don't feel bad, so does everybody else. It is possible to determine the value placed on life, I believe there are studies that show the value is more stable than you might think, and balance things appropriately. It may be uncomfortable thinking, but, again, unless you literally never take even the smallest risk in the pursuit of other goals, you are already thinking this way. You just haven't lifted it up to the conscious level yet.
- jessaustin 9y agoNo one is asking for infinite value. A cursory glance at causes of death rates in USA reveals that far too many people are dying in automobile collisions. There is nothing about our world that requires that level of carnage. Future generations will find our customs ghastly.
- rocqua 9y agoThe real issue with driving slower is enforcement. Enough people don't take into account the speed limit that changing the speed limit without changing the roads leads to unsafe mixed speeds. Universally adhered to lower speed limits in urban environments would be great.
- rikkus 9y agoCorrect. I often walk down a road with a 20mph 'limit' where most cars are doing around 40 - and some appear to be doing more like 50. There's simply no economically viable way to enforce it, so it will continue like this until there have been a couple of fatalities.
- mhb 9y agoThere's simply no economically viable way to enforce it Conduent offers a turnkey solution for this. They provide and manage speed cameras: https://www.conduent.com/solution/transportation-solutions/road-safety/ https://www.conduent.com/solution/transportation-solutions/r...
- jakeogh 9y agoNot a chance. And that is a good thing. This knee jerk towards "lets just monitor everyone, everywhere and automate the law" is antithetical to a free society. Most people know that, which is why speed camera votes always send that company (RedFlex or whoever) packing.
- j3097736 9y agoI don't know about the US, but where I live speed camera are relatively large bright colored boxes with reflective stripes on the side of the road, with mandatory "speed camera ahead" warnings. Most of them are empty but people unfamliar with the place will usually slow down.
- jakeogh 9y ago
- megy 9y agoWhat cost do you put on your own life? Lets start from there?