6 ms·
Two of three bank sites I log into regularly are limited to 8 alphanumeric characters, I'm frankly unsure if they even distinguish letter case. It's probably t
by tracker1 9y ago
Two of three bank sites I log into regularly are limited to 8 alphanumeric characters, I'm frankly unsure if they even distinguish letter case.
It's probably time to start holding these sites accountable, however anything that could be proposed as regulation by the gov't on this would be a clusterfuck in implementation details, so I have bad feelings all around. I agree that there should be "unlimited" or reasonably limited (64-256 character limit) in input, since hashing will take care of the rest. Personally, I'd love to be able to use pass-phrases, ie, "Because, cookies are awesome!" ... Most of my "really" secure passphrases are like that (password manager, authy, etc).
- vorpalhex 9y agoSome DBMS' do require a limit... eventually. I think 256 is a reasonable bound, since that allows very generous pass phrases. And actually, the NIST password recommendations are very reasonable, at least currently.
- nokcha 9y agoBut you shouldn't be storing a raw, unhashed password in the database anyway.
- Someone1234 9y agoThe current NIST requirements almost read like someone at NIST read the famous XKCD[0] and decided to implement it. Likely the best standard we've ever had in its reasonableness. [0] https://xkcd.com/936/ https://xkcd.com/936/
- maxk42 9y agoYou failed the test. Back to Security 101 with you! The point being made is that all passwords should be hashed and a hash is going to be fixed-length. Therefore there should be no limit on password length beyond, say the limit of the total HTTP POST size -- but you're not using a megabyte-long password, are you?
- GauntletWizard 9y agoI use The Complete Works of William Shakespeare, Unabridged as my password to several sites. How could you get more secure?
- 0xfeba 9y agoUnix or windows line endings?
- Sohcahtoa82 9y agoI mix them up using a CSPRNG to flip a coin.
- amw 9y agoI replace all line-endings with "Bee Movie" as binary in avi format.
- Sohcahtoa82 9y agoAnd every time someone says "Bee", it's replaced with "We Are Number One"
- lmm 9y agoWhat meaningful distinction are you drawing between a 1mb limit and a 256 character limit?
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- sli 9y agoThey aren't. They're just referring the the POST request size limit (which isn't hard set at one megabyte, but that's not their point, either).
- layoric 9y agoOnly the hash should be stored so limit of the original password is mute
- excitom 9y agoPedantic comment: The word is "moot"
- oasisbob 9y agoAre your banking sites smaller? (Eg, credit union) One core financial stack I know of stores home banking passwords unencrypted. They transcode ASCII -> EBCDIC to obscure the password and call it a day.
- navidfarhadi 9y agoI can confirm this. Wells Fargo, a very popular bank in the US, limits passwords to 6 to 14 characters. In fact, your passwords are not even case sensitive. This is absolutely unacceptable in 2018. I no longer have any bank accounts with Wells Fargo. In fact I don't have any bank accounts with any of these banks that have these stupid password restrictions.
- MichaelGG 9y agoComments like these come up on bank security all the time. Now the bank isn't completely retarded. They have to deal with customer support (at a minimum) when hacked. How many people are being hacked due to 14 char limit? Probably zero, relative to malware and phishing. You're only allowed a few guesses before the account locks. So I fail to see how case sensitivity is relevant. Not defending these limits but to imply they have a very strong predictive power on bank security is probably wrong.
- ttsda 9y agoYou're assuming their database doesn't leak and that account lock becomes irrelevant. Some banks are probably even storing passwords in plain-text or very old hashing methods that are not very effective in 2018.
- mackey 9y agoI almost didn't believe you because their own password page says to use mix case, but I just tried it... and flipping case totally works. Crazy!
- exikyut 9y agoWow, that's quite a dark pattern.
- soneil 9y agore: case insensitive .. I've heard of a bank with a similar problem, I don't recall which, where the reason was legacy compatibility with touch-tone phones. The password was normalized to something you could key in on a phone. This isn't an excuse, just a poorly-remembered anecdote as to how backwards some of these systems are.
- antoncohen 9y agoSadly, if the limit is 8 characters, they might be using something like the original DES provided by crypt()[1], it silently truncated to 8 characters. Or they may have moved on to something newer by now on the backend, but have the 8 character limit hardcoded in a bunch of places. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypt_(C)#Traditional_DES-based_scheme https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypt_(C)#Traditional_DES-base...
- developer2 9y agoTangerine (Canadian bank) only offers a choice between exactly a 4-digit or 6-digit password. These are numeric digits, not alpha-numeric. Yes, this is for online and telephone banking, not just one's debit card PIN - though I'm sure most people use the same 4-digit code for both. These may as well be stored as plaintext. What would be the point of hashing when you're dealing with a mere 10,000 permutations for 4-digit passwords (or 1,000,000 for 6-digit)?