2 ms·
Assuming that the world exists roughly as we understand it and is coherent and rational, evidence reflects the state of the world. There cannot be strong eviden
by geofft 9y ago
Assuming that the world exists roughly as we understand it and is coherent and rational, evidence reflects the state of the world. There cannot be strong evidence both for and against something, because all evidence is derived from the same, single, truthful state of the universe. You're misinterpreting one (or both!) pieces of evidence - maybe they're actually weak pieces of evidence, or you're mistaken about one (or both) of them.
The idea that the world is inexplicable by evidence and you must make irrational choices to satisfy your own desire for an explanation is contrary to both science and religion.
This is all before you get to Bayes - this is just about understanding the nature of the world and the nature of evidence and experience.
- BeenAround 9y ago> There cannot be strong evidence both for and against something, Of course there can be. Multiple cases exist. Light as a particle and light as a wave.
- geofft 9y agoThat's a great example of misinterpreting evidence—to see the evidence that light is a particle as strong evidence that it's not a wave, or vice versa, would be a misinterpretation of the evidence based on the incorrect assumption that it can't be both. There is a single, coherent thing that light is, which produces the evidence we see. Some of that evidence is consistent with being just a wave, some is consistent with being just a particle, and yes, it's also strong evidence that it's not just a particle and not just a wave. We don't know all the details yet; "both a wave and a particle" is a pretty good approximation given our current level of knowledge, as is "sometimes a wave and sometimes a particle." But picking the description "It's either just a wave or just a particle depending on how you feel about it, and there's no evidence that will help us because the evidence is contradictory" is wildly wrong and unscientific.