4 ms·
Unlike most people, I am not against mega rich in general, or asume, that they are all evil. But what just came to my mind with this sentence: ".. and Henry Fo
by hutzlibu 9y ago
Unlike most people, I am not against mega rich in general, or asume, that they are all evil. But what just came to my mind with this sentence:
".. and Henry Ford ruthlessly made fortunes and then established foundations to enlighten the masses and ensure world peace long after their death. "
... is how it is meant regarding Ford. Enlightening the masses about the jews evil conspiracy and ensuring world peace by helping nazi domination?
- dantheman 9y agoFord may have had bad political views, but the Ford foundation has had a huge effect on the world, especially during the cold war. https://www.fordfoundation.org/ https://www.fordfoundation.org/
- sametmax 9y agoThat's how people end up seeing the victors. No matter what they do. Take Bill Gates. 20 years ago he was evil incarnate, his company caught in lying, cheating, corrupting. Now his PR team made sure he is regarded as one of the good ones. For the last few years, you saw post in HN, reddit, imgurs, all singing the goodness of his heart. And then comments followed. No matter how many article you had decades ago stating all the wrong MS did, it's all water under the bridge. No ones remember. Clean slate. Now people are even saying that Bush Jr. was "not so bad". In 10 years, people will say Trump was ok.
- DennisP 9y agoPartly Bill's PR team. Mostly the fact that he's committed most of his billions to helping the poor and healing the sick.
- bromuro 9y agoYeah how many of those billions are part of that economy that is actually causing the harm (wars, famine, poverty, etc) that they are then proud to “fight”? c’mon how can people believe in such narrative? like the new one with Elon Musk... it is impossible even to try criticize them. Their hypocrisy is too smart and too well organized to be fought.
- hutzlibu 9y ago"Their hypocrisy is too smart and too well organized to be fought." Especially when we all are also part of the economy and therefore by your logic also responsible for every war and famime etc. So it is our hypocrisy as well. But related: you know, that there have been wars and famine and poverty since the beginning of humanity(and before) ?
- sametmax 9y agoWell, I don't pretend to be an angel, but I haven't corrupted officials (https://www.forbes.com/sites/alexandrawrage/2013/03/20/microsoft-whistleblower-allegations-highlight-global-corruption-risks/#4d3f117c2599 https://www.forbes.com/sites/alexandrawrage/2013/03/20/micro...), bribed (http://www.tomshardware.fr/articles/pots-de-vin-microsoft,1-45570.html http://www.tomshardware.fr/articles/pots-de-vin-microsoft,1-...), or aided dictators (https://www.salon.com/2011/09/06/wikileaks_microsoft_tunisia https://www.salon.com/2011/09/06/wikileaks_microsoft_tunisia). But I guess it's ok, if you fight Malaria.
- hutzlibu 9y agoHm, I guess it is hard to do much in a state where bribery is the norm, without doing it by yourself. And aiding a dictator sounds bad, but when "aiding" simply means doing business with him, then you can blame allmost the whole world. As we all are buying things that were at least partly made in dictatorships. And what is the alternative? Not doing business with states who have not our perfectly nice democratic governments? And don't get me wrong, I don't like Microsoft for making exclusive deals with any governments to strenghten their monopoly, but "evil" is something different. Like what I came across yesterday again, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/My_Lai_Massacre https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/My_Lai_Massacre and the fact, that there was a public outrage in the US, for convincting one of the murderers. And not so much about the massacre or the cover up itself. And that this does not seem to have changed fundamentaly regarding the ongoing drone war, imprisoning innocent people for years in Guantanamo, torturing, massacring etc. etc. So blaming only the rich seems hypocrite to me, when the very normal base of the people don't think or act that nice by themself. As far as I know over 70% consider Snowden to be a traitor ... so what can you expect?
- sametmax 9y agoIt's also called buying a stairway to heaven, depending on the point of view.
- dsacco 9y agoLet's assume I agree with you about how bad Microsoft's hegemony was. What exactly is the problem with "buying a stairway to heaven?" If you're actually doing good work, how is this criticism not just a vacuous attack?
- sametmax 9y agoFair point. I'm just annoyed that the rest is forgiven because of it.
- hutzlibu 9y ago"Take Bill Gates. 20 years ago he was evil incarnate, his company caught in lying, cheating, corrupting. Now his PR team made sure he is regarded as one of the good ones. " Well, I never considered him to be the evil incarnate, even though I am for free software as long as I can remember. But yes, the hatdred towards him has declined. But I think it might also have to do with him stepping a bit away from Microsoft and focusing more on his foundation (even though I don't believe, that his foundation is really doing so good). And Microsoft in general being not that important anymore.
- petra 9y ago>> even though I don't believe, that his foundation is really doing so good Why?
- hutzlibu 9y agoWelly their fight against Malaria and Polio is probably good. (even though I have certain doubts about some things) But the other things, like helping with Computers means helping establishing Microsoft Monopoly. And supporting heavily chemicalized monoculture farming, as a means to end hunger, I am very sceptical as a means to sustainable provide food production.
- eeZah7Ux 9y agoIt's a really sad reflection on how easy it is to manipulate people with PR. It sends a toxic message: be a ruthless businessman today, and, if you succeed, donate money you don't need before dying and people will call you a saint.
- csallen 9y agoThis is largely explained by all sorts of human biases. We overweigh the present moment and blow things out of proportion. In other words, we're always going to overreact to how "evil" our least favorite figures are in the present. But with the benefit of hindsight, we'll do a more rational job evaluating them. I'm a liberal voter, but I found the liberal reaction to Trump's election to be extreme. People thought it was the end of the free world and progress as we know it. Someone I knew spent a large sum of money on a bomb shelter. When your assessment is that low, is there really anywhere to go but up in the future?
- apatters 9y agoBill was certainly a ruthless businessman whose tactics caused all kinds of frustration for corporate IT departments and even stymied the development of the web for a few years. But in hindsight that all seems a lot less evil to me than what today's giants are doing: vacuuming up our personal lives and delivering them to the NSA, cultivating addiction and depression in children to increase ad views, etc. 1990s/2000s Microsoft seems saintly to me by comparison.
- dsacco 9y ago> Take Bill Gates. 20 years ago he was evil incarnate, his company caught in lying, cheating, corrupting. You have to know this level of hyperbole is baiting Godwin’s Law... I’ll come right out and say it: I never thought Microsoft’s activity was that bad, and I never really understood the ire that Bill Gates received. I agree it was worth antitrust action, but the way people talked about him and the company has always struck me as self-righteous and hollow. There were just so many worse people and things that it seemed silly in my opinion, and sort of lacking in awareness about the broader context of the country or even the world. In fact I would go so far as to say people carrying on about him like this made it more difficult to take Microsoft’s anti-competitive behavior seriously because it stifled honest conversation. If Gates is anything remotely close to “evil incarnate”, then what adjective would you use to describe, I don’t know, Kim Jong Un? Do you see why it’s hard to take your point seriously when your proclamation is that over the top? How can we communicate in good faith if that’s where you’re starting from? People diminutize the fact that Gates has spent billions of dollars of his own wealth both leading initiatives and helping others along for inarguable good in the world by calling it “PR” - if that’s PR, what isn’t? How can we reasonably and rationally discuss the legitimately impressive humanitarian achievements of the Gates Foundation or Microsoft without you just dismissing it as the machinations of someone hellbent on a quest for power? What satisfies your bar for altruism?! Listening to descriptions of the man, you’d think he was literally burning puppies and kittens alive in the early days of Microsoft while blasting The Imperial March, like some kind of macabre cartoon villain. Have some perspective. It was an internet browser.
- hutzlibu 9y ago"Have some perspective. It was an internet browser" ... a bit more than that. But also not "literally burning puppies and kittens alive in the early days of Microsoft while blasting The Imperial March" ...
- dsacco 9y agoI agree, it was more than just Internet Explorer. But it was far closer to being just Internet Explorer than it was to Bill Gates being "evil incarnate", for any reasonable definition of that term. The latter isn't even a visible destination from a perspective grounded in reality. More to the point, when people talk about Gates like this, it's both dismissive of his very legitimate philanthropic accomplishments and stifling to any well-reasoned, neutral conversation we could have about Microsoft's legitimate failings. Let's put aside the silliness of dismissing actual philanthropy by complaining that it puts people in a positive light. If I take the parent commenter's thesis at face value, then Bill Gates' philanthropy is a public relations conspiracy designed to get people to forget "how bad he was" in his Microsoft years. Frankly, I can only hope more CEOs become so publicly vilified for anti-competitive practices that they decide they need to start foundations to spend billions of dollars reducing various life threatening diseases by double digit percentages. So yes, you could say I'm willing to look the other way, or at least more fondly, when it comes to Bill's Microsoft years. If his public relations strategy is to make himself look good by doing good, then I don't have anything to complain about. What are we supposed to do, nod to each other and say, "Yes, but let's not forget about how evil his company was in the 80s and 90s..." in a somber tone every time his philanthropic works comes up? It's ridiculous. And most of the vocal proponents of this idea are intellectually insulting, with passive aggressive remarks that accuse people of being shills in a web of lies.
- madaxe_again 9y agoFord also successfully sued the US government following the Second World War for bombing their factories - in Nazi Germany - which also used slave labour from concentration camps. https://www.quora.com/Did-Ford-sue-the-US-government-for-bombing-its-factories-in-Germany-during-WWII https://www.quora.com/Did-Ford-sue-the-US-government-for-bom...
- pjc50 9y agoExtraordinary claim, which isn't quite borne out by the Quora answer. And there's a lot of weirdness in there, including the obviously lunatic claim "The U.S. (et al.) effectively built and maintained the Nazi war machine for the entirety of World War 2."
- madaxe_again 9y agoIt’s hardly lunatic - Nazi germany was in no small part financed by American banks and corporations through German corporations such as Thyssen/Krupps - see Brown Brothers Harriman’s involvement, for example. WWII was a wildly profitable enterprise. Re: slave labour, see: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/1445822/Ford-used-slave-labour-in-Nazi-German-plants.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/northamerica/usa/... BBH: https://www.google.com.uy/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/world/2004/sep/25/usa.secondworldwar https://www.google.com.uy/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/world/20... More on Ford: https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/daily/nov98/nazicars30.htm https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/national/daily/nov98/n...
- pjc50 9y agoOK, I'm now convinced on the Ford slave labour question. And the rather extraordinary "General Motors, which was paid $32 million by the U.S. government for damages sustained to its German plants." from the WaPo link. It really does seem that money is stronger than blood when it comes to war. The quora answer I was calling questionable was https://www.quora.com/Did-Ford-sue-the-US-government-for-bombing-its-factories-in-Germany-during-WWII/answer/Dumaya-Paruqa https://www.quora.com/Did-Ford-sue-the-US-government-for-bom... which is very different - while it seems that there were Americans illegally collaborating, that's a very different claim to the US supporting Nazi Germany.